Hours after the U.S. President defended the JCPOA, stating that Israel's assessment is that Iran has fully complied with its commitments under the agreement, the Israeli Defense Ministry likened the JCPOA to the "Munich Agreement" (the agreement with Hitler). Israel has been the staunchest opponent of the global powers' nuclear negotiations with Iran, calling the JCPOA a "historical mistake," but the Israeli military has confirmed in several reports over the past year that Iran has fulfilled all its commitments under the JCPOA. Barack Obama stated on Thursday, August 4, at the White House that the Israeli military and security institutions also acknowledge the benefits of the JCPOA. In a press conference responding to the uproar in the U.S. following the report regarding Washington's action to return $400 million of Iran's funds, he said the JCPOA was a good agreement and that Israel has come to believe it has improved the security situation in the Middle East. However, the Israeli Defense Ministry claimed that the JCPOA poses "dangers" equivalent to those of the "Munich Agreement." The "Munich Agreement" in 1938 between Italy, France, and Britain with Adolf Hitler ceded German-speaking parts of Czechoslovakia to Nazi Germany, but a year later, Hitler's invasion of Poland triggered World War II. According to Israeli media, the Israeli Defense Ministry, recently overseen by Avigdor Lieberman, stated in its announcement that "it will be proven that the agreement with Iran was a mistake." Meanwhile, the Haaretz newspaper reported on Friday, August 5, that the Israeli Prime Minister's Office also issued a separate statement attempting to mitigate the damage to relations with the U.S., emphasizing that "the U.S. is Israel's greatest ally." According to the Prime Minister's Office statement, Netanyahu said in his speech at last year's UN General Assembly that "it is necessary for all, both supporters and opponents of the nuclear agreement, to cooperate to achieve three goals: ensure that Iran does not violate this agreement; combat Iran's regional ambitions; and efforts must be made to dismantle the global terror network supported by Iran." The Netanyahu office's statement also noted that the Israeli government "expects that the three goals will be the basis of a common policy to strengthen the alliance between Israel and the U.S., both under Barack Obama's administration and the next U.S. administration." Barack Obama, in a veiled reference to Netanyahu, stated, "I want to see all those who were waiting for a catastrophe and said the sky would fall now say they were wrong... but we know they won't do that." The new tension between Israel and the U.S. comes as Susan Rice, the White House National Security Advisor, reported on Thursday, August 4, "serious progress" in negotiations between the two countries regarding the U.S. military aid package to Israel. According to Israeli media reports, the Obama administration has agreed to increase military aid to Israel for a ten-year period to about $40 billion. Benjamin Netanyahu, who had previously stated he preferred to finalize the aid package after the new U.S. president took office, changed his mind and sent an Israeli delegation to Washington in recent days to finalize this aid. Israeli media reported that last week's three-day negotiations at the White House reached the final stages, with only technical details remaining to finalize it.
Israeli Defense Ministry Responds to Obama: The JCPOA is as Dangerous as the Agreement with Hitler
The Israeli Defense Ministry has compared the JCPOA to the Munich Agreement, asserting it poses similar dangers, despite the Israeli military's acknowledgment of Iran's compliance. This statement follows President Obama's defense of the JCPOA, highlighting tensions between Israel and the U.S. regarding military aid and nuclear negotiations.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The Israeli Defense Ministry compared the JCPOA to the Munich Agreement, despite Iran's compliance, causing tension with the U.S. Obama defended the JCPOA, emphasizing its benefits and ongoing military aid negotiations with Israel.
- The Israeli Defense Ministry likened the JCPOA to the Munich Agreement with Hitler.
- Obama highlighted that the Israeli military acknowledges Iran's compliance with the JCPOA.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The JCPOA, signed in 2015, aimed to limit Iran's nuclear capabilities in exchange for lifting economic sanctions. It has been a contentious issue, particularly between Israel and the U.S.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%