With the change of generations, it seems that past justifications for the mandatory hijab (tradition and honor) no longer convince groups of women, including members of the families of clerics and Islamists close to them. For this reason, the government's propaganda apparatus resorts to strange, astonishing, and fallacious justifications for enforcing mandatory hijab. These justifications can be categorized into six groups: religious, medical, psychiatric, social, aesthetic, and legal. The divine command justification is one of the religious justifications that still works for parts of society that do not understand the difference between Islam (a non-state religion) and Islamism (a state religion). Shia clerics (except for a few very rare clerics who do not have a presence in higher levels of religious bureaucracy) believe that according to the commands of Sharia and the Quran, hijab must be mandatory for all women in a society where the majority are Muslims and power is in their hands. They do not consider the hijab command to be limited to believing Muslim women. Therefore, even non-Muslims residing in the country, non-Muslim travelers, and Muslim women who do not believe in hijab must observe it, and otherwise, they should be punished. From their perspective, hijab is akin to a religious necessity that must be enforced, and if a religious government does not enforce it, it is not a religious government. Thus, they do not allow a Muslim who does not believe in it to be free and go their own way. However, if women's hijab is a divine command, then only those who believe in that God and His commands should observe it, and if they do not, they have sinned, and that God will punish them in a way He deems appropriate. Where has God given Muslims the authority to punish sinners? The Islamic Republic has, of course, turned all sins into crimes and has taken on a god-like role. The justification of radiation is apparently attributed to the first president of the Islamic Republic, Abolhassan Banisadr. Although the author has heard this statement from him, he has denied it in recent years. In any case, the speaker is less important than the essence of the statement. According to this view, a radiation emanates from women's hair that affects men and takes them out of their normal state. Those who want to enforce hijab add another proposition, namely the government's responsibility for the health of society. Another narrative of radiation justifying hijab is that a radiation emanates from men's eyes that only hijab prevents from reaching women. Women must cover themselves to protect themselves from this radiation. The enforcement of hijab is also to ensure the protection of women against this danger (the simple gaze of men at women). The problem with this view is that if this radiation exists, why can a woman's face, hands, and feet be uncovered? Another problem is the exposure of women to this radiation in front of their male relatives unless we assume that only the radiation from men's eyes is produced when facing non-relatives. With a few pieces of glue, this justification cannot be linked to science, knowledge, and protection and health. The justification of 'respecting the rights of others' is one of the most astonishing legal justifications for enforcing mandatory hijab by state force, as it shamelessly justifies mandatory hijab and the violation of women's rights to choose their clothing with the logic of freedom and respecting the rights of others: 'The reason I personally support the mandatory hijab goes back to a logic centered on 'the rights of others,' which is even emphasized in liberalism... Being unveiled... or any action that endangers the happiness of others in society or weakens the family unit is prohibited because freedom should not infringe on 'the rights of others.' Just as the government has the duty to prevent contaminated food from being distributed in society because it harms the health of others, it has the duty to prevent the public space from being contaminated because it harms the happiness of others.' (Editor-in-chief of Khorasan newspaper, Khorasan, July 16, 2016) With this logic, no rights remain because there will always be those who consider the freedoms of some individuals to be contaminating the public space. From the perspective of Muslims, some individuals are impure, and their very existence contaminates society, and with this logic, they eliminate them. This is certainly not the meaning of liberal freedom. No scientific research shows that strengthening the family is contingent upon women's hijab unless we consider the family to be only that of clerics and their followers. This justification has an apparently aesthetic aspect. This justification for hijab (plus power - for mandatory hijab) states that a woman's beauty should remain behind a curtain and be exclusive so that it remains pure and untouched and is not exploited by others. In this logic, a woman should not be a sexual object in the street and workplace but should only be a sexual commodity in the private space for her owner. Women, in this logic, should essentially be removed from the public sphere unless in a sack and behind walls. Of course, if a share of oil revenues reaches the man of the family, there is no need for the woman to work, and by loosening the purse strings, the woman in the private space can be kept somewhat satisfied. Preventing sexual assault and abuse is a social justification. According to this justification, any sexual abuse of women and girls (even six and seven-year-old children) is due to their lack of covering and the arousal of men. To prevent this, women must have hijab and also avoid mixing with men. Islamists and government clerics attribute any assault on women to their failure to observe hijab and their mixing with men, whether it is sexual assault on girls in a garden in Isfahan or the abuse of a seven-year-old girl and her murder. From this perspective, a government that claims to be the safest in the world and that everyone should derive security from it feels no responsibility for the security of society. In this logic, the victim is always blamed, not the perpetrator. Preventing depression and stress is a justification that attempts to present itself as scientific and based on psychiatry. Newspapers, websites, and government social media in Iran constantly repeat these points to promote hijab, stating that 'being unveiled causes depression' or 'immorality leads to depression' or 'increased depression is a consequence of being unveiled.' These statements are made in response to some opponents of hijab who have said that hijab brings depression. The problem with the previous side is that they defend the mandatory nature of hijab and not its essence. Even in seemingly scientific seminars (inviting Hezbollah-affiliated doctors), graduates of 'Islamic universities' say that men's gaze at unveiled women causes them stress: 'Seeing the opposite sex with inappropriate clothing can be stressful for men; and for women, hearing the voice of the opposite sex is stressful... When a person does not observe chastity, they expose themselves to stress.' (Member of the faculty of the Baqiyatallah University Neuroscience Research Center, IRNA, July 9, 2017) This means that men have all sexual diseases and want to possess all unveiled women but cannot, and for this reason, they become stressed. Thus, all beautiful things in the world must be destroyed or hidden (from buildings and cars and beautiful household items to flowers in gardens and lakes and mountains) because anyone who sees them desires to own them, and since they cannot own them, they become depressed or stressed. Aside from this, is men's stress in front of women not due to separation from the age of six? Is it not time for the Basijis who have now become doctors to remain silent about societies they do not know?
How Mandatory Hijab is Sold?
The article discusses the various justifications used by the Iranian government to enforce mandatory hijab, highlighting the shift in societal attitudes among women, including those from clerical families. It critiques the absurdity and contradictions in these justifications, which range from religious to legal and aesthetic arguments, and emphasizes the need for personal freedom and the questioning of oppressive norms.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The article analyzes the Iranian government's justifications for enforcing mandatory hijab, highlighting a generational shift among women who increasingly reject these justifications. It critiques the absurdity and contradictions in the arguments presented by the state.
- The government's justifications for hijab include religious, medical, social, and aesthetic arguments.
- There is a growing resistance among women, including those from clerical families, against mandatory hijab.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Mandatory hijab laws in Iran have been a point of contention since the 1979 Islamic Revolution, with ongoing debates about women's rights and personal freedoms.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%