The Iran Human Rights Campaign has reported the existence and distribution of a list of 'approved and non-approved lawyers' within the judiciary of the Islamic Republic of Iran, describing it as a 'violation of the rights of defendants' in discussions with legal experts. Although the right to choose a lawyer is emphasized as one of the most important pillars of fair trial in Iranian criminal procedure, Article 48 includes a provision stating that in cases of crimes against internal and external security, defendants must choose their lawyer from a list of 'judiciary-approved lawyers.' The Iran Human Rights Campaign states that based on this provision, the judiciary has prepared this list, which reportedly includes only 'approved lawyers.' Nasrin Sotoudeh, a lawyer, has called this action a 'violation of the rights of the accused,' stating, 'It is like telling people that for your surgery, you can only choose from three doctors we specify, out of thousands available in the city.' She added, 'In this reckless action, dangerous signs are evident. In a large province like West Azerbaijan, only 33 lawyers have been approved and listed, while the number of lawyers in this province exceeds three thousand.' Hussein Ahmadinejad, another lawyer, told the Iran Human Rights Campaign that this action divides the legal profession into 'approved and non-approved.' He added, 'In a security case I approached, the investigator said I was not subject to the provisions of Article 48. In another case in Tehran, they said I had to be on the list. I asked where the list was so I could know if I should be on it or not.' Ahmadinejad also mentioned that recently, some judicial security agencies have lists of approved lawyers who do not conduct interviews or discussions and are very cautious. There are specific individuals approved by the security agencies, and the question is how they can defend a political defendant. One must consider that a political and security defendant is alone, while their opponents are the IRGC and the Ministry of Intelligence, who are part of the system, as well as the Revolutionary Prosecutor's Office, which is also part of the system. This lawyer stated, 'The Revolutionary Court, whose primary goal is to protect the government and the revolution, means that the entire judicial system is from the government, and against it is a single defendant whose lawyer must also be from them (the government). This is oppression and contrary to the principle of fair and just trial.' Inside Iran, there have been repeated criticisms of political motivations interfering in judicial processes. International organizations and human rights defenders have repeatedly accused the Islamic Republic of Iran of widespread human rights violations and non-transparent and unjust trials, criticisms that are, however, rejected by Iranian judicial officials. 'Article 48 of the Criminal Procedure Code' was included in the criminal procedure bill, which was implemented from the beginning of July 2015 with the approval of the Guardian Council.
Iran Human Rights Campaign Report on the List of 'Approved and Non-Approved Lawyers' in the Judiciary
The Iran Human Rights Campaign has revealed the existence of a list of 'approved and non-approved lawyers' in the Iranian judiciary, which restricts defendants' rights to choose their legal representation. Legal experts criticize this as a violation of fair trial principles, highlighting the limited number of approved lawyers compared to the total available. This situation raises serious concerns about the fairness and transparency of judicial processes in Iran.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The Iran Human Rights Campaign reported on a list of 'approved and non-approved lawyers' in Iran's judiciary, which restricts defendants' rights to choose their legal representation. Critics argue this undermines the principle of a fair trial.
- Defendants in security-related cases must choose lawyers from a limited list approved by the judiciary.
- Only 33 lawyers are approved in West Azerbaijan, despite over 3,000 lawyers available.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The Iranian legal system has faced criticism for lacking transparency and fairness, particularly in politically sensitive cases. Article 48 of the Criminal Procedure Code limits defendants' choice of legal representation.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%