Some social media users considered the threat made by the Deputy Security Chief of Tehran Province regarding "decisive action" against protesters in Tehran to be contradictory to the Citizens' Rights Charter presented by the government. While reports indicate a heavy presence of security forces in the streets of Tehran, Mohsen Nasj Hamdani, the Deputy Security Chief of Tehran Province, announced that "no permit for public gatherings has been issued by the provincial government so far, and decisive action will be taken by the police in the event of such gatherings." These threatening remarks came after the expansion of protests in cities such as Mashhad, Nishapur, Kashmar, and Shahroud under the slogan "No to Price Hikes," which spread to Kermanshah, Tehran, Quchan, Isfahan, Rasht, Ahvaz, and Qom. Videos shared from some of these protests on social media show that people are not only voicing economic slogans and complaints about poverty, corruption, and embezzlement in Iran but are also criticizing the ruling clergy, even praying for the soul of Reza Shah Pahlavi in Qom, the most religious city in Iran. Nasj Hamdani's threatening remarks followed statements from Eshaq Jahangiri, the First Vice President under Hassan Rouhani, who implicitly attributed the organization of protests in several cities of Razavi Khorasan Province to government opponents, stating that "the initiators of street movements will not be the ones to end them." Jahangiri also added that "economic issues have become a pretext for other matters. There are other issues behind the scenes." However, several political figures, including Mahmoud Sadeghi, a member of parliament, reacted to these government officials' positions on Twitter, stating that "if the protests are organized, government officials must be held accountable. Instead of accountability, we should not resort to conspiracy theories." Sadeghi also wrote that "holding a rally without carrying weapons is a fundamental right of the people. The government must respect the fundamental rights of the people in practice, not just in slogans and unnecessary structures of the Citizens' Rights Deputy." In addition to this parliament member, many other social media users criticized the way Hassan Rouhani's government officials are handling people's protests regarding inflation, unemployment, and other issues. "Mahdi," a Twitter user, reacted to the Deputy Governor of Tehran's statement that "no permits have been issued for these gatherings so far," writing, "Do you know that this very sentence from the executive branch officials, who are supposed to uphold the constitution, is against the constitution?" "Mediar," a human rights activist, assessed the Deputy Governor's threat of action against "illegal gatherings" in Tehran as "a clear threat for exercising a legal right," stating that "peaceful protest is the right of the people." "Amir Yaqoubi" also sarcastically tweeted that "a legal gathering is one that the television subtitles for a week. All others are always illegal. The way they say no permits have been issued makes it seem like they have ever been issued." Another user named "Abr Gharan" reminded of Article 27 of the constitution, which states that "forming assemblies and marches, without carrying weapons, is free as long as it does not disrupt the principles of Islam," asking, "Does anyone see the need for a permit here!??" Another user named "Azma" referred to the behavior and security composition of Rouhani's government, writing, "This permit thing was only bad during Mahmoud's time; now it's not a problem at all." "Kobayashi" also tweeted that "this gathering permit thing is ridiculous. It seems that apart from the Islamic Propaganda Organization, no group has ever been able to get a gathering permit." "Zohar" tweeted, "Only at specific times and for specific individuals is it allowed to gather spontaneously." "The Dark Knight," another Twitter user, referred to Rouhani's Citizens' Rights Charter, tweeting that this charter "has turned out to be yellow from the government of hope and prudence." "Minaz" tweeted, "They talk about legal permits in such a way that anyone who doesn't know would think you can easily get a permit for a public gathering." "Niyusha Sarami," a journalist, wrote, "A government that came to power with the slogan of defending citizens' rights and has drafted a Citizens' Rights Charter... does not recognize the inherent and legitimate right of the people to peaceful assembly and promises decisive action instead." "Amir Ebtehaj," another journalist, wrote on Twitter, "Isn't peaceful assembly a right for everyone? Is this how the government wanted to defend citizens' rights? I wish instead of threatening and intimidating people, they would listen to their demands." Another Twitter user named "Rainbow Green" wrote, "They said they would deal harshly with any gathering in the capital. This means that if you want to exercise Article 27 of the constitution, you will be met with extreme brutality." Hassan Rouhani, who has recently faced a wave of public protests in several Iranian cities, previously signed a 120-article Citizens' Rights Charter in December 2016. He also promised that if he won the presidential election, his government would send a bill to create a "National Citizens' Rights Institution" to the parliament within the first 100 days of his term. Article 46 of the Citizens' Rights Charter states: "It is the right of citizens to freely and in accordance with the law form assemblies and marches and participate in them, and they should enjoy the neutrality of responsible agencies and protection of the security of gatherings." This charter, which had previously faced severe criticism from conservatives such as Sadegh Larijani, the head of the judiciary, and was evaluated by some experts as merely symbolic, has once again drawn attention amid recent protests. Social media users have called on the government to adhere to the provisions of this charter and to allow free holding of protest gatherings based on Article 27 of the constitution; gatherings that have targeted Hassan Rouhani's government and other pillars of the regime in recent days.
Protests and the Test of Citizens' Rights Under Rouhani's Government
Protests against economic issues have escalated in Iran, prompting threats from government officials against demonstrators. The government's response contradicts its own Citizens' Rights Charter, raising concerns about the treatment of citizens' rights and freedoms. This situation highlights the ongoing tensions between the Iranian government and its citizens regarding basic rights.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Protests against economic issues have intensified across various Iranian cities, prompting threats from government officials against demonstrators. This response contradicts the government's own Citizens' Rights Charter, raising concerns about citizens' rights and freedoms.
- Protests have spread to multiple cities including Tehran, Mashhad, and Isfahan under the slogan 'No to Price Hikes.'
- Government officials have threatened decisive action against any public gatherings, despite constitutional rights to assembly.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran has a history of protests driven by economic issues and political repression, with citizens often challenging the government's legitimacy. The Citizens' Rights Charter was introduced to address these concerns but has been criticized as ineffective.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%