Ayatollah Javadi Amoli delivered extensive remarks on December 27, 2018, at the unveiling ceremony of the book 'Tahrir al-Usul' (the lecture notes of Ayatollah Khomeini's advanced principles class by Javadi Amoli). In part of his speech, he criticized the seminaries, stating that there are two types of students: brokers and innovative producers. He argued that the continuous quoting of past jurists' fatwas by scholars is merely a form of scholarly brokerage, not innovation. 'The seminaries are currently experiencing their richest period thanks to the Imam and martyrs; 50,000 is not a small number!' He added that the past seminaries, which were less equipped and had fewer students, nurtured great figures like Allameh Amini and Allameh Tabatabai, who produced significant works like 'Al-Ghadir' and 'Al-Mizan' alone. However, he questioned whether we currently have three such students among the 50,000. Being a broker is different from becoming a figure like Allameh Amini. He emphasized the need to open the path for scientific innovation and close the path for students becoming brokers. This criticism is valid and justified. On January 3, 2019, Mohammad Golpayegani, head of Ayatollah Khamenei's office, stated that 'today, the Qom seminary has 80,000 students.' The enormous budget allocated by the government to seminaries and other religious institutions has yielded no results. Besides the money that people and the government directly pay to the clergy, thousands of clerics are employed in various government institutions, including leading congregational prayers, and receive salaries for that. What is the issue that so much money has been spent on seminaries, which have built the most modern buildings and libraries and use modern technology, yet have no achievements? Ayatollah Javadi Amoli is one of the grand jurists. He is a Quran interpreter, and besides thematic interpretations of the Quran, about 40 volumes of his Quran commentary, titled 'Tasnim,' have been published so far. He is a professor of jurisprudence, principles, the philosophy of Muslim philosophers, the mysticism of Muslim mystics, and the science of Muslim theology. However, what innovative ideas and creative opinions do his numerous works contain? In politics, his only innovation and creativity is the discussion of 'political deviation' (refer to the article 'Political Deviants' as narrated by Ayatollah Javadi Amoli). On January 7, 2019, he went further and accused the nuclear negotiators of political deviation, stating: 'Five years ago, when foreign affairs officials came, I told the gentlemen to count your fingers when you shake hands with the Americans! I told them these people are not trustworthy at all; we saw the Americans in the coup of August 19. Three years ago, we also said that political deviation exists, be careful. Before others say that the JCPOA is dangerous, we told them. When a person deals with infidels, they count their fingers, but if, God forbid, they are deceived, it is their own fault.' Javadi Amoli's Quran interpretation is a strongly Shiite interpretation, often extremist, with numerous anti-Semitic and anti-Christian positions. Shiism goes so far as to claim: 'The infallible Imams are God's proof on earth and the heirs of previous prophets in knowledge, infallibility, and leadership; thus, they are aware of all heavenly scriptures by divine permission' (Ayatollah Javadi Amoli, Tasnim, Quran Commentary, Esra Publishing Center, Volume 14, p. 123). Javadi Amoli considers the Imams to be the best examples of the perfect human or God's vicegerent. In his view, the perfect human is, on one hand, the responsible manager of the organized system of existence, and on the other hand: 'The creation of the universe is to provide the realm of the vicegerency of the perfect human, and existence other than him is not desirable in the realm of action' (Tasnim, Volume 3, p. 197). According to Javadi Amoli, the perfect human (the vicegerent of God) has mastery over the details of material objects, brings them from potentiality to actuality, and invents industries and tools. The perfect human [who are the prophets and Shiite Imams] are the creators of sciences and inventors of technology. Water, rain, fruits, and everything is their work (Tasnim, Volumes 3, pp. 128-125). Javadi Amoli introduces all worldly matters as the work of the Imams based on several visitation texts. Thus, Shiites adopted the theory of the perfect human from Sunni mystics and introduced the Imams as the highest examples of this theory. According to Javadi Amoli, the perfect human, the vicegerent of God, is the Imams of the twelve Shiite Imams: 'The perfect human and the comprehensive vicegerent of God is Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib' (Tasnim, Volume 3, p. 103). Javadi Amoli presents the Imams as manifestations of all the active names of God: 'What emerges in the world of creation from creation, holding, expansion, revival, and death (which is derived from the realm of God's action and is possible existence, not necessary) requires a manifestation, which is the vicegerent of God and the perfect human, and Imam Sadiq states under the verse 'And to God belong the best names' that we are the best names, 'we are the best names' (Bihar, Volume 25, p. 4, Hadith 7)' (same, p. 207). According to Javadi Amoli, the divine status of the Imams is higher than all previous prophets (Tasnim, Volume 7, pp. 138-134). He claims that before Adam was created, Ali ibn Abi Talib confirmed the prophethood of Muhammad. He then concludes from this claim that he is the 'perfect human' (Tasnim, Volume 3, p. 139). Imam Hussein also knew the secrets and divine sciences before birth, and upon birth, God's revelation was known to him (Tasnim, Volume 3, p. 117). Imam Jawad and Imam Hadi reached the position of Imamate and perfect human at the age of seven and became 'God's vicegerent.' He states that the Imams are the best way to understand the Quran, the doors of knowledge and wisdom, and paradise cannot be entered without them (Tasnim, Volumes 9, pp. 565-564). Therefore, how will Sunnis and followers of other religions enter paradise? It seems that understanding and interpreting the Quran is also impossible without the Imams. He states: 'Those who seek to understand the Quran without the 'Ahl al-Bayt' are analyzing and combining dreams and think that they can interpret it with a dictionary' (Tasnim, Volume 13, p. 144). 'Knowledge of interpretation requires a close connection with the pure and immaculate Ahl al-Bayt, who are firm in knowledge' (Tasnim, Volume 13, p. 168). 'The Ahl al-Bayt are the second to the Quran and will never be separated from it... because they are the perfect example of 'the purified ones,' they have attained the highest knowledge of the Holy Quran' (Tasnim, Volume 13, p. 131). All sciences are the product of the blessings of the Imams, and the Imam of the time is truly the water of life for humanity (Tasnim, Volume 10, p. 636). The Imam of the time - the son of the eleventh Imam - is now the embodiment of the perfect human or God's vicegerent (Tasnim, Volume 5, p. 716). Ultimately, Jews and Christians will be subjected to the rule of the Imam of the time, pay tribute, and cause his martyrdom (Tasnim, Volumes 1, pp. 412-411). The Imam is above the Quran. The general Muslims - with all the greatness and respect they have for Prophet Muhammad - consider the Quran as the axis of Islam. They regard the entire Quran as the word of God. The Prophet of Islam only received divine revelation and conveyed it exactly to the people (the infallibility of the Prophet, according to Sunnis, pertains to receiving and conveying revelation). If monotheism, prophethood, and resurrection constitute the principles of religion, it is God, the Prophet, and the afterlife that the Quran introduces. According to the verses of the Quran, reason must be used to understand and interpret the Quran. In other words, the general Muslims - especially the vast majority who are Sunnis - consider the Quran as pure truth that contains no errors, but the Prophet in ordinary life may commit mistakes and minor sins. The Quran also speaks of him as a human who neither possesses knowledge of the unseen nor is capable of miracles. His only miracle is this reception and conveyance of revelation - that is, the Quran. We have reviewed Javadi Amoli's views on the Imams being the greatest vicegerents of God. He has now gone further and considers the Imams to be above divine revelation. Javadi Amoli explicitly claims in this speech that the Quran is not superior to the Imams. He states that the late Kashif al-Ghita: 'He has courage! He says there is nothing on earth as great as the Quran, but the Quran is never above the Imam. He has that courage, and he is right! He discusses this in the discussion of 'the Book of the Quran'... This 'Book of the Quran' is specified in his book on prayer... The late Kashif al-Ghita states on page 254: 'the fourth discussion,' that the Holy Quran is superior 'to all the books revealed from the heavens' and superior to the books of the prophets; he says this is correct, it is higher than all the books of the world; but 'and it is not superior to the Prophet, peace be upon him and his family, and his successors, peace be upon them'; the Quran is not higher than the Imam, and he is right! At one time, this 'with you, God opened and with you, He sealed' (Man La Yahduruhu al-Faqih, Volume 2, p. 615) could have been considered exaggeration; however, now it has been resolved for us. Thanks to the Imams, this thought has been resolved for us that 'with you, God opened and with you, He sealed,' we understand that this is in the third chapter, not in the first chapter, which is the realm of essence, and the second chapter, which is the attributes of the essence, meaning in these two realms, the realm is forbidden, the realm of manifestation, the realm of grace. According to this luminous statement of His Eminence Amir, 'He manifested to them, glory be to Him, in His Book without them seeing Him by what He showed them of His power' (Nahj al-Balagha, Sermon 147); we fully understand and it is like other ordinary issues for us, 'with you, God opened and with you, He sealed.' This Kashif al-Ghita wants to say that the Quran is correct, but it is not higher than the Imam. The Imam sacrifices his body for the Quran, not its essence! Its essence is not subject to sacrifice.' This claim that the Quran is not higher than the Imams is not only unacceptable to the general Muslims - especially Sunnis - but is also considered blasphemous. Sunnis regarded the Imams as noble and learned ordinary humans, but not possessing knowledge of the unseen, infallible, and other attributes that Shiites attribute to them. They have never considered the Imams to be on par with the Prophet, let alone superior to the Quran. Ibn Khaldun states in the introduction that the corruption and wrongdoing of Yazid was clear to all. However, the companions of the Prophet had two different interpretations regarding the uprising against him. The companions, except for Hussein, did not consider it permissible to rise against a corrupt ruler and were aligned with Yazid, and for this reason, they opposed Hussein's uprising, but 'Hussein was a jurist and indeed the leader of jurists' (Ibn Khaldun's Introduction, translated by Mohammad Porvini Gonabadi, Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company, 11th edition: 2006, p. 416). According to him, all companions voted based on their interpretation in this matter, just as Hussein did (p. 417). 'Hussein was martyred in this incident and is rewarded by God, and his action is right and based on interpretation, and the companions who were with Yazid also followed the path of truth and interpretation' (same). Sunnis do not consider Imamate to be one of the principles of religion, but rather view it as 'public interests' (same, p. 407). Thus, from his perspective, Imam Hussein was a great jurist. Imam Muhammad Ghazali also strongly criticized linking the command to good to the emergence of the Imam of the time and harshly rebuked the Shiites: 'It is astonishing that the Rawaafid (Shiites) have added another condition, which is that until the infallible Imam, who is the rightful Imam, does not rise, it is not permissible to command good. These people are too lowly to be talked to, and their response is that when they go to the court to demand their life and financial rights, they should be told that your support is the command to good and taking your rights from the oppressors is the prohibition of wrongdoing, and you who are demanding your rights are also doing a good deed, but now is not the time to prohibit oppression and demand rights because the rightful Imam has not yet risen' (Ihya Ulum al-Din, Volume 2, Book of Commanding Good and Prohibiting Wrongdoing). Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi, who introduces himself as the Seal of Saints in the second volume of Futuhat Makkiyah, quotes some Sufis in that book who have seen Shiites in the form of pigs in their revelations, and the only way to transform Shiites from pigs to humans is their repentance. He writes: 'And among them, may God be pleased with them, are the Rujabiun... and what I saw was that the Rawaafid (Shiites) remained in the revelation... so he saw them as pigs, and a covered man who did not know this sect passed by him, and he himself believed in it. When he passed by him, he saw him in the form of a pig and called out to him, saying: Repent to God, for you are a Shiite Rawaafidi... If he repented and was sincere in his repentance, he would see him as a human...' (Futuhat Makkiyah, Part Two, p. 8 and beyond, the revelation of some Rujabiun). The Quran tells the Prophet to say to the people that I am also a human like you, with the difference that I receive revelation (Al-Kahf, 110). Extreme Shiites first dehumanized and detached the humanity of the Prophet and constructed a superhuman character for him. They then extended these same characteristics to the Imams. In the next step, they placed the Imams above the prophets. And in the final step, they considered the Imams to be superior to the Quran. On the other hand, they invented the Guardianship of the Jurist. The jurist is the successor of the Imam of the time or the greatest vicegerent of God. The Messiah is not dead and is alive, and when the Imam of the time appears, he will also appear and stand behind the Imam of the time and pray, becoming one of his assistants (Tasnim, Volume 14, p. 334). When the expansion of prophethood culminates in the Imams, who are above the Quran and previous prophets, why should this expansion not continue to the jurist? Especially when this theory is combined with the theory of the 'guardian' of Muslim mystics. Why not say that the elder or guardian of the time is the same as the jurist? Why should we not consider the jurist to be superior to the Imams? Are the works left by the Imams not from the knowledge?
From 'Imams are Superior to the Quran' to 'Political Deviation' of Nuclear Negotiators
Ayatollah Javadi Amoli criticized the current state of Iranian seminaries, emphasizing the need for innovation over mere repetition of past fatwas. He controversially claimed that the Imams are superior to the Quran, which challenges traditional Sunni beliefs and raises significant theological concerns within the Islamic community.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Ayatollah Javadi Amoli criticized the Iranian seminaries for lacking innovation and accused the nuclear negotiators of political deviation. He also made controversial theological claims about the superiority of Imams over the Quran.
- Javadi Amoli criticized the seminaries for focusing on past fatwas instead of innovation.
- He accused nuclear negotiators of political deviation and warned against trusting the U.S.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's seminaries are influential in shaping the country's religious and political leaders. The nuclear negotiations are a critical aspect of Iran's international relations.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%