Also available in Persian — نسخه فارسی ✈️ Telegram EN فا
❓ Unknown

Providing a 'Thin Stream' of Income for All in Service of Economic Freedom

Jan 30, 2026 January 30, 2026 9 min read 📰 Radio Farda
📋 Key Takeaway

A recent Swiss referendum on 'unconditional basic income' was overwhelmingly rejected, prompting reflections in Iran due to similarities with its own cash subsidy program. Experts in Iran praised the Swiss decision, arguing that providing a fixed income to all citizens is unrealistic and potentially populist. The article discusses the implications of such income proposals and the necessity of economic freedom to support them.

🔍 Quick Context Guide
💡 Bottom Line: The Swiss rejection of unconditional basic income serves as a cautionary tale for Iran and other nations considering similar economic policies.

👥 Key Players

Swiss Citizens MENTIONED
Voters in the referendum
"Their decision reflects public sentiment towards economic policies that could influence similar discussions in Iran."
Iranian Experts MENTIONED
Commentators on economic policies
"Their analysis shapes public and governmental understanding of economic proposals like basic income."

📰 What Happened

On June 5, Swiss voters overwhelmingly rejected a proposal for an unconditional basic income, which sparked discussions in Iran due to similarities with its own cash subsidy program. Iranian experts praised the Swiss decision as a rational response to unrealistic economic proposals.

  • 77% of Swiss voters rejected the unconditional basic income proposal.
  • The proposal aimed to provide 2,500 Swiss francs monthly to all adults, costing the government approximately 208 billion Swiss francs.

💡 Why It Matters

🇮🇷 For Iran: The Swiss referendum outcome may influence Iranian public opinion and policy discussions regarding economic subsidies and welfare programs.
🌍 Regional: It highlights the challenges of implementing universal income schemes in economically diverse regions.
🌐 International: The rejection of such a proposal in a wealthy country like Switzerland could impact global perceptions of universal basic income viability.

📚 Background

Universal basic income is a proposed economic policy aimed at providing all citizens with a regular, unconditional sum of money, which has been debated globally as a solution to poverty and economic insecurity.

Universal Basic Income Targeted Subsidies
📡 Source: NEUTRAL
📊 Confidence: 70%
The article provides a balanced view, reflecting both Swiss and Iranian perspectives on economic policies without overt bias.

The referendum held on June 5 in Switzerland regarding the 'unconditional basic income' proposal and the overwhelming negative vote from the majority of the Swiss people had a wide reflection in Iranian political, social, and economic circles; mainly due to the similarities between this proposal and the universal cash subsidy payments under the well-known 'targeted subsidies' law. There were experts who, influenced by these similarities, commented on what happened in Switzerland. First, let’s address the main issue. Swiss law allows its citizens to put constitutional amendment proposals to a referendum, provided that any proposal has the support of at least one hundred thousand people. The proposal that was put to a vote on June 5 suggested that the right to receive an 'unconditional basic income' be included in the Swiss Confederation's constitution. If this proposal were approved, all citizens of legal age, as well as foreign adults who had lived in the country for at least five years, would receive a monthly cash subsidy of 2,500 Swiss francs (equivalent to 2,260 euros) unconditionally and regardless of their income level. For Swiss citizens under legal age, a monthly cash subsidy of 650 Swiss francs was proposed. On June 5, forty-six percent of Swiss citizens participated in the referendum, and seventy-seven percent voted against the 'unconditional basic income' proposal. This Swiss event, when reflected in Iran, is naturally compared to the well-known 'targeted subsidies' law and its consequences. Many Iranian experts, influenced by the very negative consequences of implementing this law, praised the Swiss people for their decisive negative response to the 'unconditional basic income' proposal. In their view, the idea of providing a fixed, unconditional monthly income to all citizens of a country is, at best, 'fantasy' and, at worst, 'populist', aimed at attracting the votes of the naive. Therefore, from this perspective, the Swiss people's negative and resounding response to this proposal showcased their rationality, while many Iranians, even with average and high incomes, were unwilling to give up the 45,000 tomans monthly subsidy. What happened in Switzerland is much more complex than that. In fact, the people of this country created two masterpieces with the referendum on 'unconditional basic income' and their response. The first masterpiece was that they demonstrated that the idea of providing a universal, permanent, and unconditional income is not a mad thought and can even be proposed in a country like Switzerland with its remarkable progress, vast social capital, and high rationality. The second masterpiece of the Swiss people was their negative response to this proposal. The designers of the 'unconditional basic income' intended to impose a heavy financial burden equivalent to about 208 billion Swiss francs on the Confederation's budget without convincing voters about how to finance such costs. Some of those who voted against the proposal did so not because they opposed the idea itself but because they disagreed with the very high level of monthly income proposed. However, the core issue, which is fighting poverty by providing a 'thin stream' (meaning a small but guaranteed and permanent income), is by no means fanciful or demagogic. Currently, in many European countries, trends from various political and intellectual spectrums (ranging from liberals to socialists and even some extremist right and left movements) are increasingly paying attention to the necessity of providing this 'thin stream'. This idea is not new. For about four centuries, several Western thinkers have proposed the idea of providing a minimum income to combat poverty; from the English Thomas More in the sixteenth century to the English Thomas Paine (who later became American and French) in the eighteenth century and the American John Rawls in the twentieth century. However, the most coherent and practical idea in this regard, under the title of 'negative income tax', was proposed by Milton Friedman, a Nobel laureate and one of the most important pioneers of liberal thought in the twentieth century. 'Positive tax' is the money that citizens pay to the government. 'Negative tax' is the money that the government pays to citizens. Chapter twelve of Milton Friedman's book addresses this topic. Inspired by Milton Friedman, a very simple scenario can be proposed without delving into technical details. Consider an advanced industrial country with a population of one hundred million that decides to pay all citizens over eighteen years old one thousand dollars monthly and five hundred dollars to those under eighteen. Citizens whose monthly income from the thousand dollars (negative tax) does not exceed this amount are exempt from paying taxes. However, for any additional dollar, they must pay taxes. Suppose in the country in question, twenty-five percent of each citizen's income (beyond the unconditional universal income) must be spent on taxes. A citizen who receives an additional thousand dollars from the government must pay two hundred and fifty dollars in taxes. In this case, their net income from the government decreases to seven hundred and fifty dollars (one thousand dollars minus two hundred and fifty dollars). A citizen whose monthly income, in addition to the thousand dollars received from the government, reaches ten thousand dollars must pay two thousand five hundred dollars in taxes. Of course, since they received a thousand dollars as 'negative tax' from the government, their actual tax is effectively one thousand five hundred dollars per month. In other words, a citizen with a ten thousand dollar income does not receive any money from the government and pays taxes. This calculation can be continued for various income levels. This is the most effective way found so far to combat poverty while preserving freedom, responsibility, and human dignity. Why is it decided that all citizens of this hypothetical country should receive 'negative tax' or 'unconditional basic income'? Simply because the heavy burden of a vast bureaucracy to determine who is deserving and who is not is eliminated. Moreover, no one feels ashamed of receiving this basic income due to its 'universality'. Additionally, no one has to account to others for what they want to do with their thousand dollars. This 'thin stream' can become a powerful lever in providing financial security, freedom, and human dignity. A citizen may want to make do with the thousand dollars a month, live in rural and low-cost areas, and spend their days wandering in nature, listening to music, or writing novels. Another young citizen, who loves economic creativity and becoming wealthy, can venture into new experiences in production and commerce without fearing failure and hunger, because the 'thin stream' is there for them. However, the provision of this universal income has conditions that, if not met, make its continuation impossible. In a society that accepts this principle, the fundamental mechanisms of a free economy must be recognized as valid. Prices must be subject to supply and demand rather than being captive to price-setting authorities. All goods, from energy carriers to the cost of using trains and airplanes, must have their real prices and, in other words, should not be subsidized. Monopolistic entities that prevent free competition to defend their interests must be eliminated, and the way must be opened for entrepreneurship and creativity. The labor market must be freed from cumbersome regulations that yield nothing but unemployment. The minimum wage also has no place, and there is assurance that wage earners, relying on that 'thin stream', will have greater ability to defend their rights against employers. In short, only with economic freedom can the necessary conditions for providing a universal basic income be created through wealth creation. In relation to this condition of economic freedom, the principle of providing universal subsidies in Iran under the well-known 'targeted subsidies' law is called into question. The designers of this law implemented it within one of the most closed economies in the world. In a country trapped in oil revenues and having an economy shackled by monopolies and cumbersome regulations, especially under the pressure of the toughest sanctions since World War II, the payment of universal cash subsidies became a new burden for the country's economy, to the extent that the executive apparatus had to allocate a significant portion of the credits planned for development projects to cash subsidies. We see the consequences of this bitter experience: prices in Iran remain unrealistic, class gaps are increasing, and there is no sign of creativity and economic freedom. Another point that fuels the discussion about this universal income is the perspective created by the digital revolution. Futurists have differing opinions about the impact of this event on the labor market. Some believe that, as with previous industrial revolutions, many job opportunities will disappear while more will be created. Conversely, other research, published by very credible sources, predicts a worrying future for the labor market given the dizzying scientific and technological advancements. For example, in a report titled 'The Future of Jobs', related to the 'Davos 2016' report, it is stated that due to the exponential increase in the number of robots and the process of 'self-automation' or automation and the rise of artificial intelligence, over the next five years, more than seven million jobs will disappear in fifteen industrial powers, and only two million new jobs will be created. It is possible that such pessimistic predictions may not come true. However, forward-looking societies consider various scenarios and prepare to face all of them. Providing a universal basic income is one way to combat the mass unemployment that some pessimistic scenarios predict. Currently, some advanced European countries have turned to field experiments in this area and are implementing the universal basic income proposal in a limited geographical and demographic manner. Finland and the Netherlands are at the forefront in this regard. The designers of the 'unconditional basic income' proposal in Switzerland aimed to move from a limited testing phase of this program to its full implementation on a nationwide scale. However, given the very high proposed income and the many ambiguities regarding how to finance it, they lost. Yet beyond the loss of the supporters of the Swiss referendum, the idea of providing universal income is significantly advancing. Simultaneously, in relation to this idea, the foundations of classical liberalism are undergoing transformation. Classical liberals recognized three main sovereign duties for the state: being a police force (to ensure internal security), being a judge (to oversee the enforcement of laws), and being a soldier (to maintain border security). It can be said that modern liberalism also recognizes a fourth duty for itself: guaranteeing a minimum income for all.

🌐

Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →

Translation confidence: 85%

📰 Related Coverage

⚖️ Independent Platform — Artesh.com is not affiliated with any government, military, or political organization. Editorial Policy →