Ali Motahari, a member of the Islamic Consultative Assembly, announced in an interview with the Tehran-based newspaper "Etemad" that a military agency is cooperating with the Guardian Council to assess the qualifications of electoral candidates. In this interview, published on Tuesday, January 3, he pointed out that "the Guardian Council, according to the law, does not have oversight over the Parliament" and its function is solely "to oversee elections." He stated that in addition to this responsibility, the Council "keeps records of the behavior and statements of representatives for future elections, and in this regard, information from one of the military agencies assists him." He did not mention the name of this military agency, but in recent years, political and civil activists have expressed concern about the increasing role of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and its intelligence branch in fabricating cases against electoral candidates. Motahari stated that the Parliament, according to the law, oversees the behavior of its representatives. According to Article 99 of the Iranian Constitution, the Guardian Council is responsible for overseeing all elections except for council elections, and based on the interpretation provided by this Council of this article, this oversight is "discretionary and includes all executive stages of elections, including the approval and rejection of candidates' qualifications." The Guardian Council has disqualified thousands of candidates in each parliamentary election and has stated that in addition to inquiries from agencies such as the Ministry of Intelligence, the judiciary, and the police, it conducts local investigations about candidates. Some government officials and political analysts have called this action of the Guardian Council "illegal" and believe that this Council does not have the right to conduct local investigations about candidates according to the laws. Based on a resolution passed by the Expediency Discernment Council in 1999, the bodies responsible for assessing the qualifications of electoral candidates "are obliged to examine the qualifications of candidates solely based on legal provisions and based on valid reasons and documents sent by legally responsible centers to executive and supervisory bodies," and if they reject a candidate's qualifications, "they must inform the candidate of the reason for the disqualification." However, many candidates who were disqualified in previous elections have stated that they were not informed of the reasons for their disqualification, and only the legal provisions under which they were disqualified were communicated to them. Meanwhile, Nejatiollah Ebrahimi, a legal member of the Guardian Council, stated on December 12 this year that oversight of elections is only "active" during the elections, and according to the Constitution, oversight of members of Parliament is not the responsibility of the Guardian Council. The issuance of "general election policies" by the Supreme Leader of the Islamic Republic, emphasizing "preventing financial, economic, and moral abuses and taking necessary actions in case of the loss or discovery of the lack of representation conditions in elected officials," has led to the spokesperson of the Guardian Council stating that from now on, the Council's "oversight" over members of Parliament will be "continuous" and will continue even after the approval of credentials. Ahmad Jannati, the Secretary of the Guardian Council, also emphasized that "oversight over representatives should not be ceremonial" and expressed hope that with the implementation of "general election policies," there would be "better" oversight over members of Parliament. However, Abbasali Kadkhodai, the spokesperson for the Guardian Council, on November 26, denied statements attributed to him regarding the Council's oversight over representatives during their term and announced that the "authority" for oversight over representatives in the "general election policies" has not been specified and must be legislated. In this context, Kadkhodai stated: According to the Supreme Leader's directive, the Guardian Council's oversight over representatives will become continuous. The Deputy Speaker of Parliament stated that oversight over representatives' statements is not compatible with constitutional principles. Kadkhodai reiterated that the authority for oversight over representatives has not been specified in the law. Motahari again criticized the proposal for the Guardian Council's oversight over Parliament representatives. Kadkhodai reiterated that the Guardian Council's opinion is until the approval of representatives' credentials. The ongoing disagreement between the Guardian Council and the Parliament over the disqualification of candidates continues. Kadkhodai mentioned the "possibility of amending the election law" before the 2024 elections.
Ali Motahari Reports on Military Agency's Intelligence Cooperation with Guardian Council
Ali Motahari revealed that a military agency is assisting the Guardian Council in evaluating electoral candidates, raising concerns about the legality and transparency of candidate disqualifications in Iran. This situation highlights ongoing tensions between the Guardian Council and the Parliament regarding oversight and candidate qualifications.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Ali Motahari revealed that a military agency is assisting the Guardian Council in evaluating electoral candidates, raising concerns about the legality and transparency of candidate disqualifications in Iran.
- The Guardian Council is reportedly using military intelligence to assess candidates.
- There is controversy over the legality of this practice and its impact on electoral fairness.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The Guardian Council has a history of disqualifying candidates, often leading to accusations of bias and lack of transparency.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%