Iranian media reported on Saturday, July 1, 2023, protests and demonstrations by a number of shareholders in Tehran's stock market. In this context, some shareholders accused the Tehran Stock Exchange Organization of "failing to protect their information and investments," leading to disruptions in trading activities for several hours. This is not the first time that shareholders, especially small investors, have protested against the Tehran Stock Exchange, and it will not be the last. For instance, on December 15, 2013, shareholders sent an open letter to President Hassan Rouhani and Speaker of Parliament Ali Larijani, accusing the Ministry of Oil of illegal actions that caused significant losses to shareholders in the refining industry. On Wednesday, May 20, 2015, a group of shareholders held placards demanding an end to organized corruption in the stock market and expressed concerns about the performance of stock exchange managers and allegations of favoritism in certain stocks, such as refineries. This time, however, shareholders of Iran's Meter Manufacturing Company are protesting the uncertainty surrounding the company's case and the freezing of their investments, demanding clarity regarding their assets, as the prolonged handling of the company's case leaves the future of these shareholders' investments uncertain. The constraints facing Tehran's stock market are broader and larger than this, occasionally manifesting as protests from shareholders. The stock market is part of the investment market of an economy, functioning to aggregate and multiply capital, converting small and stagnant investments into large, active, risk-taking capital, and distributing it among economic enterprises that require financing. The functions of the stock market—besides financing enterprises—include creating an environment for risk-taking investments, producing and distributing information, and encouraging the conversion of stagnant capital into active investments. Otherwise, stagnant capital—in the form of household or bank savings—cannot find opportunities for growth. Enterprises finance their economic growth by utilizing capital from the stock market and selling their shares there. Economic growth in the macroeconomic sphere and consequently job creation also depend on activating capital in the stock market. This is provided that the country's stock market is competitive and efficient; otherwise, certain constraints can negate some of the positive functions of this market. In developing countries like Iran, the stock market faces specific constraints that limit its efficiency. What are the constraints of Tehran's stock market? According to financial and stock market economic literature, an efficient stock market is one where its size—in terms of the number of shareholders and registered companies, investors, and capital volume—is so large that no individual or group can dominate it or dictate its changes. Furthermore, the financial statements of registered companies in the stock market must be transparent and accurate, reflecting the reality of the companies' economic changes. Information flow in an efficient stock market should be such that all players have equal opportunities to access information, preventing any player from obtaining abnormal profits without risk or manipulating prices. Globalization and digitization of stock markets have provided an opportunity for this important sector of the investment market to speed up and diversify information flow, preventing rent-seeking and windfall profits without risk. Such conditions are essential for the competitiveness and quantitative growth of the stock market (in terms of capital volume and the number of registered enterprises and shareholders). However, Tehran's stock market has constraints that question its efficiency. Tehran's stock market is isolated from global markets such as London and New York. It is primarily composed of state-owned or quasi-state companies, and the players and shareholders in this market are often state-owned, quasi-state, or small investors. The size of Tehran's stock market in terms of the number of registered companies, capital volume, and the number of players and small shareholders is small, which is why this market is not fully competitive, and all players do not have equal access to information, profits, and risks. Due to deficiencies in the auditing system of companies in Iran, stock prices do not fully reflect the actual capacity for profits and risks of companies; the sometimes abnormal profits and losses in this stock market are also indicative of these constraints. What are the consequences of the inefficiency of Tehran's stock market? The constraints mentioned lead to an unequal and unfair distribution of profits and risks among players. One type of rent-seeking in small, state-centric stock markets manifests as access to privileged information. In such conditions, a group of shareholders gains a superior position, allowing them to obtain windfall profits without bearing any risk. In contrast, small shareholders suffer losses, losing their investments and being excluded from the stock market. Such protests are often the result of this process, where shareholders who do not have access to privileged information and large state capital incur losses. If this trend continues and becomes persistent, it could lead to capital flight from the stock market. Capital flight from the stock market and its conversion into stagnant or wandering capital means a negative impact on economic growth and consequently on employment. In conclusion, Iran's stock market can play an important role in economic stability and the aggregation and multiplication of small capital by attracting stagnant or wandering investments. This sector of the investment market suffers from the same deficiencies that afflict other economic sectors, especially the banking sector. The lack of transparency and government and quasi-government interference are among the fundamental problems of this stock market, which hinder its expansion and growth. The conditions for increasing capital and public interest in Tehran's stock market are privatization and connections with major global stock markets. Just as small, scattered, and stagnant capital cannot play a significant role in economic growth, scattered, isolated, and small shareholders cannot provide the necessary leverage for stock market reforms. The expansion of civil society, especially shareholders' associations, can play an important role in transparency, accountability, improving laws and regulations, monitoring the functioning of this market, and enhancing the efficiency of Tehran's stock market.
What is the Problem with Tehran's Stock Market?
Shareholders in Tehran's stock market protested against the Tehran Stock Exchange Organization for failing to protect their investments, highlighting ongoing issues of inefficiency and lack of transparency in the market. This protest reflects broader systemic problems that could lead to capital flight and negatively impact economic growth. The situation underscores the need for reforms and greater accountability in Iran's financial markets.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
On July 1, 2023, shareholders in Tehran's stock market protested against the Tehran Stock Exchange Organization for failing to protect their investments, resulting in trading disruptions. This protest reflects ongoing issues of inefficiency and lack of transparency in the market.
- Shareholders accused the exchange of failing to protect their investments.
- Protests have occurred previously, indicating a pattern of dissatisfaction among investors.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's stock market is characterized by a lack of transparency and significant government involvement, which undermines investor confidence. Small investors often face disadvantages compared to larger, state-affiliated entities.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%