The 44th International Rotterdam Film Festival, one of the most recognized film festivals in Europe, which aims to introduce new faces in cinema worldwide, opened on Wednesday night with the film "The Book of War" directed by Tom Harper; a loud film about nuclear war in the world. This British film narrates a fictional situation where nuclear war is escalating globally. The British Prime Minister holds meetings with several advisors and officials over three days, each time discussing and voting on how Britain should respond to the nuclear war. The film sees the start of nuclear war in a conflict between Pakistan and India: during these three days, Pakistan destroys one of India's cities with a nuclear bomb, and soon India retaliates with a nuclear response. The U.S. supports India, and China targets its nuclear missiles at India and the U.S. Russia enters the scene a bit later, and at the tables in this room in Britain, the Prime Minister and his companions must decide whether Britain will join the U.S. in using nuclear weapons. Meanwhile, Iran plays a small role and is mentioned several times throughout the film. In the film's fictional narrative, Iran is the first country to support Pakistan and soon finds itself opposing the U.S. The film begins with a brief historical overview of nuclear weapons: we see a map of the world alongside a review of the years since World War II to the present; initially, only a few countries had nuclear weapons, but red circles on the map increase year by year, showing how the number of these countries and their nuclear weapons has grown. The meeting starts in a room, marking the beginning of a marathon of very long dialogues, some of which are beautifully written, but the camera's confinement in this room and the mere display of a few faces constantly providing statistics and reports—who quickly become repetitive—soon tires the viewer. In fact, the film has only an intriguing initial idea: every viewer wants to know what would happen to the world in the event of a nuclear war. A large part of the dialogues summarizes information for the viewer: for example, how many nuclear weapons each country has and how grocery stores are looted, and what governments demand from their people in such situations. For this reason, the film could have taken on a documentary form, but the filmmaker uses all his efforts in a blatant contradiction to tell us that he is imagining, and these people are 'playing' and each has accepted a role in this game. On the other hand, the film has only one scene outside this room, the purpose of which is unclear. If the filmmaker intends to choose a challenge for filmmaking in a room, taking the camera outside does not justify itself, just as this external scene (dialogue between two characters in the yard) adds nothing to the plot and can easily be omitted. However, the challenge of confining characters and the viewer inside the room is not a successful challenge for Tom Harper. His camera quickly loses its way and must move unnecessarily to avoid making the scenes boring. These movements do not fit within the film's atmosphere and rather add to the film's tediousness. Ultimately, the film summarizes all its concerns in the last moments of the third day: the discussion about whether nuclear weapons produced from taxpayers' money, under the pretext that they are only for deterrence, should now be used in a day of need? The film provides a bitter answer to this question.
The Book of War: A Fictional Nuclear War and Iran's Marginal Role
The film 'The Book of War' opened the Rotterdam Film Festival, depicting a fictional nuclear conflict involving Pakistan and India, with Britain deciding its stance. Iran is portrayed as a supporter of Pakistan, highlighting its marginal role in global nuclear politics. This film raises questions about the implications of nuclear deterrence and the responsibilities of nations.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
The film 'The Book of War' premiered at the Rotterdam Film Festival, depicting a fictional nuclear conflict between Pakistan and India, with Britain deliberating its response and Iran supporting Pakistan. The film explores themes of nuclear deterrence and the responsibilities of nations.
- The film features a fictional escalation of nuclear war starting from a conflict between Pakistan and India.
- Iran is depicted as a minor player, supporting Pakistan against the U.S. and its allies.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Nuclear proliferation remains a critical global issue, with various countries, including Iran, involved in complex geopolitical relationships.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%