The Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister announced that Ayatollah Mohammad Ishaq Fayyaz, one of the four prominent clerics in Najaf, stated in a meeting with the head of Iran's judiciary that "the use of force and coercion in promoting hijab is ineffective." According to ISNA news agency, Hossein Jaberi Ansari, who traveled to Iraq with Sadegh Larijani, published a report on his Telegram page about the meeting on Wednesday, November 3. Jaberi Ansari noted that this Shia cleric proposed three suggestions for "improving the hijab situation" in Iran: "appropriate use of radio, television, and media to promote hijab," "avoidance of using force and coercion in promoting hijab, which is ineffective," and "the return of scholars and preachers to their former influential positions in the religious education of society and ending the dominance of other professions over scholars in religious gatherings and assemblies." In this meeting, Ayatollah Fayyaz also emphasized that "Islam and Shia are religions of moderation" and that "moderate and tolerant behavior of government officials towards the people is necessary and a requirement of justice and proper governance." He further stated that "the attention of government officials to the people strengthens their trust in the government and contributes to the survival and stability of governments." The Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister mentioned Ayatollah Mohammad Ishaq Fayyaz, Sheikh Bashir Najafi, and Mohammad Saeed Hakim as three important Shia clerics in Iraq after Ayatollah Ali Sistani. Ayatollah Fayyaz was born in Ghazni, Afghanistan, and was a student of the famous Shia cleric Ayatollah Khoei in Najaf. According to a law passed in 1983, adherence to hijab in public places in Iran is mandatory, and non-compliance is punishable. However, some analysts have spoken about the failure of the Islamic Republic's policies in this regard. The website "Alif," close to Ahmad Tavakoli, previously wrote that "bad hijab" in Iran has turned into "a kind of nudity" and that "most" of the Islamic Republic's policies regarding hijab have failed. Gholamali Haddad Adel, an advisor to the Supreme Leader of the Islamic Republic, also stated on July 16 that the hijab situation in Iran is "getting worse day by day" and that "the changes regarding hijab that have occurred in recent years are not satisfactory." Every spring and summer, "guidance patrols" begin their activities in major cities of Iran with the aim of "dealing with bad hijab." Officials in Hassan Rouhani's government have previously criticized the police's handling of issues like hijab, and Rouhani himself emphasized that "culture cannot be established with vans, minibuses, policemen, and soldiers." Abdolreza Rahmani Fazli, the Minister of Interior, also stated on August 14 that police action in this area has "very high social costs." Mohammad Reza Zaeri, a cleric affiliated with the conservative faction, also emphasized last year in a meeting titled "The First Free Thought Forum on Mandatory Hijab; Priorities and Cultural Requirements of Society" that the "mandatory hijab policy" in the Islamic Republic is "completely wrong." In contrast, Sadegh Amoli Larijani, the head of the Iranian judiciary, stated on April 25 that there are "clear and codified laws" in "dealing with violations such as bad hijab and non-hijab, and all those who commit violations due to negligence or mistake must know that even if they do not personally believe in a law, they must adhere to it." Abbas Jafari Dolat Abadi, the Tehran prosecutor, also previously emphasized that "although the best solution in the area of chastity and hijab is cultural actions," the impact of "countermeasures and punitive tools" or "so-called military actions" in combating "crimes against public decency and morality" should not be overlooked. The head of the Iranian judiciary traveled to Iraq on November 1 and met with officials in that country, including the Prime Minister, the Speaker of Parliament, and the head of the Judicial Council. Larijani also traveled from Baghdad to Najaf on November 4 and has met with several clerics in the city, including Ayatollah Ali Sistani, a prominent Shia cleric. The Najaf seminary is one of the most important Shia seminaries, and Mirza Hashem Amoli, the father of Mohammad Javad, Ali, and Sadegh Larijani, was also a cleric in this seminary. These three brothers hold significant positions in the Islamic Republic of Iran and are all born in Najaf.
Najaf Cleric in Meeting with Sadegh Larijani: Use of Force and Coercion in Promoting Hijab is Ineffective
Ayatollah Mohammad Ishaq Fayyaz, a prominent cleric in Najaf, advised against the use of force in promoting hijab during a meeting with Iranian judiciary chief Sadegh Larijani, suggesting more moderate and cultural approaches. This highlights ongoing debates within Iran regarding the effectiveness of current hijab enforcement policies, as many express dissatisfaction with the government's methods.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Ayatollah Fayyaz advised against using force to enforce hijab laws during a meeting with Sadegh Larijani, suggesting more cultural and moderate approaches. This reflects ongoing debates about the effectiveness of Iran's hijab enforcement policies.
- Fayyaz proposed using media to promote hijab instead of coercion.
- The meeting highlights internal disagreements on hijab enforcement within Iran's leadership.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran has mandated hijab since 1983, but enforcement has faced significant public backlash and criticism from various factions within the government.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%