Jalil Roshandel, a political science professor in the United States, examined the 'political spectrum' and the idea of 'change and transformation' as prerequisites for democracy in the first part. In the second part, he discusses the confrontation of the political spectrum with social changes. This series of discussions will continue to be presented to Radio Farda readers every two weeks in the thought section. Political changes are usually among the problematic categories of social life. The perception and behavior of an individual towards political change and transformation is related to that individual's position on the political linear spectrum. One must first look at the direction of change in society and measure its direction against the individual's position to evaluate or calculate the individual's stance towards that change. One of the questions that arises here is whether the direction of that change is 'progressive' or 'regressive'? Will it advance society or take it backward? Will the impending change cause a shift in social classes and political-economic relations in society and transform the infrastructures, or will it merely have an external and formal aspect? Intellectuals, thinkers, and even many ordinary people in any society can recognize the direction of a movement that begins with the slogan of change from their own perspective or feel its direction. In open and pluralistic societies, in other words, democratic ones, efforts to constrain and limit change and transformation through the application of force and the use of state power do not occur. However, in closed societies, where change usually means a threat to the ruling class, no effort will be spared to block a movement that could lead to fundamental changes. In this context, the possibility of opportunism, deception, and exploitation always exists. Therefore, individuals must be cautious and vigilant that regressive goals are not hidden behind a layer of attractive and vibrant colors. Regressive political regimes usually conceal their goals behind various tactics and use the emotions or beliefs of the general public to buy the agreement and support of society or obtain it through intimidation to resist change, ultimately portraying the essence of change as a negative factor or a means of overthrowing the regime. On the other hand, the wave of change and transformation, when moving forward, is not necessarily a bad or good thing; it is merely a movement that seeks to replace the 'status quo' with something different and often unfamiliar. This very fact causes 'change' to be equated with 'threat' and to face the prejudice and resistance of the right-wing. Regressive regimes usually conceal their goals behind various tactics and use the emotions or beliefs of the general public to buy the agreement and support of society or obtain it through intimidation to resist change, ultimately portraying the essence of change as a negative factor or a means of overthrowing the regime. Regressive change is an effort to return the status quo to its previous direction or to re-establish a policy and institution that previously existed and aligns with the current ruling policies, even if it has not left a positive impact in the minds and memories of the people. If there is no clear horizon and alternative, changing the existing situation back to the previous state will face resistance from the people. Rapid change, even if progressive, usually faces opposition from both sides: one group desires the status quo, and another group, due to the lack of tangible, objective reasons, does not want to change the existing situation; both resist change. In revolutionary conditions, both of these groups oppose the revolution because they either prefer the status quo over the transitional period of the revolution or do not understand the necessity of the final result of change and transformation. For example, one can look at the policy of unveiling during Reza Shah's time and the policy of returning to the era of compulsory hijab in the early years of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Both policies are considered rapid or revolutionary change policies. The unveiling at the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century is a change that has no historical precedent and seeks to change the existing situation without providing a tangible image of the desired state. The social infrastructures of the time (illiteracy, ignorance of world conditions, and the role of women in it) do not allow the logic of unveiling to be convincing for fifty percent of the country's population. Therefore, at least two factors come into play against that policy: first, the opposition of religious law and clergy (viewing it as a threat) and second, the lack of historical precedent for unveiling in the people's memory (the factor of concern about changing the existing situation). Most people had not experienced unveiling and could not compare the imposed situation. In contrast to this situation, at least two factors can be named in support of that policy: first, the alignment and simultaneity of this action with other actions aimed at advancing the country that did not have religious opposition and whose benefits were tangible. For example, the establishment of modern military, social, and cultural facilities alongside efforts to develop, create communication networks, schools, and civil facilities. Many of these actions provided opportunities for women's participation as half of the driving force and productive power of society. Second, the experiences and insights of those who had traveled abroad brought thoughts of freedom and progress alongside equality and gradually expanded it. Although this second factor was only effective in the capital and populous centers and border and port cities that were centers of communication and exchanges, not everywhere in the country, which was largely under the influence of the clergy. In this regard, elements associated with the reactionary and conservative class were on one side; moderates in the middle, and liberals and radicals on the other side of the unveiling policy. Of course, the numerical power of liberals and radicals was less than that of reactionaries and conservatives, and the small number of moderates did not change the balance in any direction. Ultimately, it was the pressure and state power that caused the unveiling policy to be enforced, and the role of the political spectrum in it was negligible. After the revolution, the conditions had completely reversed. The historical memory of the people did not regard the Qajar era and compulsory hijab as a period of greatness and glory for the women of the country. On the contrary, that era was recorded as a period of backwardness in all dimensions of Iranian life, especially for women. An era where women's roles were limited to the harem or as the second, third, and fourth wives of wealthy or lustful men. With the passage of three generations, families had risen from the floor of the room to sit at tables; and instead of candles and oil lamps, they benefited from electricity and gas as a second source of energy production. Mass communication tools, multilingual books and press, university education, and the possibility of scientific competition along with a sense of equality with men, roles in the armed and law enforcement forces, the right to vote, and determining political destiny, and many small and large privileges had been experienced; and all these factors had completely darkened and made the historical memory of the hijab undesirable. Of course, there were even individuals in the educated class of the country who easily accepted the hijab and had no problem with it. Conversely, with the passage of three generations, families had risen from the floor of the room to sit at tables; and instead of candles and oil lamps, they benefited from electricity and gas as a second source of energy production. Mass communication tools, multilingual books and press, university education, and the possibility of scientific competition along with a sense of equality with men, roles in the armed and law enforcement forces, the right to vote, and determining political destiny, and many small and large privileges had been experienced; and all these factors had completely darkened and made the historical memory of the hijab undesirable. Of course, there were even individuals in the educated class of the country who easily accepted the hijab and had no problem with it. This latter case raises a question regarding the political spectrum. Some may consider themselves conservative and not reactionary, but insist on a specific issue, such as supporting compulsory hijab in the years after the revolution, which is essentially an attempt to change the existing situation back to what was in the early century. The question is whether these individuals with this mindset are considered conservative or reactionary? The answer is that a conservative with this stance becomes reactionary. Such individuals may rightly consider themselves conservative, but ultimately, one may occupy different positions on the political spectrum at the same time, and only a few individuals maintain their absolute and rigid position on the spectrum without the possibility of change. Studies show that in practice, an individual may occupy two or three points on the political spectrum that are not necessarily aligned with each other. Individuals may sometimes feel strongly aligned with liberal values while at other times fundamentally disagree with liberal theories. In many marriages before the revolution, while the marriage took place in its Islamic form, the principle of receiving and paying the dowry had faded among many intellectuals. The amount of a woman's dowry was limited to zero or, symbolically, to a few branches of flowers, a piece of candy, and a copy of the Quran. Women were equal to men in many respects and had equal roles in the economic and cultural life of the family, and there was no longer a need to take the money for the milk that their mothers had fed them from the groom. If the husbands of women during the Qajar or early Pahlavi era were reluctant about unveiling, at the beginning of the revolution, they were completely opposed to returning to the era of hijab and chador. If after the revolution the slogan and action 'either hijab or beating' (resorting to violence) did not exist; if Mr. Banisadr had not remained silent in a clever response to a question posed by a young girl at one of his speeches about whether women's hair produces rays that attract men; if there were no advertisements and incitements from mosques and pulpits; if anti-compulsory hijab demonstrations were not suppressed; and if women had been given the natural right to choose, today there would have been neither this atmosphere of acid attacks nor a need for clandestine freedoms. In fact, the issue of hijab in Iran, like some other Islamic countries, would have become a non-governmental, non-political, and non-security issue that would have been best balanced by the women themselves, just as we see today in the multi-religious, multilingual, and multi-ethnic society of Lebanon, where Muslim women in hijab have the best social relations with non-hijab-wearing Muslim and non-Muslim women. At the same time, they live peacefully alongside and even under the protection of Hezbollah in Lebanon. In some cases, even non-hijab-wearing women support Hezbollah. The event that occurred in the political spectrum after the revolution was the isolation of liberals and radicals, while reactionaries, conservatives, and even part of the moderates collaborated and conspired using state repression and exploiting the existence of an external enemy (the Iraq war), and gradually the issue of hijab moved from a simple scarf to a superior hijab and chador, and in each stage, more and more women were driven out of public spaces. The event that occurred in the political spectrum after the revolution was the isolation of liberals and radicals, while reactionaries, conservatives, and even part of the moderates collaborated and conspired using state repression and exploiting the existence of an external enemy (the Iraq war), and gradually the issue of hijab moved from a simple scarf to a superior hijab and chador, and in each stage, more and more women were driven out of public spaces. Studying transformations in other social, cultural, and especially economic phenomena during this period shows how parts of the political spectrum, which could have established enduring democratic institutions, were shut down or temporarily halted and rendered ineffective under state pressure. In practice, the shutdown of democratic institutions and the chaining of active parts of the political spectrum in society led to the eradication of the middle class, which bore the burden of economic production and social management, in universities (culture) and in spontaneous economic centers. The direct result of these interventions was that security agents or individuals approved by security apparatuses replaced university professors, and the market turned from production and distribution into a black market for currency and distribution of low-quality imported goods. In such circumstances, the political spectrum, without undergoing formal changes, faces internal transformation and the migration of its constituent particles. Thus, the particles of the spectrum either become distorted out of fear of state power or through opportunism move from the left to the right because on the right, they enjoy a safer position and state support and can wait for a suitable opportunity to return to their political position. Of course, some individuals within the radical section also prefer to engage in revolutionary movement and struggle instead of protecting themselves. If we depict this internal distortion in the form of colors, the following diagram is obtained, with the direction from left to right. Of course, the closer we move towards moderates and liberals, the more density and gathering we will see. Regarding Iran in the 1970s and 1980s, part of this reincarnation resulted from the suppression of leftist elements, radicals, and liberals by state power, which forced them into silence through arrests, imprisonment, and comprehensive pressures.
The Political Spectrum's Confrontation with Social Changes
Jalil Roshandel discusses the political spectrum's response to social changes in Iran, emphasizing the tension between progressive and regressive movements. He highlights how political regimes manipulate public sentiment to resist change, drawing parallels between historical and contemporary issues like hijab policies. This analysis is crucial for understanding the dynamics of Iranian society and politics.
👥 Key Players
📰 What Happened
Jalil Roshandel discusses the interaction between political ideologies and social changes in Iran, focusing on how regimes resist or embrace change. He uses historical examples, such as hijab policies, to illustrate these dynamics.
- Political regimes often manipulate public sentiment to resist change.
- Historical examples, like hijab policies, highlight the tension between progressive and regressive movements.
💡 Why It Matters
📚 Background
Iran has a history of political and social transformation, often marked by tension between conservative and progressive forces. The hijab policy is a prominent example of these dynamics.
Translated from the original and edited for English readers. View original source →
Translation confidence: 85%