Elliott Abrams, former U.S. envoy for Iran and senior member of the Council on Foreign Relations, writes in an article for the Washington Post that if the United States wants to continue paying the Islamic Republic for the freedom of Americans, it must reduce the number of Americans who could potentially be detained in Iran. He initially emphasizes the necessity of rescuing American hostages as a priority and also a terrible dilemma for the government, stating, "Paying cash for their freedom rewards rogue regimes and encourages more illegal behavior." This senior diplomat in the Trump administration refers to the Biden administration's negotiations with the Islamic Republic regarding the release of five American hostages in exchange for six billion dollars, adding that the last such "extortion" occurred in 2016 when the Obama administration paid 1.7 billion dollars for the release of four other hostages. Abrams, quoting Kylie Moore-Gilbert, a British-Australian academic previously imprisoned in Iran, argues against paying ransom to kidnappers, saying, "Punitive measures must be taken publicly and proactively to send a clear signal that in the future, hostage diplomacy will be met with punishment rather than tolerance and reward." He notes that just as U.S. passports are invalid for travel to North Korea, over a thousand Americans travel to Iran annually, and Washington should invalidate U.S. passports for travel to Iran. According to him, Iranian-Americans wishing to reunite with family can do so in neighboring countries like Turkey and the UAE. Elliott Abrams also mentions the detention and imprisonment of Xiyu Wang, an American student, by the Islamic Republic from 2016 to 2019, adding that the second important step should be ensuring that American students do not travel to Iran. The former U.S. envoy for Iran concludes that the frequency of hostage-taking by the Islamic Republic necessitates that Washington take actions beyond complaints, negotiations, and paying "ransom." * The Persian translation of this article is published solely for informational purposes, and the opinions expressed do not reflect the views of Voice of America.
Perspective | The Islamic Republic and the Six Billion Dollar Hostage Trade
Elliott Abrams argues that the U.S. should stop paying ransom to Iran for American hostages, suggesting that this only encourages further hostage-taking. He proposes invalidating U.S. passports for travel to Iran to protect Americans. This discussion highlights ongoing tensions between the U.S. and Iran regarding hostage diplomacy.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Elliott Abrams argues against the U.S. paying ransom to Iran for American hostages, suggesting it encourages further hostage-taking. He proposes measures to protect Americans from being detained in Iran.
- The Biden administration is negotiating the release of five American hostages for six billion dollars.
- Abrams cites a previous ransom payment by the Obama administration in 2016 for the release of four hostages.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Hostage diplomacy has been a tactic used by Iran to extract concessions from the U.S. and other countries, complicating diplomatic relations.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%