According to Iranian media, 4,390 people from 11 different provinces in Iran responded to questions from interviewers in December regarding their preferred type of hijab. It seems that the interviewers preferred to ask this question mostly to men, with 51% of respondents being male and 49% female. The youngest respondent was 18 years old and the oldest was 80, with 60% of respondents having a diploma or lower education. In a conversation with Hossein Ghazian, a sociologist residing in the U.S., we discussed the details of this survey. Mr. Ghazian, does this survey have the characteristics of a scientific survey? In fact, complete information has not been provided in this research, but considering the sampling method and the information available, the characteristics of the sample provided and the institution conducting this survey—which is relatively reputable—it seems that this survey is not far from scientific research. Mr. Ghazian, throughout the years following the Islamic Revolution, women's clothing has been one of the contentious issues between women and the authorities of the Islamic Republic. Have similar surveys been conducted in Iran over these years? Is there a significant difference or similarity between them? This is the first time I have encountered a survey of this nature, at this level, directly about hijab. Other work done has been small-scale and with very limited samples. However, this case is a national sample. The sample size is large, and specific questions regarding types of clothing have been asked. Therefore, from this perspective, it can be said that the sample is unique. We conducted another study on mandatory and optional hijab in Iran, which has some similarities with this research. There, 42% of people, meaning most people, wanted to observe hijab 'optionally,' while only 38% believed that since hijab is a religious obligation, it should be accepted. This survey also showed that when the level of human development in a region is higher, the desire for optional hijab increases, and a higher level of education correlates with a greater desire for optional hijab. Additionally, as age increases, there is a greater tendency to adhere to mandatory hijab, just like the relationship seen in this survey. According to reports published about this survey, graphic images were shown to respondents depicting women in nine different types of clothing, from chador and headscarf to short manteaus with leggings and buttonless manteaus with leggings. However, overall, only 46% of respondents showed a preference for the chador. Mr. Ghazian, let me ask a recurring question: why, 37 years after the Islamic Revolution, and despite all the propaganda and threats, has the Islamic Republic been unable to convince everyone to accept the chador as the superior hijab? Note that research can be interpreted in different ways. Those who published this research at the Jihad University, namely in ISPA, presented it differently. Their emphasis is on those who prefer to wear hijab, thus they used the figure of 45% for those who wear chador and 46% for those who prefer chador. However, this can also be read in reverse. It can be said that while 46% prefer chador, it means that 54% do not wish to wear chador. But why they have not succeeded so far seems quite clear to me. The inclination towards hijab is not something that can be instilled through commands, orders, beatings, and patrols. Many individuals choose to wear chador not due to government demand, but because of their lifestyle, the traditions they live in, and the consequences of not adhering to those traditions. As you also pointed out, one of the notable factors is education. Based on the results published in this survey, 43% of individuals with a diploma or lower, 40% of men with academic education, and only 28% of women with academic education showed a preference for chador. Do social evidence also confirm this relationship between education and choice of clothing? Not only social evidence but all of us may have seen this through personal observation, and other research also confirms this issue. In fact, there are three elements that usually influence and change traditional values. If we consider the inclination towards chador as a desire for this traditional value, these three factors play a role here. Generally, with increasing urbanization and higher levels of education, the inclination towards these traditional values, including the desire for chador, decreases, while with increasing age, this inclination increases. This means younger individuals generally have less desire for hijab, as do those living in more urban areas or those with higher education levels. These three factors have been largely confirmed in other research. However, the relationship between education level and type of clothing does not relate to the content of education an individual receives in university. For example, someone who enters university and studies chemistry is not taught anything about hijab that would affect their values. However, entering university, separating from family, and stepping out of the protective and controlling circle of family creates a freer environment and more opportunities for choice, which may lead them to question their past values, thus creating a wave in society with the advancement of education and urbanization that cannot resist the governmental demand for superior hijab. One notable point in the published survey is that overall, 49% of men and 43% of women prefer chador. Why do men, who face far fewer clothing restrictions than women in Iran, prefer chador for women? Yes, I think this is a subtle point. Not only do men prefer chador more than women, but married individuals prefer it more than singles. If we analyze this issue, we actually confront the fundamental issue of honor and ownership of women's bodies in patriarchal culture and society. Because in patriarchal culture and society, no matter how weakened it may be, a woman's body is part of a man's property. This man can be a brother, father, or husband. However, in any case, the woman is part of his property. Therefore, when a person gets married, they feel a sense of ownership over themselves and do not want their ownership to be exposed to the harm or access of others, believing that hijab is something that protects their property. Like a fence you build around your land to keep it safe from intrusion. You also see in daily life many young men who may have relationships with multiple girls. But when it comes to marriage, they look for a girl who is considered innocent and untouched. That is, when someone is to become 'owned,' a fence is necessary to protect her, and in Iranian society, one of the symbols of this ownership is the choice of chador. As reported by the media, more details about this research are expected to be published in the future. With the release of more details, we will revisit this topic. My question, however, remains: what is your opinion on the common clothing in Iran, and what type of clothing do you think Iranian women should choose?
Survey: 54% of People Do Not Consider Hijab as Chador
A recent survey in Iran revealed that 54% of respondents do not consider the chador as their preferred hijab. The survey, conducted among 4,390 people, highlighted significant differences in preferences based on education and age, indicating a trend towards optional hijab. This reflects ongoing tensions between traditional values and modern perspectives in Iranian society.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
A survey conducted in Iran revealed that 54% of respondents do not prefer the chador as their hijab choice, indicating a shift towards more modern clothing preferences. The survey also highlighted the influence of education and age on these preferences.
- The survey included 4,390 respondents from 11 provinces.
- 46% of respondents preferred the chador, while 54% did not.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Since the Islamic Revolution in 1979, the hijab has been a contentious issue in Iran, symbolizing the clash between traditional values and modernity. This survey is one of the first large-scale studies to explore public opinion on hijab preferences.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%