Also available in Persian — نسخه فارسی EN فا
❓ Unknown

Mohsen Renani: We Are Quietly Moving Towards 'Cartoonish Science'

Feb 6, 2026 February 6, 2026 3 min read 📰 VOA Persian
📋 Key Takeaway

Mohsen Renani critiques the Iranian government's recent actions to suppress academic freedom, linking them to a broader trend of silencing dissent following the Mahsa movement. He warns that these actions reflect a regime in decline, moving towards ineffective and 'cartoonish' governance. This commentary highlights the precarious state of intellectual discourse in Iran.

🔍 Quick Context Guide
💡 Bottom Line: The Iranian government's actions against academic freedom signal a troubling trend towards authoritarianism and intellectual repression.

👥 Key Players

Mohsen Renani MENTIONED
Economist and faculty member at Isfahan University
"Renani is a prominent intellectual who critiques the Iranian government's policies, particularly regarding academic freedom and dissent."
Reza Ghaibi MENTIONED
Commentator on economic issues
"Ghaibi highlights the economic implications of Renani's analysis, emphasizing the potential for economic decline in Iran."

📰 What Happened

Mohsen Renani criticized the Iranian government's recent actions to suppress academic freedom, linking them to a broader trend of silencing dissent after the Mahsa movement. He described these actions as indicative of a regime in decline, moving towards ineffective governance.

  • Renani's comments were in response to the attempted closure of the 'House of Thinkers' at Allameh Tabatabai University.
  • He warned that the government's policies are leading to a chilling effect on intellectual discourse and student activism.

💡 Why It Matters

🇮🇷 For Iran: The suppression of academic freedom reflects broader authoritarian trends in Iran, potentially stifling dissent and critical thought.
🌍 Regional: This situation may influence regional dynamics by affecting Iran's stability and its relations with neighboring countries.
🌐 International: Internationally, this could impact perceptions of Iran's governance and human rights record, affecting diplomatic relations.

📚 Background

The Mahsa movement was a series of protests in Iran that began in 2022, advocating for women's rights and broader freedoms, which have faced severe government backlash.

Iranian protests Academic freedom in Iran
📡 Source: NEUTRAL
📊 Confidence: 70%
The article presents the views of an academic and commentator, reflecting critical perspectives on the Iranian government's policies.

Mohsen Renani, a faculty member of the Economics Department at Isfahan University, reacted to recent events at Allameh Tabatabai University in Tehran and the efforts to shut down the 'House of Thinkers' by stating: 'Apparently, they have lost hope in the software movement and theoretical platforms, and now we are set to quietly move towards 'cartoonish science.' In a note published on Wednesday on the 'Kalameh' website, he wrote: 'The recent incident at Allameh University and the attempt to close the House of Thinkers is the tip of the iceberg that is heading towards us. Even the university's sanctuary is no longer safe.' He emphasized: 'I believe that following the Mahsa movement, a public policy to silence thought has begun. It started with changes to the student disciplinary regulations; they have changed it in such a way as to incapacitate students so that they either do not come to university or, if they do, they do not dare to protest.' Renani further noted: 'They would love for us to leave. It does not matter where, just leave. Whether from this world, this country, the university, or anywhere else that our presence makes them uncomfortable. I told the students who came depressed and worried after the Mahsa movement: if you commit suicide, they will be happy, one less voice and one less thorn in their side. If you emigrate, they will be happy, one less critical elite activist. If you drop out, they will be happy, one less protesting student. The more you leave, the less capacity for change in the country. So we must stay and reclaim Iran.' Renani had previously written in another article: 'The main sign of a regime entering the fourth stage of collapse is that the system begins to exhibit cartoonish behavior.' In a section of an article titled 'Collapse,' published last February, he wrote: 'The main sign of a regime entering the fourth stage of collapse is that the system begins to resume its previous failed activities under a different name and in a different form. The indicator is that as its 'controllability' over the situation decreases, its 'flexibility' also declines. There is ample evidence that the regime is now openly exhibiting these characteristics.' He had noted that 'when the final collapse of the structure will occur depends on numerous events, but it cannot currently be predicted which one and exactly when they will happen.' Reza Ghaibi referred to Mohsen Renani's article: 'Next year, the people of Iran will witness unfortunate economic events.' Reza Ghaibi referred to Mohsen Renani's article: 'Next year will be the year of entering the fourth stage of collapse.' Mohsen Renani: 'The Mahsa movement completed a stage of the four stages of collapse.' Economists warned the government, Kayhan to economists.

🌐

Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →

Translation confidence: 85%

📰 Related Coverage

⚖️ Independent Platform — Artesh.com is not affiliated with any government, military, or political organization. Editorial Policy →