A few years ago, the results of a scientific study brought joy to those suffering from a few extra kilograms of weight! According to NPR, in this study, Dr. Katherine Flegal from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and her research team announced after reviewing hundreds of practical articles and tests conducted on over three million people worldwide that having a few extra kilograms reduces the risk of premature death! They stated that these few extra kilograms decrease the risk of death by up to 6 percent. However, they were referring specifically to a few extra kilograms, not obesity. But on Monday this week, another scientific study was published in the Annals of Internal Medicine that contradicts the previous finding. Dr. Andrew Stokes from the Boston University School of Public Health and his team concluded that having a little extra weight actually reduces lifespan. They claim that the mortality rate among individuals who have had a history of a few extra kilograms throughout their lives is 6 percent higher than others, not lower! Dr. Stokes states: 'Our findings indicate that there is no advantage to being overweight. Being overweight not only does not increase your lifespan but also increases your risk of death.' Dr. Stokes and his team studied data from over 225,000 individuals over 50 years old to see if obesity affected their lifespan. They believe that the data they collected is more accurate and reliable than the previous study because it examined a longer timeframe of these individuals' lives. He argues that the previous research is 'seriously flawed' because it cannot distinguish the effect of illness on weight change from the impact of weight on the risk of illness. However, Dr. Flegal, the author of the previous study, believes that the new research is not as reliable because it asks individuals to recall their weight over different years. She states: 'We know that individuals do not accurately report their height and weight. Women often report their weight as less than it is, and men report their height as taller than it actually is.' But which study is correct, and which results can be trusted? Dr. Steven Heymsfield, an obesity specialist from Louisiana State University, believes that individuals who are overweight should ask their doctor whether obesity-related diseases such as high blood pressure, high blood sugar, or high cholesterol threaten them. In any case, it is safer to say that if your weight is slightly high, try not to let it increase further. Meanwhile, control cardiovascular diseases through exercise and healthy nutrition.
Is Having a Few Extra Kilograms Beneficial or Harmful to Your Health?
Recent studies present conflicting views on the health implications of being overweight. While an earlier study suggested that a few extra kilograms could reduce the risk of premature death, a new study indicates that even slight overweight increases mortality risk. This debate is significant as it influences public health guidelines and personal health decisions.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Recent studies have produced conflicting results regarding the health implications of being overweight. While one study suggested that a few extra kilograms could reduce the risk of premature death, a new study claims that even slight overweight increases mortality risk.
- Dr. Flegal's study involved over three million people and suggested a 6% reduction in premature death risk with a few extra kilograms.
- Dr. Stokes' study, based on data from over 225,000 individuals over 50, found a 6% higher mortality rate among those with a history of being overweight.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Understanding the relationship between weight and health is crucial as obesity rates rise globally. This ongoing debate reflects the challenges in establishing clear health guidelines.
🏷️ Entities Mentioned
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%