The nuclear agreement between Iran and the P5+1 group was one of the outcomes of direct contacts and negotiations between the foreign ministers of Iran and the United States, two countries that severed relations shortly after the victory of the Islamic Revolution in February 1979. But has the nuclear agreement changed this situation? Read John Limbert's responses to Radio Farda's questions: John Limbert is a veteran American diplomat and one of the American hostages during the occupation of the U.S. embassy in Tehran. He later worked in 2009 as an assistant secretary of state for Iran but resigned due to lack of progress in relations. Mr. Limbert, who speaks Persian, completed his doctorate in Middle Eastern studies and history. When we look at today's Iran and its foreign policy, has anything changed in this country after reaching a nuclear agreement? We should not expect that the problems resulting from thirty-five years of entanglement will disappear immediately with one agreement and a handshake. If bilateral relations are to move in a so-called more constructive line, this is a step in that direction, but there are other steps as well. It is true that the JCPOA is a positive outcome, a significant advancement, but this situation does not solve all the problems of the past thirty-six years. Mr. Limbert, do you think this agreement, which you evaluate positively and some call historic, is at risk, and is there something threatening it? What threatens it are the same problems that have always existed in the way of improving bilateral relations. We see that in the past whenever we saw some progress or the possibility of improvement, an uncalculated rhetoric quickly emerged that blocked any progress. We have seen this repeatedly. We saw it during the time of George H.W. Bush, Carter, or Khatami. These threats are always present. Because both sides have now entered unfamiliar territory, and because for thirty-six years they knew how to insult each other, but what they did not know was how to sit down and negotiate seriously and reach an agreement. And now they have entered an unfamiliar territory. Now, what will the situation of this unfamiliar territory you speak of be in the coming months with the end of Barack Obama's term and John Kerry leaving the State Department? This is a good question and everyone is asking it. Of course, we should not relate this approach and process too much to individuals; whether the president or the secretary of state is this person or that person. But the reality is that we saw that when John Kerry and Mohammad Javad Zarif were foreign ministers or when Mr. Obama was president, they created favorable conditions. But this issue must be outside the control or desire of an individual. Everyone knows that if the Republicans win in the November elections, predicting the situation will be very difficult because contradictory statements have been made and no one can predict the situation. Well, if we do not see this process as person-centered, do you think the situation, for example, in the Middle East necessitates that the nuclear agreement remains stable? This is correct. We see, for example, that Mrs. Clinton, eight years ago when she was running for president, criticized Obama's policy of engagement and improving relations a bit. But now she somewhat supports it. Personally, I think if the JCPOA lasts for another six months, it will gain momentum, and both sides will find it difficult to backtrack if they see it is in their interest. Of course, other conditions may arise. For example, if the Republicans win or another group wins in Iran's elections, it could completely change the situation. Do you think the JCPOA and the new conditions that Iran has gained after the JCPOA can help the Middle East region? It certainly helps. We cannot say that Iran and the U.S. have become friends or allies and are cooperating. But the issue of the JCPOA has proven one thing: that apart from confrontation, threats, and insults, there is another way, and that is that countries, despite their differences, can seriously and effectively talk to each other and act where they find common interests. This means there is another way, and utilizing that way will yield positive results for both sides.
Limbert: The JCPOA Will Not Solve All 36 Years of Problems Between Iran and the U.S.
John Limbert, a former U.S. diplomat, discusses the implications of the nuclear agreement (JCPOA) between Iran and the U.S., emphasizing that it won't resolve decades of issues immediately. He highlights the ongoing challenges in U.S.-Iran relations and the potential impact of upcoming political changes in the U.S. on the agreement's stability.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
John Limbert discusses the JCPOA's impact on U.S.-Iran relations, noting it won't resolve decades of issues immediately but is a step forward.
- The JCPOA was a result of direct negotiations between Iran and the U.S.
- Limbert emphasizes the persistent challenges in improving U.S.-Iran relations.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
The JCPOA, signed in 2015, aimed to limit Iran's nuclear capabilities in exchange for lifting economic sanctions.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%