Despite the "appreciation" of the Tehran Friday prayer leader for Iran's nuclear negotiation team, the Friday prayer leader of Mashhad described the Vienna nuclear agreement as a "crossing and violation" of the Supreme Leader's red lines and urged members of parliament to pay "special attention to their religious responsibility" when reviewing it. According to Fars and Mehr news agencies, Ahmad Alam al-Huda, the Friday prayer leader of Mashhad, also asked Iranian parliamentarians that if they wish to approve the Vienna nuclear agreement, they should "think about their afterlife." Alam al-Huda stated: "Although the principles of leadership have been violated in this agreement, if representatives conclude that rejecting this agreement would incur high costs for the country... they must be accountable for every decision they make." This comes as Mohammad Imami Kashani, the Tehran Friday prayer leader, praised the "scientific logic, prudence, and calmness" of Iran's nuclear negotiation team, stating that they have courageously accomplished something that the people and the Supreme Leader "support." The differing positions of the Friday prayer leaders regarding the Vienna nuclear agreement occur while reports indicate that the Iranian Ministry of Culture has requested media outlets to refrain from "implying a duality" in the positions of "high-ranking officials" of the Islamic Republic regarding the Vienna agreement, based on the resolutions of the Supreme National Security Council. Meanwhile, the Iranian Press Supervisory Board on Tuesday, August 12, suspended the weekly 9 Dey, managed by Hamid Rasai, a member of parliament from Tehran, and referred its case to court for "reviewing the performance" of media regarding the nuclear negotiations between Iran and the 1+5 group. However, Seyyed Hashem Hosseini Bushehri, the Friday prayer leader of Qom, called for a "fair criticism of the agreement" to remain open, as everyone believes that this agreement has strengths and weaknesses. He also emphasized that this agreement is "not the end of the matter and has multiple stages." According to a law titled "Obligation of the Government to Preserve Nuclear Achievements and Rights," which was approved by the Iranian parliament and ratified by the Guardian Council on Wednesday, July 3, the "results of negotiations" regarding Iran's nuclear program "must be presented to the parliament for compliance with the constitution and legal resolutions." However, some government officials, including Mohammad Baqer Nobakht, the government spokesman, and some members of parliament have emphasized that the parliament "is not supposed to vote" on the Vienna nuclear agreement. Meanwhile, Ali Larijani, the Speaker of the Parliament, stated that "perhaps" it would be better if the parliament "gives its opinion" on this agreement, but in some important "international treaties," such as the acceptance of UN Resolution 598, which led to the end of the Iran-Iraq war, "it did not give an opinion." Nevertheless, some parliament members, like Ahmad Tavakoli, have insisted that this agreement must be approved by the parliament unless the Supreme Leader refers this case to another institution.
Alam al-Huda Describes Nuclear Agreement as Crossing the Supreme Leader's Red Line
Ahmad Alam al-Huda, the Friday prayer leader of Mashhad, criticized the Vienna nuclear agreement as a violation of the Supreme Leader's red lines and urged parliament members to consider their religious responsibilities. This reflects a division among Iranian clerics regarding the agreement, with some supporting it while others call for caution. The debate highlights the complexities of Iran's political landscape regarding nuclear negotiations.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Ahmad Alam al-Huda criticized the Vienna nuclear agreement as a violation of the Supreme Leader's red lines, urging parliament members to consider their religious responsibilities. This reflects a division among Iranian clerics regarding the agreement's implications.
- Alam al-Huda's remarks indicate significant opposition within the clerical establishment to the nuclear agreement.
- There is a call for parliament to review the agreement despite some officials suggesting it does not require a parliamentary vote.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's nuclear program has been a contentious issue, with negotiations aimed at limiting its nuclear capabilities in exchange for sanctions relief. The Supreme Leader's red lines are critical in shaping Iran's approach to these negotiations.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%