Also available in Persian — نسخه فارسی ✈️ Telegram EN فا
❓ Unknown

Protest by Zoroastrian Representative Against Isfahan Friday Prayer Leader

Jan 29, 2026 January 29, 2026 12 min read 📰 Radio Farda
📋 Key Takeaway

Esfandiar Ekhtiari, the Zoroastrian representative in the Iranian parliament, protested against Isfahan's Friday Prayer leader Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad's remarks labeling Zoroastrians as dualists. The controversy highlights ongoing tensions between Zoroastrians and the Iranian government, which officially recognizes Zoroastrianism yet sometimes refers to it negatively.

🔍 Quick Context Guide
💡 Bottom Line: The protest underscores ongoing tensions between Iran's Shia majority and its Zoroastrian minority, reflecting deeper societal issues.

👥 Key Players

Esfandiar Ekhtiari MENTIONED
Zoroastrian representative in the Islamic Consultative Assembly
"Represents the interests of the Zoroastrian community, which is one of the officially recognized minority religions in Iran."
Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad MENTIONED
Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan
"A prominent clerical figure whose statements can influence public perception and inter-religious relations in Iran."

📰 What Happened

Esfandiar Ekhtiari protested against remarks made by Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad, who labeled Zoroastrians as dualists during a Friday sermon. Ekhtiari called for an end to divisive rhetoric that undermines the status of Zoroastrians in Iran.

  • Zoroastrianism is officially recognized in Iran but is sometimes disparaged by government figures.
  • Tabatabai-Nejad's comments reflect ongoing tensions between Shia Islam and Zoroastrianism.

💡 Why It Matters

🇮🇷 For Iran: The incident highlights the fragile status of religious minorities in Iran and raises questions about the government's approach to religious tolerance.
🌍 Regional: This controversy may resonate with other religious minorities in the region, influencing their relations with the state.
🌐 International: International observers may view this as indicative of Iran's broader human rights issues regarding religious freedom.

📚 Background

Zoroastrianism, one of the world's oldest religions, is recognized in Iran but often faces discrimination. The Iranian government officially prohibits conversion from Islam to other religions.

Religious minorities in Iran Iran's human rights record
📡 Source: NEUTRAL
📊 Confidence: 70%
The article presents a factual account of the incident without apparent bias, focusing on the perspectives of key figures involved.

"Iranians are proud of their civilization and culture throughout the tumultuous history of this land, and being monotheistic is one of the proud aspects." With this statement, Esfandiar Ekhtiari, the Zoroastrian representative in the Islamic Consultative Assembly, has strongly protested in an open letter to the Friday Prayer Leader of Isfahan at the end of last week. A week prior, Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad, the Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan, referred to Zoroastrians as dualists. In his letter, the Zoroastrian representative requested that the Friday Prayer leader refrain from making what he described as "divisive" statements. Zoroastrianism is an official religion in Iran, but sometimes some government institutions refer to it as a "false religion and the cult of fire worship." This same Zoroastrian representative had previously protested to the mayor of Khorramshahr in another letter during the summer, questioning why Zoroastrianism was mentioned at a conference discussing false sects. On the other hand, the Iranian government does not recognize conversion from Islam to another religion. However, the office of the same Friday Prayer leader in Isfahan announced last winter that one of the Zoroastrians in Isfahan had converted to Islam. What motivated Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad's statements during the Friday Prayer on October 18? What is the relationship between the Shia clergy and the Iranian government with Zoroastrians? These are the main questions posed to three guests on this week's program "Views": Mohammad Ali Dadkhah, a lawyer in Tehran; Parviz Ravani, former representative of Zoroastrians in the fourth and fifth terms of the Islamic Consultative Assembly in Toronto; and Hassan Farshchian, a Shia religious scholar in Paris. The background of Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad's statements during the Friday Prayer on October 13, where he described Zoroastrians as believing in two gods, is questioned. Is it related to the city's situation or his personal views? Greetings to all Iranians, friends of Iran, and especially to our esteemed compatriots of the Zoroastrian faith, who are considered the heirs of this ancient civilization. We have a rule in philosophy that says: "the essence of the union is the essence of the attachment." Mulla Sadra also addressed this. In simpler terms, you can weld iron to iron, but you can never weld wood to iron. The Quran in the 17th part of Surah Al-Hajj, verse 16, states: "Indeed, those who have believed and those who are Jews and the Sabians... and finally the Magians." The meaning of this verse is that God distinguishes between believers, Jews, Sabians, Christians, Magians, and polytheists. If we come to believe that they are dualists, it means we have come to believe that they are polytheists, and such a matter is completely unacceptable. Apart from this, one of the greatest religious scholars of our time, Mr. Ataollah Shahabpour, believes that the heart of the Quran is in Ayat al-Kursi, which speaks of the essence of God: "Allah, there is no god but Allah. He is the Living, the Sustainer..." Then he says we must turn to Yasin. Yasin is the heart of Yasna. For this reason, Yasin comes first, meaning Yasna comes first, and then the Holy Quran comes, and then about the messengers. Do you think his view is due to the events currently happening in Isfahan, or has he reached this conclusion and come to express it? I think if they have reached this conclusion, it shows that they did not have sufficient depth of thought. Even a normal view was lacking. Because Zoroastrianism is monotheistic, and according to many researchers, it is much purer than Hebrew religions and other religions. All of them say that God, in Zoroastrianism, is the creator of everything, both material and spiritual. And you see only one will in the Gathas that has created the world, and that will is Ahura Mazda. Mr. Ravani, you were previously the representative of Zoroastrians in the Islamic Consultative Assembly. At the end of this week, Esfandiar Ekhtiari, the Zoroastrian representative in the Assembly, reacted to the statements of the Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan and called for avoiding divisiveness. What could be the outcome of this reaction from Esfandiar Ekhtiari based on your experience in these matters? Greetings to my dear compatriots and to you friends who are working to inform the people. Mr. Ekhtiari must take certain precautions, just as we did at that time. Because we did not want to create division and problems in our society. When the leader says that the emergence of monotheistic Zoroastrianism in Iran is a source of pride for Iranians, how can his representative, Mr. Tabatabai-Nejad, make such statements that they are dualists? This shows the chaos that exists in this government. Unfortunately, these gentlemen, due to their ignorance, sometimes make statements that they cannot retract later. Those who make these statements can be divided into several groups. First, there are those who are poorly informed. For example, when I entered the Assembly during my fifth term, a cleric who was one of the representatives came to me and asked which of the infallible Imams I did not accept. Let’s come to an understanding so that you are also recognized as a religion from the perspective of Islam. I just laughed at him. That’s it. This means that his knowledge is so limited that he does not know that the Zoroastrian faith fundamentally does not accept such a thing. How could he think that? Not even once has he read the constitution to know that we Zoroastrians are among the recognized religions. The second group consists of those who, observing that many Muslims are returning to their ancestral religion... at that time, I also witnessed that despite all the problems they created for them, they reacted. Like Mr. Tabatabai-Nejad, who says that a Zoroastrian has converted to Islam in Isfahan, and he or his office has converted him to Islam. Of course, bribery or coercion has existed for 1400 years to convert non-Muslims to Islam. It is nothing new. An example of this is also present in today’s laws in Iran. Article 881 of the Civil Code states that a non-Muslim does not inherit from a Muslim; if there is a Muslim among the heirs of a non-Muslim, all inheritance goes to him, which is evidence of this. Bribery and coercion have existed and continue to exist. The last group consists of those who receive salaries. They are mercenaries. They receive salaries from various places to destroy the history of Iran. Now I will not go into this topic because it requires a lot of time. In the next turn, if you want, we can continue the discussion. Mr. Farshchian, how has the Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan deemed it appropriate to raise theological discussions in the Friday sermon? Greetings to you and the friends present in the studio, as well as to the esteemed listeners, and with respect to our Zoroastrian compatriots. Regarding why he [Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad, the Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan] raised this discussion, apparently he was speaking about monotheism in his Friday sermon. You know that in theology, we have several kinds of monotheism: active monotheism, essential monotheism, and worshipful monotheism, each of which has definitions that are specified in theology, which state that the essence of God is one. His actions are one, and we must worship the one God. In the course of his discussion, he made a reference to the fact that Zoroastrians believe in two gods. That is, the creator of the world is two gods: one who creates good and one who creates evil. This perspective has existed since the early days of Islam and even before Islam. That is, at the time of the Prophet, when he returned to Mecca, he established a governmental structure and divided people into three groups based on faith: Muslims, who were called believers, or the people of the book, and polytheists. The verse 17 of Surah Al-Hajj that Mr. Dadkhah referred to is regarding these three groups: "Indeed, those who have believed" and then "and those who are Jews," Christians, and Zoroastrians, and "the Sabians and the Christians and the Magians" become the second group. And the third group "and those who associated partners" means the polytheists. Then, regarding the people of the book, they were tolerant towards them. They recognized them in such a way that they allowed them to remain in their faith and pay a kind of supportive tax called jizya. At that time, some polytheists and idolaters came to the Prophet and said, "We will also pay this tax so that we can continue our idol worship." The Prophet said no. This jizya tax and support are specific to the people of the book, not to you polytheists. Those [polytheist idolaters] protested that if it is specific to the people of the book and not to polytheists, why did you take jizya from the Magi? In an area in Yemen. [They responded to the Prophet that] they are also like us polytheists, and you took it from them as well. I want to say that this perspective that they [Zoroastrians] are polytheists and believe in a kind of dualism existed even before Islam in Arabia [mistakenly]. After that, the Prophet explained that no, this is not the case, and they [Zoroastrians] are people of the book: "They had a prophet who was killed and a book that was burned," meaning that from our perspective, they [Zoroastrians] are considered people of the book. I presented this introduction to say that perhaps [the misunderstanding of Zoroastrian beliefs] stemmed from the fact that many Arabs did not understand the philosophy of good and evil, that is, the duality of the world, and thought that those who believe that there are two kinds of good and evil in the world can easily be labeled as polytheists and dualists. This discussion remained present in Islamic texts and among Muslims. Even in the early days of Islam, some caliphs, due to criticisms they had towards Iranians and Magians and Zoroastrians, tried at one point to classify them as polytheists. However, the second school that existed in Islam resisted this and believed that they are people of the book and are not polytheists. Among them are narrations from the Imams of Shia, including Imam Ali, Imam Baqir, and Imam Sadiq, stating that these [Zoroastrians] are monotheists. I believe that Mr. Youssef Tabatabai-Nejad entered a theological discussion when he discussed monotheism and expressed a view, while the prevailing view among the Shia Imams is that they are people of the book and are considered monotheists. Moreover, the Islamic constitution in its thirteenth article accepts this theory and considers them people of the book and monotheists. The last point is that when they themselves say this, there is no reason to even engage in complex philosophical and theological discussions to consider them dualists. I think that Mr. Esfandiar Ekhtiari, the esteemed representative of the Zoroastrians, acted very reasonably and politely advised unity, which unfortunately was not observed in the Friday sermon. Mr. Dadkhah, considering the legal status of Zoroastrians in the Islamic Consultative Assembly, what is the obligation regarding uttering statements like those made by the Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan? We must pay attention to two points. First, in the constitutional law of a hundred years ago, it was explicitly stated that non-Muslims who believe in the oneness of God should be supported. Zoroastrians were among them. Based on this thought, this criterion was repeated in the constitution of the Islamic Republic without any discussion. This rule counts. The right thing was that the Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan had a little perspective on these matters. Furthermore, we know that the Gathas are the first source and the highest authority through which Zoroastrians declare their religion. In verses seven and eight of the Gathas, we read: "O wise Lord, when I perceived you in my thought, indeed, I recognized you as the beginning and the end of existence, and with the eye of the heart, I saw you as the father and the good spirit and the true judge who examines the actions of all people." In the next verse, we read: "Ahura Mazda is the first thinker whose light is reflected in the heavenly lights and with his power of wisdom created the eternal law of truth to be a helper and supporter of the good thinkers." These are precisely declarations of one God. Dualism does not actually exist in true Zoroastrianism. Those [like the Friday Prayer leader of Isfahan] are individuals who, with their misunderstandings, have tainted the Zoroastrian religion with dualism or duality. The reality is that it was the first monotheistic religion in Iran, and the first prophet and the first poet in human history is Prophet Zoroaster. Given that we cannot negate the jurisprudence, Zoroastrians are entitled to all rights and are considered our religious compatriots. Mr. Ravani, you were talking about your experience during your representation in the Islamic Consultative Assembly. What was that experience regarding the view of the government clergy towards your religion? I do not want to go into the details of the issues because I do not want to say things that would cause further division. But I will point out some points that may help understand why these gentlemen make these statements. Dualism was prevalent among the Zoroastrians, one of the religions before Zoroastrianism. Zoroastrians considered time to be God. They said time gave birth to two sons: one, Ahriman, and the other, Ahura. Ahura was a god that existed before Zoroaster among various peoples. According to the Zoroastrians, these two, Ahura and Ahriman, are constantly in conflict. This dualistic belief of the Zoroastrians existed. But the one God of Zoroaster is Ahura Mazda. This word [Ahura Mazda] consists of two parts. One is Ahura, meaning the creator, and the other part is Mazda. Maz comes from the word "great." Da means "wise." Therefore, the God of Zoroaster becomes the great wise creator or the wise great creator.

🌐

Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →

Translation confidence: 85%

📰 Related Coverage

⚖️ Independent Platform — Artesh.com is not affiliated with any government, military, or political organization. Editorial Policy →