With the repeated contradictory statistics and detachment from the realities of Iran's economy by Ebrahim Raisi and Mohammad Mokhber, media and experts criticized the 'illiteracy' of the President and the 'statistical manipulation' by the ministers. In this regard, the newspaper 'Ham-Mihan' wrote that incorrect figures are being provided to government leaders, and since Raisi and his first deputy 'know nothing about economics,' they accept those numbers. The author of this newspaper referred to Ebrahim Raisi's statements in South Khorasan, noting that while he announced the 'record-breaking' achievements of the thirteenth government, economic experts believe that 'settling a budget deficit of 480 trillion tomans through a logical and legal method is not feasible, and it is likely that incorrect or, better said, incomplete information has been provided to the President.' A faculty member of Imam Sadiq University also criticized the contradictions of government officials, stating that Raisi and the government, having made promises initially and failing to fulfill them, 'are forced to showcase a positive record in various ways.' Kamran Nadri emphasized that these methods have also been employed by previous governments, and unfortunately, past administrations have not been better than the current one. Economic expert Ali Saadouni pointed out the 'incorrect statistics' provided to Ebrahim Raisi, stating that the President should hold accountable those who 'present such reports.' Saadouni stressed that the government's major problem is that it lacks a 'strategist economist' and that 'unfortunately, Mr. Ebrahim Raisi and his first deputy have no expertise in economics, and therefore when incorrect reports are given to them, they cannot properly discern them.' Criticism of the government intensified from Thursday, September 7, as Ebrahim Raisi claimed to compensate for the 480 trillion toman budget deficit without printing money or borrowing from the Central Bank. Voice of America, on September 7, validated Raisi's claims by looking at a report from the Research Center of the Islamic Consultative Assembly, showing that the total debts of the government and state-owned companies at the end of the year 1401 had increased by 61% compared to the end of Shahrivar 1400. During this period, the debts of securities also grew by 42%. Additionally, a review of new reports from the Central Bank of the Islamic Republic of Iran showed that during Raisi's government, borrowing by state-owned companies from the Central Bank increased by about 60%, and borrowing from the entire banking system increased by over 77%. Ebrahim Raisi also claimed that in the past two years, the average inflation rate of food items in European countries was 19%, and in neighboring countries, it was between 28% and 29%. This claim comes despite the fact that the inflation rate in the Eurozone, after reaching a record 10.6% in October 2022, has been on a downward trend, and with measures taken in the economic sector, the inflation rate has dropped to single digits in 19 Eurozone member countries, except for Slovakia, where it remains above 10%. According to the International Monetary Fund, inflation in Iraq, the UAE, Bahrain, Qatar, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia is expected to be less than 5% in 2023. Meanwhile, Egypt is experiencing 12% inflation, and Yemen is at 17%. In contrast, inflation predictions for Turkey are at 51%, and for Iran, above 45%. Last year, on Bahman 12, some domestic Iranian media verified the statistics presented by Ebrahim Raisi just hours after his statements on the Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting and announced that the President had fallen into the trap of 'illiteracy and the opportunism of his surroundings' and continues to present 'bulk statistics.'
Media Criticism of the President's 'Illiteracy'; Raisi and Mokhber 'Know Nothing About Economics'
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi and his deputy face criticism for their lack of economic knowledge and reliance on incorrect statistics, leading to public distrust. Experts argue that the government is attempting to cover up its failures by presenting misleading data. This situation highlights ongoing economic challenges in Iran and raises concerns about governance.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi and his deputy face severe criticism for their economic illiteracy and reliance on misleading statistics, leading to public distrust and concerns about governance. Experts argue that the government is attempting to mask its failures by presenting inaccurate data.
- Raisi claimed to address a 480 trillion toman budget deficit without borrowing, despite evidence of increasing government debt.
- Critics highlight that Raisi and Mokhber lack economic expertise, leading to reliance on incorrect statistics.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran has been facing severe economic challenges, including high inflation and budget deficits, exacerbated by international sanctions and mismanagement. The current government has struggled to deliver on economic promises, leading to widespread dissatisfaction.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%