Among the economic constraints of Iran outlined in the introduction of this discussion, Fereydoun Khavand examines the third constraint, which is dedicated to the "introverted economy." Since the late 1960s, several developing countries, especially in Asia, have proven that only by adopting an industrial strategy aimed at extroversion (mass exporting of competitive goods to global markets) can they escape the whirlpool of unemployment and poverty. However, Iran remains trapped in an economy where its production sectors have become accustomed to introversion, except for the oil industry, which is oriented towards global markets and primarily bears the burden of generating foreign currency for the country. But this situation cannot continue for long, as the current major global developments and the rapid advancement of new technologies make it uncertain what position oil and gas will hold in the future energy basket. In the past, the literature of international relations divided the countries of the world into two sections: "North" and "South." The "North" (also known as the "developed world" or "center") included countries whose economic structures were diverse, meaning that most of them had advanced agriculture and also had a say in industrial and service sectors. This diversity was naturally reflected in their foreign trade. The economies of these countries, in addition to producing a significant portion of the needs of their citizens and production units, were oriented towards global markets with the aim of generating the necessary currency for their required imports through the export of agricultural (especially food) and industrial goods, as well as services. In fact, the foreign market was the continuation of the domestic market of the "North" countries, and extroversion was considered an integral part of their economic policy. Their economy sought to conquer foreign markets, just as foreigners sought to conquer their domestic market. On the other hand, the "South" (which was referred to by other terms such as "developing world," "third world," or "periphery") included economies that had been left out of the industrial revolution and relied on backward agriculture. Their exports often consisted of one or very few raw commodities (oil and other minerals, agricultural materials used in industry, etc.) that provided the currency needed to import their industrial goods and food. Over decades, from the first half of the 19th century to the late 20th century, the "North" enjoyed a prominent position in international trade (exchanging manufactured products and food for raw materials) and had a somewhat monopolistic role in exporting industrial goods. However, this monopoly gradually faded, and the division of countries into "North" and "South" no longer aligns with the current realities of the world. From "Import Substitution" to "Export Promotion" In the years leading up to World War II, some "South" countries, especially in Latin America, adopted the strategy known as "import substitution," meaning they decided to produce domestically as much as they could instead of importing certain industrial goods like textiles and household appliances, and later automobiles. For example, instead of buying textile products from Europe, a national textile industry was established, and the government either completely banned the import of fabrics and clothing from abroad or imposed heavy tariffs and duties on them to protect domestic fabric and clothing within a protected national market. It is emphasized that the "import substitution" strategy, at its inception in the first half of the 20th century and also in its subsequent expansion to a large part of the developing world, did not aim to export goods to foreign markets. At that time, even the thought that an underdeveloped country could conquer the markets of America and Western Europe with industrial goods seemed very audacious. The "import substitution" strategy had a much more limited goal: to replace imported goods with domestically produced goods as much as possible under the umbrella of customs protection and within relatively closed borders. Since domestic enterprises grew in "greenhouse conditions" and did not compete with foreign rivals, they lacked the ability to produce superior goods at lower prices and could not test their luck in international markets. Domestic consumers, who had tolerated buying domestic goods for several years in the name of "defending national industry," eventually grew tired and, if possible, turned to imported goods, even if smuggled. From the text, the "import substitution" strategy is, in this sense, an introverted strategy, as it creates an industry that relies solely on the domestic market, targets domestic consumers, grows under customs protection, is safe from competition from foreign goods, and, for this reason, operates in "greenhouse conditions." This strategy allowed many developing countries to familiarize themselves with the first steps in the industrial arena. However, its limitations soon became evident. In fact, the national market becomes saturated after a few years, and domestic industries become trapped in excess capacity. Moreover, since domestic enterprises grew in "greenhouse conditions" and did not compete with foreign rivals, they lacked the ability to produce superior goods at lower prices and could not test their luck in international markets. Domestic consumers, who had tolerated buying domestic goods for several years in the name of "defending national industry," eventually grew tired and, if possible, turned to imported goods, even if smuggled. Given all these limitations and other obstacles that cannot be addressed here, the "import substitution" strategy did not provide a favorable environment for the growth of a modern, dynamic, and sustainable industrial economy and fell out of breath. In the meantime, several Asian countries and territories (South Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong), inspired by Japan, turned to the "export promotion" strategy from the mid-1960s. These countries, dubbed the "Asian Tigers," linked industrial development with foreign trade and began mass production of manufactured goods for export to global markets. Unlike the followers of the "import substitution" strategy, these countries abandoned introversion and turned to extroverted industry. The maneuvering area of these countries in the early years included "low-end" goods, including textiles, clothing, toys, and sports equipment, which did not require complex technology and massive investments for production. Such goods, with average quality and very low prices, were very suitable for meeting the consumption needs of low-income classes in wealthy Western countries, and thus gained a booming market in these countries. Relying on the currency obtained from exporting these goods, understanding the complexities of international trade, and the increasing entry of foreign investors, the "Asian Tigers" quickly improved the quality of their goods, became skilled in producing more complex goods with increasingly advanced technology year by year, and reached the point we see today. Meanwhile, the "export promotion" strategy almost encompassed the entire Asia-Pacific region and found many followers in other continents as well. China's adoption of the extroverted "export promotion" strategy in the 1980s not only transformed the "Yellow Empire" but also the entire international trade system. With the entry of a country with a population of 1.3 billion (sixteen times Iran's population) into the global economy and the activation of hundreds of millions of arms in the service of producing goods for export to world markets, the international division of labor and the power relations on a global scale were completely transformed. This event, like the accession of dozens of new countries to the ranks of extroverted industries (from Turkey to Mexico, from Vietnam to Brazil), forever ended a world where international relations were based on the division between "North" and "South." A Prisoner of the Domestic Market Iran, like many other developing countries, also adopted "import substitution" in establishing its modern industries, except for the oil industry, which was naturally created from the beginning for production and export to global markets, and this "extroversion" essentially constituted its reason for existence. Following the efforts of economic pioneers during the Qajar era, such as Hajj Amin al-Darb and Hajj Mo'in al-Tijar Bushehri, serious initial steps towards industrializing Iran were taken by establishing production units in areas such as textiles, sugar, cement, matches, soap, etc., during the reign of Reza Shah Pahlavi. These steps, after overcoming the severe ups and downs caused by World War II and Iran's domestic politics in the 1320s and 1330s, eventually led to the golden years of the 1340s and early 1350s, which turned the country into one of the most successful developing countries with an average growth rate of over eight percent per year and an inflation rate below four percent. During this period, Iran made significant advancements in many industrial fields, from steel to food industries and household appliances and automobiles, and witnessed the emergence of prominent entrepreneurs such as the Khiyami, Iravani, and Azmayesh families, with businesses that for the first time aimed at conquering regional and global markets beyond the domestic market. However, Iran's industry could not free itself from introversion and break out of the cage of the national market like the dynamic Asian economies. In the early 1350s, with the multiple increase in oil prices, the pre-revolution political system was drawn into increasing intervention in the country's economic life. With the Islamic Revolution of 1357, the new system essentially abandoned the idea of making the economy extroverted (except for oil) and turned introversion into an economic ideal. Despite this, Iran's industry could not free itself from introversion and break out of the cage of the national market like the dynamic Asian economies. In the early 1350s, with the multiple increase in oil prices, the pre-revolution political system was drawn into increasing intervention in the country's economic life, and the injection of massive oil dollars disrupted the healthy environment that had been created, especially with inflation control for business. The weight of oil soared in the economy to such an extent that even the thought of utilizing industrial activities for exporting goods to global markets for currency lost its appeal. When a country earns so much currency from oil, what need does it have for exporting its industrial units? With the Islamic Revolution of 1357, the new system essentially abandoned the idea of making the economy extroverted (except for oil) and turned introversion into an economic ideal. The Islamic Republic, in line with the prevailing thought in a very large segment of the political spectrum at that time, interpreted economic independence as "self-sufficiency," meaning the country should free itself from dependence on the "dominance system" by avoiding the international trade system (except for oil) and rejecting foreign investors (again except for oil). This closed and introverted policy became the guiding light of the Islamic Republic at the very time when an increasing number of developing countries, from China to Turkey and Brazil, turned to extroversion by integrating into international trade and attracting foreign investments. The result of this policy is the existence of industries, many of which can only survive within the framework of the internal market and under government support. The most important example in this regard is Iran's automotive industry, which is not favored by Iranian consumers and its presence abroad is so marginal that it does not count. Of course, other Iranian industrial exports such as food, cement, pharmaceuticals, and household appliances can be seen in neighboring countries, including Afghanistan and Iraq, but even in these markets, Iran's presence is weak and suffers from competition with rival goods (Chinese, Korean, Turkish, etc.). The only possible way to escape this major deadlock is to transition from introversion to extroversion in the industrial sector. Iran must leave behind the "import substitution" strategy and adopt an industrial strategy based on "export promotion." Iranian industrial goods are deprived of the ability to be exported to foreign markets (except in a marginal and fragile manner) and also suffer from reduced domestic demand due to the decline in people's purchasing power. According to calculations by Dr. Masoud Nili, special assistant to Hassan Rouhani on economic affairs, the size of the country's industry has doubled compared to 1381, while the level of demand remains stagnant at the level of 1381 (fifteen years ago). This situation has resulted in about half of the country's industry being considered excess capacity (ISNA, July 26, 2017). This means that Iran's industry, due to the decline in people's income, has no demand domestically, and since it cannot export either, half of its capacity remains unused. This is the most significant disaster for an industry that, due to the fatal mistakes of the past few decades, has been constrained and is in no position to utilize its capacities to penetrate global markets. With this introverted industry, which currently has half of its capacities idle, how can one fight the poverty resulting from unemployment? How can jobs be created for the one million two hundred thousand people who are added to the number of job seekers each year? The only possible way to escape this major deadlock is to transition from introversion to extroversion in the industrial sector. Iran must leave behind the "import substitution" strategy and adopt an industrial strategy based on "export promotion." This transition requires a fundamental transformation.
Iran's Economy: Ten Constraints and Two Escape Routes; An Introverted Economy
The article discusses the constraints of Iran's economy, particularly focusing on its introverted nature and reliance on oil exports. It argues that Iran must shift from an import substitution strategy to an export promotion strategy to overcome economic stagnation and unemployment. This transition is crucial for the country's economic future.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The article analyzes the constraints of Iran's economy, emphasizing its introverted nature and reliance on oil exports. It argues for a shift from an import substitution strategy to an export promotion strategy to address economic stagnation.
- Iran's economy is heavily reliant on oil exports, which limits diversification.
- The shift to an export promotion strategy is seen as essential for overcoming unemployment and poverty.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's economy has historically been characterized by a reliance on oil exports and limited industrial diversification, which has hindered its growth.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%