The Poligraph website, a fact-checking project of Voice of America, states that the claim that Russia held 'local elections' with high voter turnout in five occupied regions of Ukraine is fake. Moscow had announced that it held 'elections' in five occupied regions of Ukraine. This illegal voting for candidates in 'regional parliament elections' took place from September 8 to 10 in the occupied areas of Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson. Moscow claims that participation in these elections was high and that hundreds of thousands voted. Ukraine and Kyiv's allies condemned the holding of elections in parts of eastern and southern Ukraine as an attempt by Moscow to consolidate its power in these regions. The Russian Election Commission announced that the ruling party 'United Russia' is leading in four annexed regions of Ukraine, while the Russian army does not have full control over any of these areas. On September 10, Marina Zakharova, head of the Russian Election Commission in the occupied Kherson region, claimed that 'a total of 65.14% of voters in the Kherson region participated in the voting.' This news is false. Firstly, holding 'elections' in war zones is illegal under international law. A senior United Nations official stated that the holding of these 'elections' has 'no legal basis' according to the UN Charter and the UN General Assembly resolution that deems Russia's occupation of Ukraine illegal, and undermines the peace process. In addition to unverifiable claims regarding the elections, Russia announced figures for the number of participants that exceed the total population of the cities and regions occupied in Ukraine. Less than 63% of the population of the Kherson region lives in areas currently occupied by Russia, making the likelihood of 65.14% voter participation in the region highly unlikely. According to the Kherson region's main statistics office, the permanent population of the region as of January 1, 2022, was just over one million. Since early September 2023, Ukraine has had full control of the Beryslav area in the Kherson region with a population of nearly 100,000, as well as the city of Kherson with a population of nearly 280,000, which together account for 37% of the region's population. Furthermore, Ukraine controls about one-third of the Kherson region, with a population of 170,000, excluding the city of Kherson. Therefore, according to the most conservative estimates, more than 37% of the residents of the Kherson region live in areas controlled by Ukraine, while only less than 63% live in areas controlled by Russia. The BBC reported that verifying the results and voter turnout in Russia's 'elections' in the occupied areas of Ukraine is impossible, as there were no independent observers and voting was conducted under duress. 'Images of voters show that ballots are apparently being cast under the watchful eyes of armed soldiers with heavy weapons and face masks. Some images show ballots being placed in transparent plastic boxes where votes are visible.' Andriy Mahra, a former member of Ukraine's Central Election Commission, shared a video on Facebook showing a military man in a face mask and a woman in civilian clothes walking down the street in one of the occupied villages in the Kherson region, knocking on doors and asking residents to vote. One resident of the Russian-occupied area in the Kherson region, speaking on condition of anonymity to the BBC's Ukrainian service, said that 'local accomplices and Russian soldiers with machine guns and ballot boxes were walking around.' Ukraine and the West condemned Russia's efforts to legitimize its occupation of Ukraine, including through falsified elections. Antony Blinken, the U.S. Secretary of State, stated on September 10 that Russia's 'fake elections' demonstrate a blatant disregard for the principles of the UN Charter, including respect for the sovereignty and territorial integrity of nations, which underpins global security and stability. Blinken stated that the United States 'will never recognize the Russian Federation's claims to any of Ukraine's sovereign territories' and warned any potential 'international supporters' of Russia's actions that they may face sanctions and visa restrictions. The foreign ministers of the G7 countries, the U.S., Japan, Germany, the UK, France, Italy, Canada, and the EU representative, called these elections 'fake' and a 'blatant violation of Ukraine's independence, sovereignty, and territorial integrity and the UN Charter.' This article is based on a report by Poligraph, a fact-checking project of Voice of America.
Fact-Check | Russia's Claims About 'Elections' in Occupied Areas of Ukraine Are Fake
Russia claimed to have held 'local elections' in five occupied regions of Ukraine, asserting high voter turnout, which Ukraine and its allies have condemned as illegitimate. International law prohibits elections in war zones, and evidence suggests that the reported turnout figures are exaggerated and unverifiable. This situation highlights ongoing tensions and the struggle for legitimacy in the conflict over Ukraine.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Russia claimed to have held elections in occupied regions of Ukraine, which Ukraine and its allies have condemned as illegitimate and illegal under international law. The reported voter turnout figures are considered exaggerated and unverifiable.
- Russia announced elections in five occupied Ukrainian regions with high turnout claims.
- International law prohibits holding elections in war zones, and these claims are widely disputed.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Russia's occupation of parts of Ukraine has been a major international issue since 2014, with ongoing military and political conflicts.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%