After the government's unsuccessful attempt to separate the commerce sector from the industry, mining, and trade sector, and sending a bill to the parliament to keep Seyed Reza Fatemi Amin at the head of the 'Ministry of Industry, Mine, and Trade' and his subsequent dismissal, the Research Center of the Parliament has now announced its complete opposition to the 'formation of the Ministry of Commerce,' declaring it contrary to the Constitution. In a detailed report made public this week, one of the challenges identified by this center as a 'threat' is the historically import-oriented view of commerce, and it has been pointed out that the establishment of a Ministry of Commerce will lead to an increase in 'unnecessary intermediaries' in the economy, ultimately resulting in higher prices for goods. Documents received by VOA indicate the depth of this concern from the Research Center of the Parliament, as these documents show that during Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's government, imports became a tool for rent-seeking in the Ministry of Commerce, with the Persepolis and Esteghlal football clubs, represented by Mohammad Royanian, the then CEO of Persepolis, signing a memorandum for the import of essential goods with the then Deputy of Internal Trade. Accordingly, the 'Consumer Cooperative of IRIB' also sought 'import applicants for chicken' in a letter. Reza Ghaibi, a journalist and former advisor to the Deputy Minister of 'Industry, Mine, and Trade' and the public relations manager of the country’s market regulation in 2013, told VOA that the most important tool of the Ministry of Commerce at that time was imports, with 'over 260 companies participating in meat imports.' Ghaibi emphasized that 'the establishment of the Ministry of Commerce will lead to the distribution of currency rents,' noting that many of these companies were subsidiaries of state institutions, while the rest were 'affiliated with individuals close to the power circle.' He explained the reasons for the multitude of companies and the attractiveness of imports by stating: 'At that time, government currency was allocated for this purpose, and a significant number of these companies either spent the received currency in other sectors or sold the imported goods at the free dollar rate.' Ghaibi highlighted the corruption surrounding imports, mentioning that 'a flower shop in Niloufar Square and Bank Eqtesad Novin had also joined the ranks of importers.' The report from the Research Center of the Parliament also referred to the intensification of price controls, stating that this form of policy-making for market regulation would lead the country into a destructive cycle of production and exacerbating inflation and crisis. According to Ghaibi, decisions in the market regulation headquarters during the years of the Ministry of Commerce were made with minimal review in a one-hour meeting, with 'representatives of other agencies acting as spectators.' The Research Center of the Parliament emphasized that after the establishment of the 'Ministry of Commerce,' agencies would suffer from a dispersion of duties, which would create significant costs for their compatibility with the new structure. According to this center's report, these issues are part of the evidence showing that the Ministry of Commerce disrupts the administrative affairs of the country's food security and that its establishment is 'contrary to the principles of a proper administrative system emphasized in higher-level documents.' The report refers to Article 10 of Principle 3 of the Constitution, which calls for the establishment of a proper administrative system and the elimination of unnecessary organizations, as well as Articles 10 and 12 of the general policies of the administrative system, which advocate for streamlining, adapting, and rationalizing the administrative structure while focusing on effectiveness and efficiency in administrative processes and methods, and Article 16 of the general policies of the resistance economy, which calls for rationalizing the size of the government and eliminating parallel and unnecessary agencies and excess costs. It is noteworthy that the thirteenth government presented a bill consisting of a single article and six notes titled 'Bill for the Establishment of the Ministry of Commerce' to the Islamic Consultative Assembly, which was approved in a session on May 1 of this year. Previously, Ebrahim Raisi's government attempted to establish a 'Commerce Organization' under the presidency instead of a ministry, which was halted due to initial opposition from the parliament. The parliament voted for the 'urgency' of establishing the Ministry of Commerce.
A Former Iranian Commerce Ministry Official to VOA: The Return of This Ministry Means Distribution of Currency Rents
The Iranian parliament's Research Center has opposed the establishment of a Ministry of Commerce, citing concerns over increased economic intermediaries and historical rent-seeking practices. Former officials warn that this move could exacerbate corruption and inflation. The government's push for this ministry reflects ongoing tensions between the executive and legislative branches.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The Iranian parliament's Research Center has opposed the establishment of a Ministry of Commerce, citing concerns over increased economic intermediaries and historical rent-seeking practices. Former officials warn that this move could exacerbate corruption and inflation.
- The Research Center claims that a Ministry of Commerce would lead to higher prices and inefficiencies.
- The parliament had previously voted for the urgency of establishing the Ministry of Commerce despite opposition.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's economy has historically been characterized by state control and corruption, particularly in import sectors. The establishment of a Ministry of Commerce raises concerns about the potential for increased inefficiencies and corruption.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%