Fifty Iranian economists have written a letter to the leaders of the three branches of the Islamic Republic, once again requesting the closure of the "secondary currency market" and warning about the consequences of uncontrolled currency prices, including "60% inflation" and "half of the population falling below the absolute poverty line." This letter, published on Tuesday, October 1, in the ILNA news agency, urges the heads of the three branches to "prevent a national catastrophe." The economists emphasized that the continuation of current currency policies, including the operation of the "secondary" currency market, will lead to "the sudden plunge of millions of middle-class individuals below the poverty line" and the creation of "massive rents." The authors of this letter warned that "the destructive and anxiety-inducing effects of the fourth currency shock in the past 75 years will be unprecedented." According to these economists, "60% inflation," "the halt of production units," and "unemployment of at least one million people" will be the consequences of the recent "currency shock." Three previous "currency shocks" occurred in 1993, 1997, and 2011. The authors of this letter accused the government of welcoming "the sale of currency at higher prices" to meet its expenses and called for the government to prepare a plan to restructure its expenses instead. This accusation comes at a time when Hassan Rouhani's government has announced its official policy to reduce currency rates. The economists also demanded that all currencies obtained from the sale of raw and primary mineral, steel, and petrochemical materials be sold to the Central Bank and that the "secondary currency market" be closed. According to the authors of this letter, due to the increase in currency prices, only "100 trillion tomans of currency rent" will be created in the export sector of raw and primary mineral and metallic materials. In August, 38 economists had also written a letter to the President of Iran, proposing suggestions for economic reform and calling for a reconsideration of the idea of establishing a "secondary currency market" before implementing these reforms. Farshad Momeni, Hossein Raghfar, Mohsen Renani, Morteza Afghah, Kamal Ataei, Mohammad Bahreinian, Gholamhossein Hassan-Tash, Mohsen Riazi, Valiollah Shahbazkhani, Hassan Tai, Mohammad-Reza Yousefi, and Ahmad Yazdanpanah are among the signatories of this letter. The first letter from these economists, who are more known as institutionalists and Islamic leftists, went unanswered by President Hassan Rouhani. The new letter has also been signed by some conservative figures, including Ahmad Tavakoli and Gholamreza Mesbahi-Moghadam. In July of this year, the government accepted the failure of its single exchange rate policy and created the "secondary currency market," which means a three-tiered currency system. In this scheme, exporters who previously did not offer their currency in the "Integrated Currency System" (NIMA) now offer it at an agreed rate to be allocated to non-essential goods that do not fall under the 4200 toman currency. A group of critics of the secondary currency market argue that petrochemical and steel companies and other "private state" companies that are the main suppliers of currency in the secondary market benefit the most from this market. According to these critics, while these companies benefit from energy subsidies and other exemptions, they sell the currency obtained from exports at high prices in the secondary market. Previously, some government officials, including Ahmad Torkan, head of the Free Zones Organization, had deemed the increase in currency prices beneficial for exports. However, these economists have stated that despite the increase in currency prices, "real exports" have not increased, and "only raw selling" has increased. The authors of this letter believe that the current model of non-oil exports is also an "inefficient and non-developmental" model that has become a center for reproducing rent-seeking relations and has neither increased Iran's share in global trade nor improved the technological quality of the country's products. The authors of this letter called for decisive and serious action against exporters who do not return their export currency to the country. Abdolnaser Hemmati, the head of the Central Bank, reported that of about $23 billion in non-oil exports conducted until September 14, only about $4 billion of that was offered in the NIMA system. Mr. Hemmati did not provide further clarification about the approximately $19 billion in currency that, according to him, has not entered the economy. Meanwhile, the Supreme Economic Coordination Council of Iran approved new policies for managing the currency market on October 1, which include obliging non-oil exporters to offer currency in the NIMA system. These economists have also proposed that the currency needed for raw and primary materials for industrial units be provided at the official rate. They have also called for a ban on the export of essential goods and medicines "until the situation improves and the existing problems are resolved." "Taxing properties and bank profits and speculative incomes," "cancelling tax exemptions for the export of raw and primary materials," "daily monitoring of cash flow through a central system in the Ministry of Economy and the Central Bank... and clarifying the process of using public currency resources" are among other proposals from these economists. In their letter, 38 economists declared "the withdrawal of all military enterprises and institutions from economic activities," "cleaning up the country's tax system," "merging banks with each other," "preventing interest payments on government accounts," "financing the country's security expenses through taxation and monopolizing it in the path of the public budget approved by the parliament," and "designing a special housing program for low-income groups" as some of the proposed solutions for getting Iran's economy out of crisis.
Letter from 50 Economists to Rouhani: Shut Down the Secondary Currency Market
Fifty Iranian economists have urged the government to shut down the secondary currency market to prevent severe economic consequences, including high inflation and increased poverty. They warn that current currency policies could lead to a national catastrophe and call for structural reforms in the economy. The letter highlights the urgent need for action to address the economic crisis facing Iran.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Fifty Iranian economists have urged the government to shut down the secondary currency market to prevent severe economic consequences, including high inflation and increased poverty. They warn that current currency policies could lead to a national catastrophe and call for structural reforms in the economy.
- The economists predict 60% inflation and a significant rise in poverty if current policies continue.
- The letter follows previous warnings from a smaller group of economists about the inefficiencies of the secondary currency market.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran has faced multiple currency shocks in the past, leading to high inflation and economic hardship. The secondary currency market has been criticized for benefiting certain exporters while exacerbating economic inequality.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%