In recent days, cities in Iran have witnessed protests by depositors of the country's credit and financial institutions. For instance, some depositors of the Caspian Institute demonstrated in front of the Central Bank on June 8, shouting slogans against the Central Bank's governor. Previously, there were also gatherings by depositors of the Arman (Development) credit institution in Khuzestan cities, demanding the return of their deposits. In response to these protests and the spread of rumors on social media regarding the bankruptcy of the country's banks, Abbas Kamarei, the Central Bank's Director General of Supervision, stated: 'Currently, some banks are facing problems, but the Central Bank, as the supervising authority, is monitoring their performance, and bankruptcy does not occur easily.' However, this claim is questionable as there are many signs indicating that the Central Bank lacks the authority and independence to address the deep issues in Iran's monetary and credit markets. For example, the Minister of Economic Affairs and Finance recently stated that under current conditions, the Central Bank has lost control over liquidity, attributing this to the bank's lack of independence. This official added: 'Under current conditions, the Central Bank has lost the ability to control liquidity; we have focused all our efforts over the past two years to respect the independence of the Central Bank and to abolish the dominance of financial policies over budgetary policies.' The functioning of the banking system is of great importance, and if there is a disruption in this system, other sectors of Iran's economy will also face a crisis. The main problem with Iran's banking system is that it is a dual system consisting of an official government sector and a so-called private sector, alongside an informal sector that is simultaneously rent-seeking and isolated from the global banking system. A significant portion of the total liquidity in this system is held by unofficial and opaque credit institutions that often operate under the guise of charitable lending. Global experience also supports this claim. Among economic researchers, there is consensus that one of the major reasons for the global economic and financial crisis that first manifested in the U.S. in 2007 and swept through the Western economy was the failure to adhere to banking laws and standards in the U.S. For this reason, global institutions like the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund strive to enforce uniform regulations and supervision to prevent unhealthy competition, duality in the monetary and credit markets, and circumvention of the rules governing the banking system. The non-compliance of financial institutions and banks with uniform rules and the supervision of the Central Bank makes the Iranian economy susceptible to the emergence of a chain bankruptcy, which would paralyze the entire Iranian economy, with the first casualties being those institutions that compete unhealthily with one another. What problems make Iran's banking system susceptible to bankruptcy? A significant portion of the total liquidity in this system is held by unofficial and opaque credit institutions that often operate under the guise of charitable lending, thus not complying with banking and monetary regulations and competing with official banks by offering very high interest rates to depositors. It is difficult to estimate the volume of activities in this sector because government officials provide various statistics that are inconsistent with each other. According to the Central Bank's governor, nearly a quarter of credit and banking activities are outside the bank's supervision and belong to this sector. Moreover, some banking system officials have stated that some of these unauthorized institutions have expanded to the extent that the branches of some of these institutions exceed those of some authorized banks. The Central Bank's efforts in recent years to stop or limit the activities of these institutions have not succeeded. Due to the lack of sufficient political will to stop these institutions, these rent-seeking institutions, which also have political functions, are connected to influential entities and individuals within the ruling network. Additionally, a significant portion of Iran's banking system is under the management of institutions controlled by the Supreme Leader, and effective supervision over their activities is not conducted. Furthermore, the massive and accumulated overdue debts of this banking system, the large debts of banks, low capital ratios, and consequently, a lack of current capital and high risk are concerning. Various figures of overdue debts to banks are presented that are inconsistent with each other. However, as indicated by the signs, the problem of overdue debts of banks remains unresolved. Over time, the accumulated interest on these debts increases their volume. This volume of overdue debt, especially without guarantees, is astonishing and indicative of disorder, rent-seeking, and corruption within the banking system. Such a trend is, of course, intertwined with corruption in political and managerial spheres; otherwise, banks should not lend these massive amounts without the necessary guarantees. Given the current economic situation in Iran, especially in the real estate and housing market, and the inability of supervisory institutions and the judicial and legal system in Iran, it seems unlikely that a significant portion of the overdue claims of banks can be recovered in the short term. For this reason, considering these overdue and massive claims, a significant portion of the banks' capital is locked up, and they cannot return depositors' funds to them. One of the motivations for depositors' protests against banks like Arman and Caspian has also been this issue. If Iran's banking system wants to connect to the international banking network, it must make its accounts transparent and calculate their value based on market criteria. Such an action could reveal their problems, especially the bubble in their balance sheets. The Central Bank officials, unable to manage banking, monetary, and credit effectively, have repeatedly warned about the loss of depositors' savings in unofficial credit and financial institutions, but these warnings have not been taken seriously. In recent weeks, the bubble of promises made by these institutions regarding high interest rates has finally burst, and the repayment of the principal and interest of these deposits to their owners has come into question. The main reason for the inability of the mentioned banks to repay deposits to customers is their lack of liquidity, which is manifested as overdue claims or investments that at least in the long term are not recoverable. Given the interconnectedness of the banking system, if only a few banks go bankrupt, the entire banking system will be affected. It seems that some of the necessary conditions for the bankruptcy of part of Iran's banking system—such as massive overdue claims and severe rent-seeking and corruption—are being met. The government, by utilizing oil revenue rents and other measures, has prevented the bankruptcy of banks, but how long can the government continue its support?
Is the Bankruptcy of Iran's Banking System Threatening?
Recent protests by depositors of Iranian banks, particularly Caspian and Arman, highlight growing concerns over the potential bankruptcy of the banking system. Central Bank officials acknowledge some banks face issues, but there are doubts about their ability to manage the crisis effectively. The dual nature of the banking system, with significant informal and opaque sectors, exacerbates the risk of widespread financial collapse.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Recent protests erupted in Iran as depositors from banks like Caspian and Arman demanded the return of their savings, amid fears of a banking system bankruptcy. Central Bank officials acknowledged some banks are struggling, but there are doubts about their ability to effectively manage the crisis.
- Protests occurred in multiple cities, indicating widespread concern among depositors.
- The Central Bank has lost control over liquidity, complicating the financial situation.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran's banking system is characterized by a dual structure of official and unofficial institutions, leading to significant instability and lack of transparency. This situation has been exacerbated by economic mismanagement and corruption.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%