After 38 years of nepotism, unreasonable foreign trips, pilgrimage and Hajj at the government's expense, collusion, embezzlement, exclusive import and export licenses, contracts and projects awarded without bidding, personal use of state resources (like cars), converting state recreational centers into family recreational centers, appropriating state resources under the guise of privatization, allocating low-interest loans from state banks to themselves and their close ones, and various other corruptions and abuses by the managers of the Islamic Republic, government-affiliated media and those close to Khamenei have suddenly remembered the high salaries of state managers, especially those in companies and institutions affiliated with the government. The close associates of the ruling elite know that in the context of economic recession and relatively high and increasing unemployment, such revelations can weaken the position of the governments. They have just remembered the increasing class divide (the ruling class and the condemned class) without considering their own status as members of the ruling class. Over the past 38 years, the only flow of resources that has been generously and without current auditing has been that of the managers and their close associates. Independent capitalism and a market-based economy do not exist in today’s Iran. Wherever you see large capital, companies, and institutions, you can definitely find their connection with the government and the rents and privileges arising from it. No large capital in Iran comes from invention, discovery, entrepreneurship, or starting a business in competitive and free conditions. Unfortunately, in Iran, those who talk about transparency and fighting corruption and waste (like Ahmad Tavakoli and Hossein Shariatmadari) are themselves and their close ones deeply involved in corruption and abuse of public resources. Fighting corruption within the framework of free media may be possible, but those claiming to fight corruption in Iran are serious enemies of independent and free media. Why are there salaries in the tens of millions? Except for some managers and board members of financial, banking, and insurance sectors who receive salaries and benefits in the hundreds of millions, state managers usually receive salaries and benefits in the tens of millions. In a country where the minimum wage for hourly workers is about $1.25, this level of salaries and benefits for state managers in Iran reflects their view of their own competencies and the value of their work to higher authorities. This view does not match their level of competence. If you look at the backgrounds of state managers in the Islamic Republic, most of them have reached these positions without any competence (even without a diploma) and solely based on political and factional relationships or experience in military, paramilitary, and security institutions. The most important justification of the government for paying these high salaries and benefits is the issue of the 'dignity' of the manager. The Islamic Republic does not respect the human dignity of Iranian citizens in any case, but the dignity of the clergy and state managers is observed far beyond their level of competence. State managers in Iran could not have reached these positions without being privileged and connected. The struggle of individuals to obtain these positions is precisely due to the benefits and rents that are granted to managers. The unprecedented increase in their numbers during Ahmadinejad's era was also for the greater distribution of rent. Astronomical salaries do not belong to Rouhani's government. This has been common in all periods, but during Ahmadinejad's government, with the increase in oil revenues and the thirst of Ahmadinejad's managers for plundering public budgets, the amounts received without effective parliamentary oversight increased, and the titles received became more diverse. This continued in Rouhani's government as well. The salaries of managers of appointed institutions and those under the leader's supervision are mainly discussed in the exchanges between the close associates of the ruling elite and state managers, primarily concerning the salaries of executive branch managers. However, no one knows or dares to investigate the salaries of managers of economic institutions and appointed bodies under the leader's supervision. How much do hundreds of industry managers under the management of the Foundation of the Oppressed or the Executive Headquarters of Imam's Command receive? How much do the managers of Astan Quds Razavi receive? They are generally outside of this discussion because no one dares to approach the institutions under the leader's supervision. If on a working morning, 200,000 people (the number of state and governmental managers at various levels) were randomly gathered from 40 squares in major cities (5,000 people per square) and assigned to existing managerial positions according to their numbers without any inquiries about their work and educational backgrounds, the management of the country would definitely improve because 1. In the selection of existing managers, it must have been ensured that they are obedient and compliant to the ruling elite, the Revolutionary Guards, the police, intelligence and security institutions, the managers of the three branches, and the Friday prayer leaders. In a situation where dozens of high-ranking managers and clerics, who themselves have no managerial qualifications, are supposed to agree on some individuals, they can only agree on the weakest individuals in terms of efficiency and competence. In the Islamic Republic, agreeing on the most efficient managers is impossible because ideological and unprofessional factors will definitely intervene; 2. Random selection from the squares of major cities at least provides the possibility that individuals with greater qualifications and efficiency will be among the managers; this would also increase the ethnic, religious, and local diversity of the managers; 3. Today, unlike the early years of the establishment of the Islamic Republic, there is no possibility for new forces to enter the ranks of high and middle-level managers in the country. The ruling caste is now a nearly closed caste, and the same permanent members are shuffled among various institutions over different periods. Occasionally, mid-level managers rise and take the place of higher managers, but no one from outside can join the existing managers; 4. The behavior and attitudes of the current managers in the country show that they have not been able to gain sufficient experience over the past 38 years because 1) gaining experience and applying it requires basic education that most of them lack, and 2) experience means being driven out by existing authorities. The leadership apparatus and the institutions under it do not want experience, efficiency, and expertise; they want loyalty. Managers who criticize the current situation based on experience are sidelined. Following the wave of criticism against these salaries and benefits and after the president's order for addressing the issue, ultimately a few state managers resigned and were dismissed, and some will return to the government in a nominal way, but the previous routine will not change because state management in the Islamic Republic is a kind of reward for serving the regime (in the repression organization; praising the leader, supporting in key points) and its survival, and rewards are never reduced but rather increased. Reducing rewards leads to a collapse that the government does not want. The government fundamentally wants its managers to be the owners of the wealth and resources of the country so that everything remains under the control of the government. The uproar is noise for political competition ahead of the 96 elections and a display of fighting corruption and favoritism.
The Astonishing Salaries and Benefits of Government and State Managers in Iran
The article discusses the astonishing salaries and benefits of Iranian government managers amidst economic recession and increasing unemployment. It highlights the disconnect between these high salaries and the qualifications of the managers, many of whom are appointed based on political connections rather than merit. This situation reflects systemic corruption and the ruling elite's disregard for the economic struggles of ordinary citizens.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The article reveals the high salaries and benefits of Iranian government managers, highlighting systemic corruption and political favoritism. It criticizes the disconnect between the managers' compensation and their qualifications, amid economic hardship for ordinary citizens.
- Government managers receive disproportionately high salaries compared to the general population.
- Appointments are often based on political connections rather than merit.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's political system is heavily influenced by the Supreme Leader and Revolutionary Guards, with economic management often linked to political loyalty.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%