Among the ten economic constraints of Iran outlined in the introduction of this discussion, Fereydoun Khavand examines the fifth constraint, which is dedicated to 'weak growth.' The growth rate is the most important tool for measuring the economic status of a country. The labor market, the welfare level of the people, the annual budget, and even the type of decision-making at the household, business, and government levels all depend on this indicator. In Iran, the very low growth level is the main factor behind significant economic difficulties and, at the same time, one of the most important and obvious manifestations of the heavy weights that have been shackling the country's economy for about four decades, preventing it from taking flight. A new phenomenon in the history of human civilization, the growth rate is measured based on the real increase in gross domestic product (GDP) compared to the previous year, but the impact of this indicator on the economy and the overall social conditions of a country manifests itself in the long term. Economic growth relies on the long-term increase in GDP. In simple terms, GDP refers to the total value of goods and services produced in a country within a year. By dividing this variable by the population of a country, per capita domestic production is obtained. If the annual average population growth exceeds the annual average GDP growth, the standard of living will naturally decline. This means that to improve the welfare level of the people, the GDP growth rate must significantly exceed the population growth rate and, at the same time, be sustained over a relatively long period. It is essential to emphasize that the GDP growth rate can lead to a significant improvement in an economy and society only if it is sustained. In an oil-exporting country, due to the accidental increase in exports of this commodity or a surge in its price in the global market, the GDP can rise significantly in a short period. However, as soon as exports decrease or oil prices fall in the global market, the growth rate in the country declines just as quickly. In other words, GDP growth must continue for years to qualitatively transform a society towards improvement. The strength and sustainability of this transformation are realized in economies where the main driving force is endogenous and originates from various sectors of activity (industry, services, agriculture). If a peasant from Khorasan during the Samanid era could pass through a time tunnel and reach the Safavid period or even the mid-Qajar period, he would not feel the impact of the passage of time much in the lives of people. In contrast, if a Khorasani from the early twentieth century were to come back to life today, he would see a completely different world after just one century. Economic growth, as we see it today, is a very recent phenomenon in the history of human civilization. If a peasant from Khorasan during the Samanid era (tenth century) could pass through a time tunnel and reach the Safavid period (sixteenth and seventeenth centuries) and even the mid-Qajar period (mid-nineteenth century), he would not feel the impact of the passage of time much in the lives of people. In other words, over a nine-hundred-year period, the changes in the way of production, consumption, and the living standards of Khorasanis were so negligible that they went unnoticed. In contrast, if a Khorasani from the early twentieth century were to come back to life today, he would see a completely different world after just one century. Economic growth primarily began in the late eighteenth century with the first sparks of the Industrial Revolution, accelerated in the mid-nineteenth century, and in the years following World War II, it overflowed from its initial bed (Europe and America) to other parts of the planet, dramatically transforming the lives of hundreds of millions of people. According to calculations by economic historians, in 1820, eighty-four percent of the world's population lived in absolute poverty. The ratio of the absolutely poor to the total population decreased from forty-four percent in 1981 to about ten percent today. The 'golden period' holds true for Iran as well. Over the past two centuries, Iranians have endured many calamities, but at the same time, they have been significantly transformed by recognizing new ideas and achieving some advancements from the West in production and services. Some of the ideals of the Constitutional Revolution for progress were realized during the reign of Reza Shah Pahlavi. Another part was realized during a period of the reign of Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi. However, for the past four decades, at the height of economic dynamism in a large part of the developing world, Iran has lost its momentum in economic growth and now finds itself lagging behind not only advanced countries but also emerging powers. The main factor behind Iran's backwardness is the stagnation of economic growth. Of course, over the past forty years, Iran has also experienced high growth rates. However, the increase in Iran's GDP growth rate during these years has been the result of increased foreign income from oil exports and has often fallen just as rapidly as it rose. For example, the Central Bank of the Islamic Republic announced the country's economic growth in 2016 to be over twelve percent. This surge was born from the increase in Iran's oil exports following the implementation of the JCPOA and has no relation to an endogenous and real growth, which naturally does not end in one or two years. To understand the importance of sustained growth rates, we refer to the example of China. What is called the 'Chinese miracle' relies on the long-term nature of GDP growth in that country. From 1979 to 2010 (over a period of thirty-one years), China's average annual growth rate fluctuated around ten percent. With such a growth rate, a country's national income doubles in eight years. From 2011 to today, China's growth rate has fluctuated between six and seven percent per year. For a country like China, which needs to create twenty-five million new jobs each year, achieving such high growth rates is a vital necessity. We refer to the example of Iran, which experienced a 'golden period' in its contemporary economic history between 1961 and 1976. During these fifteen years, the country's average annual growth rate fluctuated above ten percent. The total volume of Iran's economy nearly quintupled during this period. If we consider the population growth rate during these fifteen years, the GDP per capita for each Iranian tripled. With the continuous increase in per capita income, the lives of Iranians visibly improved, their homes became larger, and their tables became more colorful. From the mid-1970s, under the influence of the sudden rise in oil prices and the injection of massive oil dollars into the country's economic arteries, the growth train somewhat lost its momentum, and inflation surged. These troubles were not incurable, and reforming economic policies could have addressed them. However, the country fell into the Islamic Revolution and then sank into the whirlpool of war, and after the war, its economy, under the blows of destructive domestic policies and endless external tensions, never stood upright again. Based on calculations from expert circles in the Islamic Republic, the average GDP growth rate in the post-Islamic Revolution period has been between two to two and a half percent per year. The Minister of Economic Affairs and Finance has assessed this indicator during the relevant period at 2.3 percent per year ('World of Economics,' July 21, 2017). The Research Center of the Parliament estimates the same indicator at 2.1 percent (Requirements for Achieving Eight Percent Growth, June 2016). During the same period, Iran's average population growth rate has been slightly above two percent. In other words, the average per capita growth rate in Iran in the post-Islamic Revolution period has fluctuated between zero percent and, in the most optimistic assessments, less than half a percent per year. This means that the volume of Iran's economy over the past four decades, in relation to population growth, despite the country having about nine hundred billion dollars in oil revenues, has practically not changed. The atmosphere of trust Iranians ask themselves why China has achieved an 'economic miracle,' while Iran has stagnated in the market of Chinese export products? The answer to this question can be found in the difference between the average annual per capita growth rates of the two countries over the past four decades: below half a percent (optimistic estimate) for Iran and about eight percent for China. With such a significant difference, a Chinese citizen's income doubles in less than ten years, while an Iranian must wait about one hundred years for his per capita income to double, even if we consider the most optimistic assessment of the per capita GDP growth rate for the country. In evaluating the consequences of Iran's very weak economic growth over the past four decades, Dr. Masoud Nili, the special economic assistant to the president, goes even further, stating that Iranians' per capita income in 2016 decreased by thirty percent compared to the per capita income of 1976. In other words, Iranians have become thirty percent poorer over the past forty years, although, according to him, to neutralize this income drop, they have raised their consumption compared to that period by drawing from their assets (energy, water and air, pension funds, banking assets, etc.). One fundamental question remains: why has the economic growth rate in Iran fallen to such a low level? For years, Iranian planners have targeted an eight percent annual growth rate for the Iranian economy, arguing that only with such a growth rate can the country create jobs for newcomers to the labor market (between one million two hundred to one million five hundred thousand people). Why does this goal seem unattainable compared to the existing economic realities of the country? The driving force of economic growth is investment. From the total GDP, a large portion is consumed, and the other part is allocated to savings and investment. The major problem in Iran is the lack of investment. The driving force of economic growth is investment. From the total GDP, a large portion is consumed, and the other part is allocated to savings and investment. The major problem in Iran is the lack of investment. Between 2009 and 2016, the average growth of fixed capital formation in Iran has been negative (about minus five percent). Beyond the countless obstacles to private sector investment, the share of development budget in the overall budget has also significantly decreased in recent years, being allocated to unnecessary expenses such as cash subsidies. The unfavorable business environment is the main barrier to mobilizing savings and talents for productive activities. There is also little news of foreign investments, especially considering the endless tensions that weigh on Iran's international relations. According to the UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development), Iran attracted only three billion three hundred million dollars in foreign investment in 2016, which is equivalent to 0.2 percent of foreign investments worldwide. Another factor contributing to the low growth rate in Iran is the decline in productivity. Economic growth accelerated when humans were able to use limited resources more effectively and profitably, relying on knowledge and technology. Productivity improves when humans can use production factors (labor, energy, and capital) more efficiently and raise outputs with the same inputs. A large portion of economic growth in countries is due to productivity improvements. Over the past forty years, about thirty to forty percent of economic growth in dynamic Asian countries has originated from productivity growth, while this ratio in the Iranian economy has been below one percent. The enormous share of the public sector and costly but ineffective supportive policies are among the most important factors contributing to low productivity in Iran. Overall, the general conditions in Iran in economic, political, legal, and social spheres do not provide a favorable environment for economic growth. Economic growth relies on investment, and investors need a climate of trust. The lack of trust in Iran's environment is the main barrier to investment in advancing economic growth. Fereydoun Khavand is an economist, economic analyst, and professor of economics in Paris, France.
Iran's Economy: Ten Constraints and Two Escape Routes - Weak Growth
Fereydoun Khavand discusses the weak economic growth in Iran, highlighting that the country's GDP growth has stagnated for four decades, leading to significant economic difficulties. The article emphasizes the need for sustained growth and investment to improve the welfare of the Iranian people.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The article discusses the persistent issue of weak economic growth in Iran, highlighting that the country's GDP growth has stagnated for four decades, leading to significant economic difficulties. It emphasizes the importance of sustained growth for improving the welfare of the Iranian people.
- Iran's average GDP growth rate since the Islamic Revolution has been between 2% and 2.5% per year.
- The average population growth rate in Iran has been slightly above 2%, leading to stagnation in per capita income.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran has faced economic difficulties for decades, particularly after the Islamic Revolution, with fluctuating oil prices impacting its GDP growth. Understanding the relationship between GDP growth and social welfare is crucial for grasping the current economic landscape.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%