On Thursday, April 6th, during his visit to Semnan, Hassan Rouhani, the President of the Islamic Republic, reiterated that Iran's economy created 630,000 new job opportunities in the past solar year and that it is one of the six countries in the world that managed to create over 600,000 jobs in a year. This figure was cited by the President based on data from the Statistical Center of Iran and has been emphasized multiple times by his close advisors and colleagues in the government. With the presidential elections approaching, it can be confidently stated that Rouhani will focus on reducing inflation rates, the surge in growth rates, and this figure of jobs created in the past solar year to defend his economic record. The disbelief of people who experience the agony of unemployment within their families or among their close ones daily raises the question of how they can accept that Iran is one of the six major job-creating countries in the world. Their astonishment grows when they see that the Statistical Center of Iran reports, based on the 'summary results of the labor force survey in 1395', that the unemployment rate in Iran has risen from 11% in 1394 to 12.4% in 1395. This naturally leads them to question how the unemployment rate could have increased while Iran is simultaneously one of the top six countries in job creation. The first reaction to these contradictions is to label the statistics from the Islamic Republic as false. Given the collapse of 'social capital' and trust, along with the increasing gap between the people and senior officials, this reaction is completely natural in light of the stark contradiction between the reported statistics and tangible realities. The author of this note views the economic statistics published by official sources with skepticism for various reasons, but this does not mean that the published statistics from these sources are entirely invalid and should not be taken seriously. In today's world, considering the volume of published data, one can arrive at relatively accurate statistics, and one cannot always settle for saying 'these statistics are false' in analyzing phenomena and events. The first problem relates to how 630,000 new jobs were created in 1395. Although the country's economic growth rate was high last year, estimated by various domestic and international sources to be between 6% and 11%, all these sources state that this growth rate was achieved due to increased oil production and exports in the post-JCPOA era and also due to rising oil prices compared to the previous period. With a growth rate primarily driven by oil, the creation of such a large number of jobs is understandably questioned. Conversely, Iran's non-oil growth rate last year was around 1%. In other words, the main employment-generating sectors in the country have had low growth rates, and even a very important sector like construction has experienced a negative growth rate of between -15% and -20%. In this case, where did the 630,000 jobs come from? It is likely that many of the jobs created that President Rouhani and the statistical sources mention are due to government hiring, especially considering the upcoming presidential elections. If this is the case, the jobs created will impose a new heavy burden on Iran's fragile economy. Until accurate statistics are published regarding the true sources of the 630,000 jobs in 1395, as announced by the President, we assume this figure is correct. With this assumption, we address the significant gap that exists between this statistic and people's perceptions of tangible realities. The gap in interpreting the statistics first answers the question of how it is possible for the unemployment rate to rise while 630,000 new job opportunities are created. Essentially, there is no contradiction between these two data points. For two main reasons, an economy can witness an increase in the unemployment rate while creating a large number of new job opportunities: 1) The first reason was mentioned by Rouhani himself in his recent speeches, including on Thursday in Semnan. He stated that 1.2 million people entered the labor market last year, while the number of jobs created was 630,000. In other words, based solely on this difference, about 500,000 people were added to the unemployed population last year, causing the unemployment rate to rise. In reality, a large number of individuals born in the 1970s and early 1980s have flooded the labor market, along with waves of young people who have studied in higher education institutions and are now seeking jobs with bachelor's, master's, and doctoral degrees. To meet this demand, the country's economy needs to create at least 1.2 million new job opportunities annually, and even then, the unemployment rate would remain at its current level. 2) Another justification for the increase in the unemployment rate despite the creation of a large number of new job opportunities is the increase in the 'participation rate', also known as the 'activity rate'. The 'participation rate' is calculated by dividing the active population of a country (employed or unemployed) by the working-age population (usually 10 or 15 years and older depending on the country) and multiplying the result by 100. In some circumstances, part of the working-age population loses hope of finding a job and removes themselves from the unemployed population. Conversely, when jobs are created or a better outlook for employment emerges, those who had withdrawn return to the labor market, and for this reason, despite the labor market booming, the unemployment rate also rises. In other words, the 'participation rate' increases, putting more pressure on the labor market. The Statistical Center in its latest report states that the 'participation rate' in Iran increased from 38.2% in 1394 to 39.4% in 1395. This means that some of the 'hope-lost' individuals have returned to the labor market. Is this event really one of the factors contributing to the increase in the unemployment rate in Iran in 1395? The gap between official figures regarding the unemployment plague on one side and people's perception of the dimensions of this plague on the other side has a very important reason, which is the interpretation and analysis of statistics. To understand this gap, we refer to the assessment of both sides regarding the number of unemployed. The official unemployment rate in Iran is 12.4%, and the number of officially unemployed is 3.2 million people. This statistic does not align with the tangible reality of unemployment for the people, who estimate the number of unemployed to be much higher than this. The issue is that both sides do not share the same perspective on the definition of unemployment. The Statistical Center of Iran relies on the criteria of the 'International Labor Organization' in compiling unemployment statistics. From this institution's perspective, three factors must be considered in defining 'unemployed': a) An 'unemployed' person is someone who did not work even one hour in the week prior to the survey. This means that all part-time workers are excluded from the unemployment statistics. b) An 'unemployed' person is someone who is actively seeking work, for example, registered at job placement centers. In other words, all those who have left the labor market due to frustration from not finding a job and despair of the job market do not count as unemployed. Additionally, those who, due to lack of hope in finding a job, extend their education in university or aimlessly switch from one field to another should also be considered. c) An 'unemployed' person is someone who is willing to start a job that has been offered to them and accepted within the next 15 days. In assessing the number of unemployed based on this definition, a large number of individuals are excluded from the statistics. Based on these criteria, the Statistical Center announces the figure of 3.2 million unemployed in the country. If we add to this figure all those who, out of necessity, accept a few hours of work per week or month, or those who have withdrawn from the labor market due to despair, the actual number of unemployed in the country, according to various assessments, will reach 6 to 7 million people, about twice the figure announced by the Statistical Center.
Contradictions in Iran's Labor Market
President Hassan Rouhani claims Iran created 630,000 jobs in the past year, but the unemployment rate has simultaneously risen to 12.4%. This contradiction raises skepticism among the public regarding official statistics, especially as many experience unemployment firsthand.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
President Rouhani announced that Iran created 630,000 new jobs in the past year, despite the unemployment rate rising to 12.4%. This contradiction has led to public skepticism about the accuracy of government statistics.
- The unemployment rate increased from 11% to 12.4% while 630,000 jobs were claimed to have been created.
- The rise in unemployment is attributed to a larger number of job seekers entering the market than jobs created.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's economy has been struggling with high unemployment and inflation, exacerbated by international sanctions and internal mismanagement. The youth population is particularly affected, as many graduates face a challenging job market.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%