The United States could have a field presence in Ukraine; however, not in the way many expect. In a recent phone conversation between Donald Trump and Volodymyr Zelensky, the presidents of the US and Ukraine, during which Kyiv agreed to a 30-day ceasefire, the topic of US presence in Ukraine's nuclear power plants was also raised. Zelensky stated that he discussed the possibility of US assistance in rebuilding Zaporizhia with Trump. Zaporizhia is the largest nuclear power plant in Europe and has been under Russian occupation since March 2022. The Ukrainian president added, 'I said that just ending the occupation [of Zaporizhia] is not enough, because there must be infrastructure there: water supply, technical personnel, and many other steps so that the plant can start bringing money and electricity to the people in the future.' The White House also stated in its announcement regarding the phone call between the two leaders that Trump told Zelensky that US ownership of the electricity supply and nuclear power plants in Ukraine 'would be the best protection for these facilities.' Trump described the conversation as a 'very good' dialogue with Zelensky. Experts who spoke with the Ukrainian section of Radio Free Europe expressed cautious optimism about the proposed presence of US nuclear staff in Ukraine, stating that such a move would provide a strong security guarantee and be a step in the right direction for transferring Ukraine's nuclear power from Russia to the West. Volodymyr Omelchenko, energy program director at the Razumkov Center in Kyiv, stated, 'I believe that if Mr. Trump makes such a proposal, Ukraine should not reject it, but should accept it with specific conditions.' According to him, these conditions should include guarantees of complete Ukrainian control over the plant and assurances that 'Energoatom,' Ukraine's nuclear energy agency, remains the sole operator of the plant. Omelchenko added, 'No one but Ukrainian specialists knows the specifics of Zaporizhia, as each nuclear unit has its own characteristics.' Ukraine has 15 operational reactors located in four nuclear power plants; Zaporizhia is one of these four plants and is currently under Russian occupation. The status of two reactors is described as 'under construction,' but no work has been done on them for over 30 years. Twelve of Ukraine's 15 reactors date back to the Soviet era and have been operational since before 1991, the year of Ukraine's independence. These 12 reactors provide more than half of Ukraine's electricity. The situation in Ukraine is unprecedented. Active war has never occurred in a country with multiple nuclear power plants; the Zaporizhia plant is under Russian occupation, Russian drones are alarmingly flying near the Khmelnytsky nuclear plant in western Ukraine, missiles and drones are flying near the Rivne plant in western Ukraine, and the shelter for the remains of the destroyed Chernobyl reactor was also targeted by a Russian drone last month. Igor Ruytrovyich, a political expert, views the US presence in Ukraine's nuclear power plant and the creation of interests for Washington as a type of security guarantee, stating to Radio Free Europe, 'Russia has repeatedly targeted Ukraine's infrastructure, and the field presence of American personnel would be a potential red line that Moscow would hesitate to cross.' In recent years, Ukraine has sought to reduce its dependence on Russian nuclear technology; for instance, in June 2022, Ukraine's state nuclear energy agency signed a contract with global nuclear giant Westinghouse, ensuring that the company would supply all nuclear fuel for Ukraine's reactors, breaking Russia's monopoly. Plans are also underway to construct new reactors using US technology at the Khmelnytsky nuclear power plant. Omelchenko discusses the benefits of US presence in Ukraine's nuclear power plant, stating, 'There are safety guarantees, but there are also significant investments, as well as cooperation with Westinghouse and other American companies, providing equipment... There are many positives to American participation.' However, as they say, the devil is in the details. CNN reported on Thursday, citing Western experts, that there are concerns about maintaining a stable power supply and sufficient water for cooling the plants under ongoing attacks on the facilities. They also mentioned that Western nuclear technicians lack experience working with VVER reactors, which were designed by the Soviets and are currently in use in Ukraine. On the other hand, there is disagreement about what exactly was discussed in the Trump-Zelensky phone call. According to the Ukrainian president, their conversation was exclusively about the Zaporizhia plant; however, the White House statement referred to 'plants' in the plural. Zelensky is eager for US assistance while also committed to maintaining Ukraine's sovereignty, especially in areas closely related to national security. He emphasized during that phone call that 'all nuclear power plants in Ukraine are owned by the people of Ukraine.' Some experts have suggested a potential compromise where Americans could be present in oversight committees for the nuclear power plants or even within the Energoatom company itself; a move that would provide influence and security without transferring ownership. However, other experts argue that mere US presence will not be sufficient to rectify the situation. Vadim Denisenko, a political expert, told Radio Free Europe, 'There is only one way to return Zaporizhia [to Ukraine]; that is for Russian forces to completely leave the area and the city of Enerhodar [the city adjacent to the plant]. I see no other option.' The remnants of Chernobyl, the site of the 1986 disaster, illustrate the limitations of international presence; despite significant international funding and the global reputation of this site, the inactive plant was still targeted. This incident occurred on the night of February 14, when a Russian drone with powerful explosives struck the extensive protective barrier created to prevent radiation from the destroyed fourth reactor. Serhiy Taran, a political expert, told Radio Free Europe that if American specialists come to Ukraine's energy facilities and stay there, 'there will definitely be a lower likelihood that Vladimir Putin will target these facilities.' He added, 'In any case, they need to have security personnel, and it would be better if they also had air defense systems.'
Ukraine is Assessing US Presence in Its Nuclear Power Plants
The US may establish a presence in Ukraine's nuclear power plants as discussed in a recent call between Trump and Zelensky, amid ongoing Russian occupation. Experts express cautious optimism about this potential move, which could enhance security and facilitate the transition of Ukraine's nuclear power from Russian to Western control. However, concerns remain about the practicalities and implications of such a presence.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The US may establish a presence in Ukraine's nuclear power plants, as discussed in a call between Trump and Zelensky. This move aims to enhance security and facilitate a shift from Russian to Western control of Ukraine's nuclear power.
- Zaporizhia is the largest nuclear power plant in Europe and is under Russian occupation.
- Ukraine is seeking to reduce dependence on Russian nuclear technology.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Ukraine's nuclear power sector is a legacy of the Soviet era, with most reactors dating back to before 1991. The ongoing conflict with Russia has heightened the strategic importance of these facilities.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%