Simultaneously with Ali Motahari's criticism of the Supreme Leader's approval for handling the cases of 'economic offenders' without the right to appeal, the head of the judiciary called reports about the 'facilitation' of executions with these orders 'absolute lies.' Ali Motahari, the Deputy Speaker of the Iranian Parliament, on Tuesday, August 13, criticized the letter from the head of the judiciary, stating that this branch 'could have achieved its demands through a bill or an urgent proposal and should not have acted to bypass the parliament.' He added, 'We should not resort to a government decree for any excuse. A government decree is applicable where there is no legal path. They might say we would lose time; the response is that the time difference from presenting an urgent proposal to the approval of the Guardian Council is five to seven days.' On Sunday, some lawyers also described the request from the head of the judiciary and the Supreme Leader's order as contrary to sections of the constitution that grant the parliament the authority to legislate judicial laws. However, Sadeq Larijani, the head of the judiciary, on Tuesday called reports from Persian-language media abroad, which claimed that the recent orders from the Supreme Leader were aimed at 'facilitating the death penalty,' 'absolute lies.' He also stated that the 'two-stage' nature of issuing death sentences in these orders has not been removed. Mr. Larijani's remarks come at a time when the final issuance of a death sentence is carried out in three stages, and defendants can request a review after the initial court ruling, in the appellate court, and the Supreme Court. On August 10, the Supreme Leader agreed to the head of the judiciary's proposal to establish a special court with three revolutionary court judges to handle the cases of 'economic offenders.' According to this proposal, this court is formalized with the presence of two members, and 'its rulings, except for death sentences, are final and enforceable,' and 'death sentences can be appealed within a maximum of 10 days in the Supreme Court.' Based on these orders, branches of the Islamic Revolutionary Court with three judges will be established to handle the cases of 'economic offenders.' Meanwhile, the head of the judiciary stated that these courts 'have been prepared with the appointment of expert and qualified judges' and 'will begin their work as soon as possible.' Gholamhossein Mohseni Ejei, the spokesman for the judiciary, also announced that 'at least' in the initial stage, 'six courts' will be established for these cases, and the rulings of these judges have been issued. Judiciary officials did not mention the names of the appointed judges for this court or other details regarding this court. Iran's economy has faced severe turbulence and tensions in recent months following Donald Trump's final decision to withdraw from the JCPOA. The rial has significantly lost its value against the dollar, the prices of gold coins and other goods have risen, and a wave of protests has emerged in various cities across Iran. The Supreme Leader and his close associates attribute the country's economic problems not to U.S. sanctions but to the 'weak' performance of the government and also to what they describe as 'exploitation by profiteers.' Ahmad Iraqchi, the currency deputy of the Central Bank of Iran, is among those who have been arrested in recent weeks. In recent weeks, reports have also emerged regarding 'violations' in the import of mobile phones, cars, and other goods that have been imported with government currency, and judiciary officials have announced the arrest of some individuals in this regard.
Motahari Criticizes Larijani's Letter: The Judiciary Should Not Bypass the Parliament
Ali Motahari criticized the head of the judiciary for bypassing the parliament in handling economic offender cases, while Sadeq Larijani denied allegations that recent orders facilitate executions. This situation highlights tensions between branches of government amid Iran's ongoing economic crisis.
👥 Key Players
⚡ Actions
📰 What Happened
Ali Motahari criticized Larijani's judiciary actions bypassing parliament on economic offenders' cases.
- Ali Motahari criticize Sadeq Larijani, Judiciary
- Sadeq Larijani announce Judiciary, Supreme Leader
- Judiciary establish Special court for economic offenders
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The judiciary's actions and parliament's response indicate a power struggle in Iran's governance.
📝 Key Evidence
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%