In the first part, the demands and expectations of the leaders of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries from the United States were discussed, focusing on strengthening military-security cooperation and selling more effective weapons to Arab countries. Here, we continue the discussion on the dimensions of the military dependency of the GCC countries on the United States and the roots of security threats in the region. Military Dependency on the United States The leaders of the GCC countries, especially King Salman, are not pleased with Obama's policies but face a complicated defensive situation. Although these countries have taken significant steps to strengthen their military capabilities and wish to oversee their own defense affairs, they are currently completely dependent on the United States for their security, and this dependency will continue for years. So far, these countries' efforts to find reliable military allies in the region, such as Egypt or Pakistan, have not yielded satisfactory results. Decades of military cooperation and various arms contracts, along with billions of dollars spent on weapons and equipment, have deeply tied the GCC countries to the United States and, to a significant extent, to Britain and France, making it difficult to break this dependency in the short term. The largest U.S. airbase in the Middle East, Al Udeid Air Base, is located in Qatar. Another important U.S. base in the Gulf countries is Al Dhafra Air Base in the UAE, and Bahrain hosts the official base of the U.S. Fifth Fleet. Britain also established a naval base in Mina Salman, Bahrain, 43 years after leaving East Suez. France, nearly six years ago during Nicolas Sarkozy's presidency, established a joint naval-air base called 'Peace Base' in Abu Dhabi, maintaining a permanent presence in the Gulf. The GCC countries are dependent on the U.S. and other weapon suppliers for optimal use of their weapons in terms of training, maintenance, and parts. Saudi Arabia uses American bombers to bomb Houthi positions in Yemen, but continuing these operations would be impossible without American trainers, maintenance technicians, and the parts and ammunition sent by the U.S. The U.S. plays a significant role in training the Saudi army and modernizing the country's National Guard, with American advisors and managers prominently present in Saudi Arabia's industry, energy, maritime, and cybersecurity sectors. Additionally, the U.S., Saudi Arabia, and Britain have close intelligence cooperation. Some smaller GCC countries, like Qatar, are trying to reduce their dependency on the U.S. by purchasing weapons from other countries. Qatar recently signed a $7.1 billion deal with France, and François Hollande, the President of France, made an unprecedented appearance at the annual GCC leaders' summit. Despite this, it will be challenging for Saudi Arabia, a key member of this council, to reduce its dependency on the U.S. in the short term. Regarding the Yemen crisis, Saudi Arabia, which has always supported Pakistan with generous financial aid, asked the Pakistani government to send troops to assist in Yemen, but the Pakistani parliament unanimously rejected this request. Egypt, which has received billions of dollars in financial aid from GCC countries, similarly refused to send troops to Yemen. The GCC countries have a long way to go to reduce their dependency on the U.S., but until then, they prefer the U.S. to be their guardian and protector. Internal Discontent, Roots of Threat Obama, challenging the prevailing perceptions that view Iran as the primary threat to the security of the Middle East and Arab countries, stated in April this year to the New York Times: 'Perhaps the greatest threat to Saudi Arabia and other GCC countries is internal discontent, not Iran.' Nevertheless, the U.S. President, in a contradictory move, invited the leaders of these countries to the U.S. and made serious commitments regarding their security against external threats and strengthening their military capabilities with more effective weapons, implicitly portraying Iran as the greatest threat. The leaders of the GCC countries generally view Iran's nuclear program and the expansionist policies of the Islamic Republic as a serious threat to themselves. While some of the Islamic Republic's approaches and policies can indeed pose a threat to these countries, and their concerns about the Islamic Republic are understandable, Iran is not the source of their threats and instability. The roots of this threat must be sought in the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003 and the fall of Saddam's regime. This action disrupted the existing order in the region, which relied on pro-American Sunni autocratic governments, and as a result, Saudi Arabia, one of the most important regional players, could not accept the formation of a post-Saddam government in Baghdad that placed Shiites in the majority and in power, consequently marginalizing the Sunnis of Iraq, leading to an increase in the Islamic Republic's influence in Iraq. In this context, Saudi Arabia encouraged Sunni militants and jihadists, some of whom were affiliated with al-Qaeda, to undermine the foundations of the new government in Baghdad and to fight against foreign occupying forces, including the U.S. One of the outcomes of this Saudi policy was the connection and unification of former Saddam army soldiers, Sunni fighters, and foreign jihadists, leading to the emergence of the phenomenon known as ISIS or the Islamic State. Currently, the threat that the GCC countries perceive from Iran is not based on long-standing sectarian conflicts between Shiites and Sunnis or Persians and Arabs. According to some American analysts, including Flynt Leverett and Hillary Mann Leverett, former members of the National Security Council and professors at the University of Pennsylvania and Georgetown University respectively, this threat arises from the Islamic Republic's efforts to integrate the principles and institutions of Islamic governance with election-based politics, as well as its attempts to adopt an independent foreign policy. 'The leaders of the GCC countries are not concerned about the demands of some secular liberal Westerners for reforms in these countries because they know that such demands will not garner support from Arab societies.' According to these two analysts, these leaders are particularly worried about Sunni movements like the Muslim Brotherhood that seek power through elections and popular participation. For the leaders of these countries, groups like the Muslim Brotherhood are considered a serious threat because if the majority of Muslim Arab societies are allowed to participate in free elections, the historical argument for the existence of a king in Saudi Arabia to preserve true Islam will lose its relevance. For this reason, the GCC countries label groups like the Muslim Brotherhood as terrorists and seek to suppress them in the Middle East. Saudi Arabia and its allies, by weakening the Muslim Brotherhood as an organization for expanding Sunni political engagement, have paved the way for extremist jihadist groups like al-Qaeda and ISIS to emerge as the only option for dissatisfied Sunni Arabs, and the disastrous political and humanitarian consequences of this can be seen in Libya, Syria, and recently in Yemen. The connection and attribution of instability in the Middle East to Iran and its portrayal as the main source of threats in the region, as the GCC countries present, contradicts existing realities. Iran is merely a part of the overall threats present. The threats to the stability of the Middle East, arising from Iran, Yemen, and ISIS in Iraq and Syria, are in many ways related to the shared policies of the U.S. and the GCC countries that have been pursued in the region over the past three decades, beginning with the Iran-Iraq War. During this eight-year war, the U.S. and the Gulf Arab countries actively supported Saddam Hussein. This action and subsequent events set the stage for the ongoing enmities and distrust in the region, for which there is currently no clear prospect for resolution.
Camp David Meeting; Military Dependency of Arab Countries
The article discusses the military dependency of Gulf Cooperation Council countries on the United States, highlighting their efforts to strengthen their military while remaining reliant on U.S. support. Despite attempts to diversify their military alliances, countries like Saudi Arabia continue to face challenges in reducing this dependency, particularly in light of regional conflicts and internal discontent. The article also critiques the perception of Iran as the primary threat to these countries, suggesting that internal issues and historical U.S. policies play a significant role in regional instability.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The GCC countries discussed their military dependency on the U.S. and the challenges of diversifying their defense alliances. The article critiques the perception of Iran as the primary regional threat, suggesting internal issues and historical U.S. policies also contribute to instability.
- GCC countries are heavily reliant on U.S. military support.
- Attempts to diversify alliances with countries like Egypt and Pakistan have been unsuccessful.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The GCC's military dependency on the U.S. has historical roots in decades of arms deals and strategic alliances. Regional instability is often linked to both internal discontent and external threats.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%