The Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported on the warnings from some senior Israeli security officials regarding the consequences of canceling the JCPOA on the day of Donald Trump's presidential inauguration in the United States. Haaretz wrote on Friday, January 21, hours before the inauguration ceremony of the new U.S. president, that the assessment of Israeli intelligence and security agencies one year after the JCPOA is that 'this agreement is also beneficial for Israel.' Amos Harel, an expert on Iran and the Middle East, wrote in Haaretz that Israeli security agencies have advised Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu not to pressure Donald Trump to cancel the JCPOA. Mr. Netanyahu stated last month in an interview with CBS that he has 'at least five plans' in mind for canceling the JCPOA. He added that he would discuss these 'thoughts' in his first meeting with Donald Trump after he takes office. According to Haaretz, it seems that the Israeli Prime Minister will be one of the first guests at the White House during Trump's presidency. Haaretz's report noted that senior military and security officials in Israel have been prohibited from making any public comments regarding the fate of the JCPOA under the Trump administration, and this matter has been classified as 'sensitive.' However, according to Haaretz, these restrictions do not apply to former officials of Israeli intelligence and security agencies, who have stated that these agencies' interpretation of the JCPOA differs from Netanyahu's viewpoint. Senior former Israeli intelligence officials have recently told Haaretz that 'what is beneficial for Iran is also beneficial for Israel, and any potential actions to nullify the JCPOA would also harm Israel.' On the other hand, retired General Aharon Ze'evi Farkash, former head of the Israeli military intelligence agency, told Haaretz that Israel and the U.S. could draw Iran into other agreements that would address grievances regarding the JCPOA. According to Haaretz, the senior security and military officials that Trump has considered for his Defense Ministry and other important security and intelligence agencies all have a 'positive view' towards the Israeli army and strengthening cooperation with this country. General Amos Yadlin, another former head of the Israeli military intelligence unit, also told Haaretz that if tensions escalate to the level of war with Iran, global powers will consider Israel 'behind' this crisis and will not stand by Israel's side. Benjamin Netanyahu immediately after the JCPOA was reached called it 'the worst agreement,' but later in a speech at the United Nations stated that closely monitoring Iran is on the agenda to ensure that it fulfills all its commitments under this agreement. Donald Trump insisted on canceling the JCPOA throughout his year-and-a-half election campaign before the November 2016 elections. In recent days, on the first anniversary of the implementation of the JCPOA, Barack Obama, John Kerry, and Ernest Moniz advised the Trump administration to preserve the JCPOA. Abbas Araghchi, Iran's chief negotiator, recently reiterated a statement from Ali Khamenei, the leader of Iran, saying that if the JCPOA is canceled on the other side, 'this side will set it on fire.' Hassan Rouhani, the President of Iran, also stated on Tuesday, January 17, that renegotiating the JCPOA is meaningless and 'it is like someone saying this shirt I have, I want to turn it into cotton and re-spin, weave, and sew it again.' Mohammad Javad Zarif, Iran's Foreign Minister, also said on Thursday, January 19, that if the JCPOA is canceled under the Trump administration, 'Iran also has options,' but did not specify the details of these 'options.'
Haaretz Reports Warnings from Israeli Security Officials Regarding Consequences of JCPOA Cancellation
Israeli security officials have warned Prime Minister Netanyahu against pressuring Trump to cancel the JCPOA, asserting that the agreement is beneficial for Israel. Netanyahu has reportedly devised multiple plans to discuss with Trump regarding the JCPOA. The situation remains sensitive, with differing views among former Israeli intelligence officials.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Israeli security officials warned Prime Minister Netanyahu against pressuring President Trump to cancel the JCPOA, arguing it benefits Israel. Despite this, Netanyahu has plans to discuss the JCPOA's cancellation with Trump.
- Israeli security agencies believe the JCPOA is beneficial for Israel.
- Netanyahu has multiple plans to discuss with Trump regarding the JCPOA.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The JCPOA, agreed in 2015, aimed to limit Iran's nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief. Its future under the Trump administration was uncertain.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%