Also available in Persian — نسخه فارسی ✈️ Telegram EN فا
❓ Unknown

The Islamic Republic: Forty Years of Economic Struggle, With and Without Sanctions!

Jan 24, 2026 January 24, 2026 11 min read 📰 Radio Farda
📋 Key Takeaway

The article critiques the Iranian economy's persistent disarray since the Islamic Revolution, attributing it to systemic issues rather than external sanctions. It argues that the Velayati system has failed to create a conducive business environment, leading to declining economic freedom and increased poverty.

🔍 Quick Context Guide
💡 Bottom Line: The article underscores that Iran's economic challenges are rooted in its governance model rather than solely in external pressures.

👥 Key Players

Velayati System MENTIONED
Iran's governing economic framework
"The Velayati system shapes Iran's economic policies and has been criticized for its failure to foster a free market and support economic growth."
Heritage Foundation MENTIONED
Research organization providing economic analysis
"Their Economic Freedom Index serves as a benchmark for assessing Iran's economic environment compared to global standards."

📰 What Happened

The article discusses the ongoing economic struggles in Iran since the Islamic Revolution, attributing these issues to systemic failures rather than external sanctions. It highlights the detrimental impact of the Velayati system on economic freedom and citizen prosperity.

  • Iran's economic freedom has consistently declined according to global reports.
  • The Velayati system has perpetuated an environment that favors government control over market-based initiatives.

💡 Why It Matters

🇮🇷 For Iran: The economic struggles highlighted in the article affect the daily lives of Iranians, contributing to poverty and social unrest.
🌍 Regional: Economic instability in Iran can have ripple effects on neighboring countries, influencing regional security and economic conditions.
🌐 International: The findings challenge the narrative that sanctions are the primary cause of Iran's economic woes, suggesting deeper systemic issues that may affect international negotiations.

📚 Background

Since the Islamic Revolution in 1979, Iran has faced significant economic challenges, exacerbated by both internal policies and international sanctions. Understanding the Velayati system is key to grasping the complexities of Iran's economic landscape.

Economic Freedom Index Impact of Sanctions on National Economies
📡 Source: NEUTRAL
📊 Confidence: 70%
The article presents a critical analysis based on established economic metrics, making it a valuable resource for understanding Iran's economic situation.

The Iranian economy has been disordered and broken since the victory of the Islamic Revolution until today, both with and without sanctions. The Velayati system not only failed to create a suitable environment for business and production but also, by empowering rent-seekers and government enterprises, eliminated what little was left. It was within this Velayati system that most large national enterprises that existed before the revolution were destroyed, and the largest oil revenues in Iran's history were lost without any achievements. The unsuitable economic-rent environment is not a result of the extremism or incompetence of any particular president. No government within the Velayati system has freed the Iranian economy from paying tribute to government rent-seekers or prepared conditions for business and civil society. All credible global reports, such as the World Economic Freedom [1], Economic Freedom Index [2], and Ease of Doing Business [3], point to the disordered environment of the system for the economic activities of Iranian citizens. This disordered environment is not a result of sanctions and the hostility of the global community towards Iran, but rather stems more than anything from the official viewpoint of the Velayati system, which, due to its opposition to 'capitalism', does not tolerate the freedom of citizens' trade in a market-based economy. The Islamic-Iranian economic model favored by the regime's leaders does not align with global indicators and continues to seek the supremacy of the state and government in the economy [4]. This is why Iran's ranking in economic freedom reports has always been declining. Economic freedom refers to an environment where property rights are upheld so that every individual can benefit from opportunities legally and without discrimination, using initiative, entrepreneurship, and competence to increase their purchasing power and wealth. The role of the government in a market-based economy is to remove obstacles from the paths of citizens' trade and only intervene to establish and maintain the freedom of all. The government is the guardian of freedom surrounding the work and profession in which citizens can work, invest, produce, and consume as they wish. Individual freedom is indivisible, and one cannot take away economic freedom from someone on the condition of political freedom, or vice versa. Economic freedom is a fundamental right of every individual to benefit from work and property. The consequence of economic freedom is not only material well-being but also the empowerment and flourishing of other freedoms of citizens. Economic freedom is a condition for the lasting well-being of the people. All other economic options, such as socialism, non-capitalist growth paths, self-sufficiency, and others, have been tried, but none have achieved results comparable to a market-based economy in optimal resource distribution, innovation, and citizen well-being. The less economic freedom there is in a country, the more poverty and misfortune its people experience. In this writing, we will focus on this economic freedom in the Velayati system, both before and after the sanctions. Our benchmark is the 'Economic Freedom Index' report published annually by the Heritage Foundation. To prepare this report, the Heritage Foundation collects data from various sources and analyzes it. Since the first 'Economic Freedom Index' report in 1995 until now, the Heritage Foundation has revised it multiple times based on experiences and data. The latest edition of this report is based on 12 indicators, each evaluated between zero (unfree) and one hundred (free). These 12 indicators are categorized into four groups: rule of law, size of government, regulatory efficiency, and open markets, which, from the Heritage Foundation's perspective, are the four foundational pillars of economic freedom. The unsuitable economic-rent environment is not a result of the extremism or incompetence of any particular president. No government within the Velayati system has freed the Iranian economy from paying tribute to government rent-seekers or prepared conditions for business and civil society. All credible global reports, such as the World Economic Freedom [1], Economic Freedom Index [2], and Ease of Doing Business [3], point to the disordered environment of the system for the economic activities of Iranian citizens. This disordered environment is not a result of sanctions and the hostility of the global community towards Iran, but rather stems more than anything from the official viewpoint of the Velayati system, which, due to its opposition to 'capitalism', does not tolerate the freedom of citizens' trade in a market-based economy. The Islamic-Iranian economic model favored by the regime's leaders does not align with global indicators and continues to seek the supremacy of the state and government in the economy [4]. This is why Iran's ranking in economic freedom reports has always been declining. Economic freedom refers to an environment where property rights are upheld so that every individual can benefit from opportunities legally and without discrimination, using initiative, entrepreneurship, and competence to increase their purchasing power and wealth. The role of the government in a market-based economy is to remove obstacles from the paths of citizens' trade and only intervene to establish and maintain the freedom of all. The government is the guardian of freedom surrounding the work and profession in which citizens can work, invest, produce, and consume as they wish. Individual freedom is indivisible, and one cannot take away economic freedom from someone on the condition of political freedom, or vice versa. Economic freedom is a fundamental right of every individual to benefit from work and property. The consequence of economic freedom is not only material well-being but also the empowerment and flourishing of other freedoms of citizens. Economic freedom is a condition for the lasting well-being of the people. All other economic options, such as socialism, non-capitalist growth paths, self-sufficiency, and others, have been tried, but none have achieved results comparable to a market-based economy in optimal resource distribution, innovation, and citizen well-being. The less economic freedom there is in a country, the more poverty and misfortune its people experience. In this writing, we will focus on this economic freedom in the Velayati system, both before and after the sanctions. Our benchmark is the 'Economic Freedom Index' report published annually by the Heritage Foundation. To prepare this report, the Heritage Foundation collects data from various sources and analyzes it. Since the first 'Economic Freedom Index' report in 1995 until now, the Heritage Foundation has revised it multiple times based on experiences and data. The latest edition of this report is based on 12 indicators, each evaluated between zero (unfree) and one hundred (free). These 12 indicators are categorized into four groups: rule of law, size of government, regulatory efficiency, and open markets, which, from the Heritage Foundation's perspective, are the four foundational pillars of economic freedom. What follows is a comparison of the business environment in the Velayati system with the global and regional averages based on the same four foundational pillars of economic freedom of the Heritage Foundation and its 12 constructs. Unfortunately, it must be said that Iran's economic freedom under the Velayati government lags behind not only the global average but even the regional average. 1. 'Rule of Law'; The initiative and efforts of citizens have always yielded more results than government-controlled economies, but without the support of a just legal system, citizens have no guarantee of benefiting from their work and efforts. The more the law supports the property and activities of the private sector, the more citizens will invest their capital with enthusiasm and diligence, thereby increasing the production and wealth of the country. 'Rule of Law' is based on 'property rights' [5], government integrity [6], and judicial efficiency [7]. 'Property Rights' are the cornerstone of economic freedom. When the government supports it with clear laws, citizens will gather their scattered assets with confidence and freely engage in economic activities. 'Property Rights' also assess the likelihood of expropriation and confiscation of private property by the government as a negative factor. 1. 'Rule of Law'; The initiative and efforts of citizens have always yielded more results than government-controlled economies, but without the support of a just legal system, citizens have no guarantee of benefiting from their work and efforts. The more the law supports the property and activities of the private sector, the more citizens will invest their capital with enthusiasm and diligence, thereby increasing the production and wealth of the country. 'Rule of Law' is based on 'property rights' [5], government integrity [6], and judicial efficiency [7]. 'Property Rights' are the cornerstone of economic freedom. When the government supports it with clear laws, citizens will gather their scattered assets with confidence and freely engage in economic activities. 'Property Rights' also assess the likelihood of expropriation and confiscation of private property by the government as a negative factor. 'Government Integrity' refers to the integrity and especially the absence of corruption in the bureaucracy and includes factors such as public trust in politicians, irregular payments and bribes, transparency in government policymaking, absence of corruption, perceptions of corruption, and civil service transparency. The more entrenched corruption is in government institutions, meaning if bureaucratic decision-making is influenced by payments such as bribery, extortion, nepotism, cronyism, patronage, embezzlement, and graft, the cost of labor and production for entrepreneurs and employers increases, thereby harming and potentially destroying economic dynamism. The more entrenched corruption is in government institutions, meaning if bureaucratic decision-making is influenced by payments such as bribery, extortion, nepotism, cronyism, patronage, embezzlement, and graft, the cost of labor and production for entrepreneurs and employers increases, thereby harming and potentially destroying economic dynamism. 'Judicial Efficiency' is the third construct of 'Rule of Law' and refers to a judicial system that protects citizens' rights even against the government and powerful groups. 'Judicial Efficiency' depends on judicial independence, the quality of the judicial process, and the likelihood of obtaining favorable judicial decisions. 2. 'Size of Government'. 'Size of Government' is another foundational pillar of economic freedom that indicates the extent of the field remaining for civil society's economic activities. The larger the government's share, the smaller the private sector's share. Because the government has power, it does not submit to free competition and monopolizes economic privileges through its arbitrary laws, thereby harming national production, jobs, and citizens' purchasing power. The Heritage Foundation measures the size of government by government spending, tax burden, and fiscal health. In all three cases, the record of the Islamic Republic is poor. 'Government Spending' refers to expenditures that indicate the size and intervention of the government. Not all government expenditures equally harm economic freedom. Some expenditures that the government makes for infrastructure, research, and the advancement of human capital (education and health) for citizens, especially the vulnerable, are considered investments. From the perspective of a market-based economy, acceptable government spending is that which is used to protect property, work, trade, and free competition among citizens and to prevent monopolies and rent-seeking by the powerful. Government spending, whatever it is for, must be financed, and for example, taxes must be collected from citizens. However, taxes come with an opportunity cost. That is, the more taxes citizens pay, the less they can consume or invest, which significantly harms the national economy. If government spending is financed by loans instead of taxes, government debt increases, and the burden of repayment falls on future generations. In any case, it should be noted that even if increased government spending accelerates economic growth, such growth is short-lived, and in the long term, government intervention, devoid of market-based economic logic, leads to bureaucracy, reduced productivity, misallocation of resources, and the destruction of the private sector's incentive to invest. The Heritage Foundation measures the size of government by government spending, tax burden, and fiscal health. In all three cases, the record of the Islamic Republic is poor. 'Government Spending' refers to expenditures that indicate the size and intervention of the government. Not all government expenditures equally harm economic freedom. Some expenditures that the government makes for infrastructure, research, and the advancement of human capital (education and health) for citizens, especially the vulnerable, are considered investments. From the perspective of a market-based economy, acceptable government spending is that which is used to protect property, work, trade, and free competition among citizens and to prevent monopolies and rent-seeking by the powerful. Government spending, whatever it is for, must be financed, and for example, taxes must be collected from citizens. However, taxes come with an opportunity cost. That is, the more taxes citizens pay, the less they can consume or invest, which significantly harms the national economy. If government spending is financed by loans instead of taxes, government debt increases, and the burden of repayment falls on future generations. In any case, it should be noted that even if increased government spending accelerates economic growth, such growth is short-lived, and in the long term, government intervention, devoid of market-based economic logic, leads to bureaucracy, reduced productivity, misallocation of resources, and the destruction of the private sector's incentive to invest.

🌐

Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →

Translation confidence: 85%

📰 Related Coverage

⚖️ Independent Platform — Artesh.com is not affiliated with any government, military, or political organization. Editorial Policy →