As the date of the presidential election next year approaches, the political and electoral struggle among various factions of the Islamic Republic has begun under the guise of economic debate. In this context, Ali Khamenei, the leader of the Islamic Republic, said on Thursday, March 9, 2017, during a meeting with the President and members of the Assembly of Experts: "Of course, government officials have done significant work in this area, but this is only part of the necessary work." He also added, "If all the necessary work on the topic of resistant economy had been done, today we would have seen a noticeable difference in the economic situation of the country and the lives of the people... I have also told the respected President that stating macroeconomic indicators is good, of course, if the statistics are not questionable, but in any case, these do not affect the lives and livelihoods of the people in the short and medium term." Following these remarks, Friday prayer leaders also opened their mouths to criticize the government, repeating the essence of these statements. For example, the temporary Friday prayer leader of Tehran said: "... the resistant economy should come to the tables of the people, meaning it should be tangible and not settle for long-term programs, and that people should see the results in terms of job creation and prosperity in their lives, and this should be expedited." Or the representative of the Supreme Leader in Markazi province stated: "The effects of the government's actions to improve the livelihood economy must be felt in society, and only then can it be said that the planning has been effective." In this context, the Friday prayer leader of Nasrabad said: "The resistant economy cannot be achieved with slogans and statistics; it requires management and action, and this important aspect starts from the management of parents in the family to the management of officials at the macro level." Of course, economic criticisms of the government were not limited to the level of Friday prayer leaders and representatives of the Supreme Leader in this city and that city, but escalated to correspondence between the First Vice President and Ahmad Jannati, the head of the Assembly of Experts, who is also the Secretary of the Guardian Council. The First Vice President, in his letter to Jannati, while providing a report on the achievements of the resistant economy, claimed that the Iranian economy has become "more resistant" compared to the beginning of the year and previous years. Apart from the media and propaganda struggles surrounding the economic situation of the people, which usually intensifies in the months leading up to elections, it seems that the views of the leader of the Islamic Republic are still aligned with the populist economy of the previous government. In fact, it was the leader of the Islamic Republic who, at that time, supported slogans such as "the sweet scent of service" or "bringing oil money to the tables of the people," thus endorsing the policies of the previous government. Is it possible to perceive economic improvement in the short term? The phrase "the effects of economic policies are not tangible" raised by the leader of the Islamic Republic is a general and vague statement and does not count as precise within the framework of economic language, which is defined by numbers and established terms. If domestic expert reports and international institutions are to be considered, it can be said that part of the government's policies is focused on reducing the inflation rate, the effects of which are quite tangible. The average inflation rate has been confirmed by both domestic and international institutions. For example, according to the latest report from the International Monetary Fund, the inflation rate has become single-digit, and the point-to-point inflation rate has fluctuated around 9.5 percent since mid-2016, which is a significant decrease compared to previous years. Additionally, another part of the policies is aimed at creating economic growth, the signs of which can be seen in the increase in production in some manufacturing units, the rise in oil exports, and the opening of trade outside Iran. Also, according to the latest report from the International Monetary Fund, in the first half of this year, the Iranian economy has emerged from recession, and the growth of Iran's gross domestic product is approaching 6.6 percent as the year comes to an end. At the same time, it cannot be denied that there are no signs of success from the government regarding issues such as job creation, especially for youth and women. However, it should not be forgotten that the effects of employment policies appear in the long term. But if the intention behind "tangible improvement" is increased purchasing power, then this can only be achieved in the long term and under conditions of continuous and widespread growth and sustainable job creation. Economists agree that rapid economic improvement through populist policies leads to long-term destructive effects. Therefore, if the economic situation is to improve, the same policies for sustainable improvement of macroeconomic indicators, especially economic growth, and gradual and stable improvement must be pursued. It should be noted that continued economic growth is contingent upon increasing political and economic stability, transparency in the Iranian economy, and its opening to the world. The Iranian economy is fragmented, and it is not only the government that is responsible for the problems; a significant portion of the Iranian economy is owned and managed by institutions under the supervision of the leader of the Islamic Republic. The responsibility and share of these institutions in creating or solving economic problems is not insignificant and should be subject to public scrutiny. Conclusion: Economic debate and criticism have their own rules and language, which differ from electoral struggles and religious mobilization in Friday prayers. The verbal conflicts among various factions of the Iranian regime, however, follow fewer of these accepted rules and aim to delegitimize the opponent and gain political power. The improvement of the livelihood and welfare of the majority of the people is only possible when macroeconomic indicators such as investment, economic growth, and consumption continuously increase, and no government can achieve this quickly. According to reports from international organizations, although the government has been successful in improving these indicators, other important indicators such as employment have not yet seen significant improvement. The problems left over from the previous government are only part of the obstacles to improving the economic situation under current conditions. The inefficiency and widespread corruption of the current government, as well as the interference of institutions under the supervision of the Supreme Leader in economic affairs, are also other obstacles to economic improvement. Now, as the presidential election approaches next year, the political struggles of various factions of the regime will intensify, and thus the political and economic risk indicators of Iran will increase. One of the reasons for the reluctance of international investment circles and banks to quickly approach the Iranian market will also be this, as with the coming to power of the opposition faction of the government, it is likely that things will revert to the previous state.
Electoral Struggle or Economic Debate?
As Iran approaches its presidential election, political factions are engaging in a struggle framed as an economic debate, with Khamenei criticizing the government's economic performance. This has led to increased scrutiny of economic policies and their effectiveness, particularly regarding inflation and employment. The situation highlights the ongoing tensions within the Iranian political landscape and the challenges facing the economy.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
As Iran approaches its presidential election, political factions are publicly debating the economy, with Khamenei criticizing the government's economic performance. This has led to increased scrutiny of economic policies, particularly regarding inflation and employment.
- Khamenei stated that the government's economic efforts have not sufficiently improved people's lives.
- The Iranian economy has shown signs of growth, but significant issues like unemployment remain unresolved.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's economy has been under strain due to sanctions and internal mismanagement, leading to high inflation and unemployment rates. The political landscape is characterized by factional struggles, especially as elections approach.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%