Also available in Persian — نسخه فارسی ✈️ Telegram EN فا
❓ Unknown

Is 'Coordinated Governance' Possible for Iran's Economy?

Jan 27, 2026 January 27, 2026 6 min read 📰 Radio Farda
📋 Key Takeaway

The article discusses the challenges of achieving coordinated governance in Iran's economy, highlighting the criticisms of former Minister of Economy Ali Tayebnia regarding the fragmentation of economic policies and the lack of compliance with regulations. The piece emphasizes the need for a unified approach to governance to foster economic growth and stability.

🔍 Quick Context Guide
💡 Bottom Line: Achieving coordinated governance is essential for Iran's economic recovery and stability.

👥 Key Players

Ali Tayebnia MENTIONED
Former Minister of Economy
"He provided critical insights into Iran's economic governance and highlighted the challenges of achieving coordinated economic policies."
Masoud Karbasian MENTIONED
Current Minister of Economy
"He is tasked with addressing the economic challenges identified by his predecessor and steering Iran's economic policy."
Supreme Leader of Iran MENTIONED
Ultimate authority in Iran
"His policies and directives significantly influence Iran's governance structure and economic decisions."

📰 What Happened

Former Minister of Economy Ali Tayebnia criticized the lack of coordinated governance in Iran's economy during his farewell speech, emphasizing the need for unified economic policies. He highlighted the fragmentation of economic sectors and the challenges posed by quasi-public institutions.

  • Tayebnia pointed out that economic progress requires coordination among various sectors.
  • He criticized the interference of quasi-public sectors and the lack of compliance with economic regulations.

💡 Why It Matters

🇮🇷 For Iran: The lack of coordinated governance hampers economic growth and exacerbates existing economic issues, affecting the population's welfare.
🌍 Regional: Regional stability could be affected if Iran's economic challenges lead to increased unrest or changes in foreign policy.
🌐 International: International stakeholders may view Iran's governance issues as a barrier to potential economic engagement or investment.

📚 Background

Iran's economy has faced significant challenges due to sanctions, mismanagement, and internal fragmentation, making effective governance crucial for progress.

Iranian economy Good governance
📡 Source: NEUTRAL
📊 Confidence: 70%
The article presents an analysis of internal economic challenges without overt bias, focusing on expert opinions and observations.

According to many Iranian government officials, Ali Tayebnia - the former Minister of Economy - was one of the successful members of the eleventh cabinet, yet he will not be present in the twelfth government. In his farewell speech, this minister criticized various aspects of Iran's economic relations, which, although not unprecedented, contained important and contemplative points, showcasing one of the fundamental challenges of Iran's economy. The Minister of Economy and Finance of the eleventh cabinet, during his farewell and the introduction of his successor - Masoud Karbasian - stated, 'Economic progress and welfare do not arise from fragmenting society. Reviewing successful and unsuccessful global experiences shows that only converging countries with appropriate relations with the world experience growth and welfare. Another concern of mine is the coordination in economic policies, which complicates policymaking. We are facing major challenges, and successful navigation through these challenges requires coordination.' This official also stated, 'A common understanding of these challenges and how to confront them, as well as an understanding of the costs that the continuation of this situation can impose on us, is a prerequisite for creating a coordinated planning. We need a mechanism to create coordination; as I said, the eleventh government and the president took steps, but we are still far from a coordinated governance system.' The former minister further explained this challenge of Iran's economy - namely the lack of coordinated or good governance - by saying, 'If we had a public and private sector in the past, now we have quasi-public, public, and private sectors, where the quasi-public sector has the inefficiencies of the public sector but lacks public oversight.' The former minister continued, 'It is not acceptable that whenever a company is privatized, a member of parliament in that region requests the cancellation of the transaction. I do not remember a company that we have privatized to a real private sector through auction without having a request for cancellation.' This internal tension among institutions and influential individuals of the regime over the interpretation of laws and the division of spoils is, of course, not new and has been experienced since the day the clerics came to power. However, our time has different demands, and its management discourse is 'good governance.' By 'coordinated governance,' we mean a system where the players of an economic system adhere to rules and regulations. Economists have emphasized the importance of 'compliance with the rules of the game' by players and consider it a condition for the success of any system in achieving its goals. 'Coordinated governance' is directly opposed to the recommendations of the leader of the regime regarding 'fire at will' for his followers and managed institutions. But why does Iran's economic system deviate from 'coordinated governance'? The concept of 'good governance' or the broader concept of coordinated governance has been of interest for the past three decades. This concept is now used at various levels to analyze institutions, including government (macro level), enterprises (micro level), and the financial system. For example, good governance of registered companies in the stock market reduces their risks and increases their stock values. Or good governance over government organizations reduces their risks, increases their social capital, and therefore reduces their political, social, and economic costs. The conditions for coordinated and good governance include: rule of law (instead of personal whims and power cliques), transparency, accountability, responsibility, public consensus, equal rights (or legal justice), and finally public participation in decision-making by legal institutions. Of course, these concepts overlap, but overall, they facilitate the use of public resources for development and progress. According to World Bank experts, the lack of good governance is a serious obstacle to development in transitional countries, and therefore it can be concluded that this 'political' factor is considered one of the disruptors of their economic progress process. Iran's economic system is not unified. One of the foundations of good and coordinated governance is 'compliance with the rules of the game' or, in other words, the adherence of economic players and institutions to policymaking. Just as one cannot hope for treatment without following a doctor's advice, one cannot expect an economy without adhering to economic policies. One of the reasons for the global financial crisis in the U.S., which was experienced more or less worldwide, was the lack of compliance with the rules of the game in the U.S. housing market. The lack of integration in Iran's economy is one of the reasons that makes 'compliance with the rules of the game' impossible. The level of 'compliance with the rules of the game' among various sectors of Iran's economy, whether public, quasi-public, private, etc., is not uniform. The government, by its nature, follows laws and policies to some extent. The government is under the supervision of the parliament and other supervisory institutions. In contrast, 'compliance with the rules of the game' among institutions managed by the Supreme Leader and individuals who cooperate with these institutions is negligible. A clear example of this refusal to 'comply with the rules of the game' is the 'fire at will' individuals and Friday prayer leaders who interfere in matters such as foreign policy, cultural issues like holding concerts, and even urban and provincial management. Such law evasion is observable at various levels of Iranian society - nationally, provincially, and institutionally. At the national level, for example, in 2014, the ninth parliament of Iran passed a bill under public pressure that required institutions including Astan Quds Razavi and economic enterprises of military institutions and the Executive Headquarters of Imam's Command to pay direct taxes. However, this law was not implemented, as after a few months, with the change of this law, these institutions were practically exempted from paying taxes. Of course, not paying taxes is just one manifestation of the lack of 'compliance with the rules of the game,' and the violations of quasi-public institutions are much broader than this. Access to information rents, circumventing laws, and violating competition rules in the market are other examples of this deviation from the rules of the game. The experience of Iran's banking system, especially private banks, is another example of the lack of 'compliance with the rules of the game' in Iran. It is no secret that despite the decrease in inflation rates and simultaneous recommendations from the central bank to reduce banking interest rates, banks, especially private banks, continue to circumvent regulations and discover and implement legal and religious tricks to pay higher returns to depositors.

🌐

Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →

Translation confidence: 85%

📰 Related Coverage

⚖️ Independent Platform — Artesh.com is not affiliated with any government, military, or political organization. Editorial Policy →