Perhaps only the news of the existence of two Israeli captives held by Hamas in the Gaza Strip could have temporarily sidelined the daily reactions of Israeli officials and statesmen from the headlines of this country’s media. Last Thursday, Israel was forced to confirm, after months of secrecy, that two of its citizens are alive in captivity by Hamas; an Ethiopian named Avaraham Mengistu and an unnamed Bedouin Arab. Both individuals entered Gaza on foot and were captured there; the 28-year-old Ethiopian Jew has been in captivity for ten months, while the Bedouin Arab has been in Gaza for about three months. However, the fact that one of these captives has a mental illness and the other is Arab immediately turned their captivity report into a relatively ordinary news item, and once again, Israel's 'worried gaze' regarding the potential emergence of 'white smoke' from the Coburg Hotel in Vienna, the site of negotiations between Iran and global powers, topped the reports of Israeli media. While Israel's second television channel claimed on Friday, July 19, that reaching a nuclear agreement between Iran and the P5+1 countries is 'certain in the coming days,' analysts from this channel stated that it is the U.S. and Western powers that have largely 'retreated' from their positions, rather than Iran having made concessions. According to Israel Radio, Tzachi Hanegbi, head of the National Security and Foreign Policy Committee of the Knesset, stated on Thursday that President Barack Obama's remarks, made a day earlier, that 'the likelihood of reaching an agreement with Iran is less than fifty percent,' 'does not reflect the realities, but rather the U.S. is showing a lot of 'anxiety' to reach an agreement.' General Yaakov Amidror, a former national security advisor of Israel, also stated on Thursday, July 18, on Israel Radio that the U.S. has made significant concessions to Iran and has 'significantly' retreated from its previous commitments regarding 'standing firm' against Iran's nuclear program. General Amidror claimed that Iran's request for the lifting of its arms embargo in the negotiations is a 'ruse' and that Iran will backtrack on it so that 'the U.S. can say it managed to get Iran to soften and retreat.' Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu also stated in recent days, as negotiations with Iran seemed to be reaching their final stages, that Iran is 'extorting' in the negotiations and 'with each passing day, negotiators are retreating more before Iran.' On Tuesday, July 16, at a memorial ceremony for Herzl, the founder of the Zionist movement, Netanyahu asked the negotiating powers with Iran: 'How can one trust a country that has repeatedly violated international community decisions, and how can one invest hundreds of billions of dollars more in this country; money that will be used to expand terrorism and dominate the four corners of the world?' Netanyahu had previously posted an animated film against the Iran nuclear agreement on his website; in this 27-second film, Netanyahu claimed that if a 'bad' nuclear agreement with Iran is reached, the dangers posed by Iran would be 'worse' than those of ISIS. Additionally, following the publication of an article last week by Mohammad Javad Zarif, Iran's Foreign Minister, in the British newspaper Financial Times, where he emphasized that after the nuclear agreement, Iran would cooperate with global countries in combating the 'savagery' currently in the Middle East, Dori Gold, director-general of Israel's Foreign Ministry, published an article as a 'response' to Zarif's article in the English newspaper Telegraph. In his article, Dori Gold wrote that Iran itself is an arsonist, and how can one trust this country’s role in extinguishing the fire in the Middle East? Isaac Herzog and Tzipi Livni, leaders of the Israeli opposition, have recently criticized Netanyahu for the deterioration of relations with the U.S. and Israel's relative isolation regarding its relationship with the Washington government, attributing the lack of Israel's influence on the nuclear negotiations to the relative severance of relations with the U.S. However, at the same time, opposition leaders in Israel, in contact with leaders and officials of Western countries, have spoken of the 'serious dangers' of Iran's nuclear program. According to Israeli media reports, Isaac Herzog, leader of the 'Zionist Camp,' the main opposition group in Israel, told British government officials that there is no position or opposition regarding anything related to Iran's nuclear program. However, Israeli analyst Yisrael Harel, on July 10, wrote in Haaretz an article titled 'Who is to Blame for Iran and the Powers Reaching an Agreement?' accusing Meir Dagan, Yuval Diskin, and Gabi Ashkenazi of having strengthened the U.S. position against the Israeli government due to their opposition to Netanyahu's fear-mongering policies regarding Iran's nuclear program. Meir Dagan, former head of Mossad, Yuval Diskin, former head of Shin Bet, Israel's internal security service, and General Gabi Ashkenazi, former chief of staff of the Israeli army, have all raised their voices against the potential military attack by Israel on Iran's nuclear facilities, warning that such an attack would not only be ineffective and would not eliminate Iran's nuclear program, but would also leave Israel in a very dangerous situation for a long time after such a military action; Meir Dagan even spoke of a very dark era for Israel's future in the event of an attack on Iran. However, Yisrael Harel wrote in Haaretz that in Israel being sidelined from the nuclear negotiations and not being timely informed of the latest developments in the talks, Benjamin Netanyahu is the main 'culprit' who has acted 'irresponsibly' towards the U.S. government and has 'burned bridges' with the Barack Obama administration. However, according to this Haaretz writer, Netanyahu is a 'partial culprit' in Iran and the powers reaching an agreement because previous prime ministers before Netanyahu (Ariel Sharon and Ehud Olmert) did not consider the dangers posed by Iran's nuclear program very seriously and did not take the necessary actions in a timely manner regarding it. After Netanyahu's strong opposition to Iran's nuclear program and describing it as a 'vital threat' to Israel's existence, and while he metaphorically said 'bring the hat' and his courtiers brought 'the head,' 'Yisrael Harel' adds that all those Israeli officials who, following Netanyahu and even more vehemently than him, set fire to the relations between Israel and the U.S. are also to blame for Iran's recent success in getting closer to the U.S. and forcing Western powers to soften their stance towards Iran. However, Yair Lapid, leader of the opposition party 'Yesh Atid,' stated in recent days that if a nuclear agreement is reached between Iran and the powers, it would mean the greatest political defeat for Benjamin Netanyahu, who had placed confronting Iran at the top of his government’s agenda. Lapid, who was the finance minister in the previous Israeli government until a few months ago, also stated that Netanyahu should announce his resignation from the premiership due to his failure in policy against Iran.
Nuclear Negotiations in Vienna, Reactions in Israel
Israel confirmed that two of its citizens are held captive by Hamas, while the focus of Israeli media shifts to the ongoing nuclear negotiations in Vienna. Israeli officials express concern over the potential outcomes of these negotiations, with Prime Minister Netanyahu criticizing the U.S. for perceived concessions to Iran. This situation highlights the tensions between Israel and Iran amidst critical diplomatic efforts.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Nuclear negotiations are taking place in Vienna between Iran and the P5+1 countries, with significant reactions from Israeli officials expressing concern over potential concessions by the U.S. and Western powers. Israel confirmed the captivity of two citizens by Hamas, but the focus remains on the nuclear talks.
- Israel is concerned about perceived U.S. concessions in the nuclear negotiations with Iran.
- Two Israeli citizens are confirmed to be held captive by Hamas in Gaza.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The P5+1 countries (U.S., UK, France, Russia, China, and Germany) have been negotiating with Iran to limit its nuclear program in exchange for lifting economic sanctions.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%