Also available in Persian — نسخه فارسی ✈️ Telegram EN فا
❓ Unknown

Commander of Deception Operations: Reactions to Mohsen Rezai's Defense of Karbala 4

Jan 25, 2026 January 25, 2026 4 min read 📰 Radio Farda
📋 Key Takeaway

Mohsen Rezai's recent defense of the controversial Karbala 4 operation has ignited significant debate on social media, particularly regarding the accuracy of historical narratives surrounding the Iran-Iraq War. Hesamoddin Ashna, an advisor to the president, has called for accountability and criticized Rezai's comments, emphasizing the need for transparency about the war's hidden truths. This ongoing discourse highlights the complexities and sensitivities surrounding Iran's war history.

🔍 Quick Context Guide
💡 Bottom Line: Rezai's defense of the Karbala 4 operation has reignited debates about Iran's war history and accountability.

👥 Key Players

Mohsen Rezai MENTIONED
Former commander of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC)
"Rezai is a prominent military figure in Iran, known for his leadership during the Iran-Iraq War and his current role in the Expediency Discernment Council."
Hesamoddin Ashna MENTIONED
Advisor to Hassan Rouhani
"Ashna is a political advisor who influences public discourse and policy, particularly in matters related to Iran's historical and political narratives."
Jafar Shirali Nia MENTIONED
Researcher on the Iran-Iraq War
"Nia is a historian whose work challenges official narratives about the Iran-Iraq War, contributing to public debate."

📰 What Happened

Mohsen Rezai defended the controversial Karbala 4 operation from the Iran-Iraq War, claiming it was a strategic deception. His comments have sparked debate over historical narratives and accountability for wartime decisions.

  • Rezai claimed the Karbala 4 operation was a deception tactic to mislead Iraqi forces.
  • Hesamoddin Ashna criticized Rezai's remarks, calling for transparency about the war's hidden truths.

💡 Why It Matters

🇮🇷 For Iran: The debate touches on sensitive historical narratives and accountability, affecting national identity and political discourse.
🌍 Regional: Revisiting the Iran-Iraq War influences regional perceptions of Iran's military history and strategic behavior.
🌐 International: Understanding Iran's historical military strategies can inform international policy and diplomatic approaches to Iran.

📚 Background

The Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988) was a prolonged conflict with significant casualties and political ramifications for Iran. The Karbala 4 operation is controversial due to its perceived failure and high casualties.

Iran-Iraq War Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps
📡 Source: NEUTRAL
📊 Confidence: 70%
The source provides a balanced view of the ongoing debate, highlighting different perspectives within Iran.

Mohsen Rezai, the commander of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps during the Iran-Iraq War, has sparked widespread reactions on Twitter with his tweet regarding the 'Karbala 4' operation. Meanwhile, Hesamoddin Ashna, an advisor to Hassan Rouhani, called for accountability regarding the 'secret truths' of the Iran-Iraq War, stating to Rezai, 'We may forgive those who err, but we will never forgive the narcissists.' Rezai wrote on Twitter: 'The Karbala 4 operation was conducted to deceive the enemy. If a historical analyst is fooled in understanding that deception, then woe to their writings.' He claimed: 'With the Karbala 4 operation, we made the enemy believe that our annual operation was only this one. Ten days later, at the same location and when the Ba'ath army forces were on leave, we conducted the Karbala 5 operation.' This statement from the former IRGC commander comes despite previous claims by IRGC commanders about the exposure of the 'Karbala 4' operation. Analysts have previously spoken of Iran's 'relative' victory in the 'Karbala 5' operation, stating it was not a significant victory for Iran. Rezai's tweet may be a reaction to recent discussions about this operation and the writings of Jafar Shirali Nia, a researcher on the Iran-Iraq War. On the anniversary of the 'Karbala 4' operation, the IRGC Document Center claimed that the operation 'was halted due to existing obstacles in the early hours' and that 'contrary to the propaganda of some foreign media,' the number of Iranian forces killed in this operation 'was less than a thousand.' Jafar Shirali Nia described this claim as 'strange' and refuted it by referencing previous reports from the center and statements from Islamic Republic officials. Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani noted that in this operation, 'we had nearly a thousand martyrs and 3,900 missing in action, most of whom should be counted as martyrs, and about 11,000 wounded, about half of whom were treated on an outpatient basis.' Shirali Nia also quoted Mohammad Doroudian, a narrator from the IRGC's political office, stating that Mohsen Rezai himself said that this operation 'was completely classified and leaked.' The topic of this operation was raised in 2015 after the discovery of the bodies of 175 Iranian divers. Rezai's tweet has elicited widespread reactions on Twitter. Hesamoddin Ashna, in a post titled 'Commander of Deception Operations,' called for accountability regarding the 'secret truths' of the Iran-Iraq War. He wrote to Rezai: 'You have so far appeared as a national hero. However, with these words about that bitter operation, you can no longer hide behind the names of the martyr commanders and must prepare yourself for tough questions.' Ashna emphasized that 'there is a world of difference between deception operations and leaked operations. Post-event analyses do not solve any problems. We may forgive those who err, but we will never forgive the narcissists.' Some Twitter users have also shared previous statements from IRGC commanders regarding the exposure of this operation. Others have published a video of Hassan Bagheri, a commander killed in the Iran-Iraq War, stating: 'Conducting (intelligence and reconnaissance) before operations has become very difficult, but suffering casualties during operations has become very easy... a thousand, two thousand, three thousand, it’s as if nothing happened.' Asieh Bakri, the daughter of Hamid Bakri, a war commander, wrote to Mohsen Rezai: 'For the sake of your own end and the comfort of the survivors of the imposed war, please stop writing; you are not a balm, you do not know how to apologize; at least practice silence.' Amin Qalaei also shared Rezai's statements from 2015 during the funeral of Iranian divers, in which he said that Iraq had set up floodlights on its shore after the Valfajr 8 operation to prevent Iranian divers from acting. Ali Malihi, a journalist, published part of Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani's memories about this operation, stating: 'I walked alone next to the building where I was staying and thought. The failure of the operation (Karbala 4) with all the resources and propaganda we had is very bitter... Dr. Hadi (Mohammad Ali Hadi) and Dr. Rouhani (Hassan Rouhani) came. They criticized the management of the operation. Usually, in times of defeat, grievances peak.' Farzaneh Ayini, a journalist, also raised the question regarding Rezai's tweet: whether he 'makes decisions in the Expediency Discernment Council with the same tactic.' This issue has been raised by several other users, referring to Rezai's performance as the secretary of the Expediency Discernment Council. While 30 years have passed since the end of the Iran-Iraq War, discussing certain aspects of this war remains taboo. Additionally, officials of the Islamic Republic provide different narratives regarding the details of this war and the reasons for accepting UN Resolution 598.

🌐

Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →

Translation confidence: 85%

📰 Related Coverage

⚖️ Independent Platform — Artesh.com is not affiliated with any government, military, or political organization. Editorial Policy →